SUICIDE AND PUBLIC INTEREST IN THE SPANISH PRESS: ANALYSIS FROM THE CONSTITUTIONAL JURISPRUDENCE ON FREEDOM OF INFORMATION

被引:0
|
作者
Garcia-Fernandez, Diego [1 ]
del Cano, Ana Ma Marcos [1 ]
Topa, Gabriela [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Nacl Educ Distancia UNED, Madrid, Spain
来源
关键词
suicide; press; Spanish Constitution; public interest; freedom of information; Constitutional Court;
D O I
10.15198/seeci.2024.57.e894
中图分类号
G2 [信息与知识传播];
学科分类号
05 ; 0503 ;
摘要
Introduction: Every year, more than 700,000 people commit suicide worldwide, and in Spain, it has been the leading cause of external death since 2008. Although it is a public health problem, the press follows the general rule of not reporting on suicide for fear of generating a contagion or "Werther effect," reflecting society's silence on self-induced death. This constitutes a form of self-censorship against the freedom of information enshrined in Article 20.1.d) of the Spanish Constitution, which is only broken in specific and/or extreme cases, contributing to a distorted projection of suicide. Objective: The Spanish Constitutional Court points to public interest as a necessary requirement for news in the event of a potential conflict with other rights that limit the right to information. This article confronts suicide with this notion, analyzing whether press publications about suicide meet this legal public interest, not always equivalent to journalistic interest, making them legitimate in the face of the limits of freedom of information and the rule of silence. Methodology: The jurisprudence of the Spanish Constitutional Court regarding the public interest in information has been thoroughly reviewed, and this legal argument has been compared with a self-produced database of news about suicide published between 2013 and 2022. Results: Without expressly mentioning suicide, but not excluding it, the Constitutional Court does recognize the relevance of other matters that, by analogy, allow us to infer the general interest of self-induced death. Geographic bias, the notoriety of the person, or the potential impact on society, but never the satisfaction of others' curiosity, determine its public relevance, arguable against the limits of freedom of information. Discussion and Conclusions: Despite its abstract public interest, an examination of constitutional jurisprudence shows how well-founded each piece of information on suicide must be, especially when the protagonist is an anonymous citizen, to comply with the constitutional limit on freedom of information. Self-censorship has hindered the possibility of this public health problem being legitimately debated in public opinion.
引用
收藏
页数:34
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] From Journalistic Truth to the Constitutional concept of Accurate Journalism. Rethinking the required truth in the exercise of Press Freedom
    Azurmendi Adarraga, Ana
    COMUNICACION Y SOCIEDAD, 2005, 18 (02): : 9 - 48
  • [32] Compliance with the WHO guidelines on suicide reporting. Analysis of the Spanish digital press (2010-2017)
    Olivar de Julian, Francisco Javier
    Diaz-Campo, Jesus
    Segado-Boj, Francisco
    DOXA COMUNICACION, 2021, (32):
  • [33] Current Limitations on Political Participation and Freedom of Information in the Public Space in Spain. A Constitutional Reading of the Law 4/2015 on Protection of Public Safety
    Ridao Martin, Joan
    REVISTA ESPANOLA DE DERECHO CONSTITUCIONAL, 2016, 36 (107): : 187 - 217
  • [34] PUBLIC INTEREST AND PRIVATE INTEREST: AN ANALYSIS FROM THE COLONY TO THE PROCLAMATION OF THE REPUBLIC IN BRAZIL
    Raemy Rangel, Gabriel Dolabela
    REVISTA CIENTIFICA HERMES, 2015, 13 : 124 - 143
  • [35] Re-use of public sector information from the perspective of the Spanish public administration
    Arquero Aviles, Rosario
    Del Valle Gastaminza, Felix
    Ramos Simon, L. Fernando
    Botezan, Iuliana
    Mendo Carmona, Concepcion
    Sanchez Jimenez, Rodrigo
    Tejada Artigas, Carlos
    Cobo Serrano, Silvia
    Sala Jimenez, Andrea
    REVISTA ESPANOLA DE DOCUMENTACION CIENTIFICA, 2011, 34 (03): : 427 - 446
  • [36] About the services charts in Spanish public libraries: information analysis on copyright
    Carlos Fernandez-Molina, Juan
    Perez-Pulido, Margarita
    Luis Herrera-Morillas, Jose
    BIBLIOTECAS-ANALES DE INVESTIGACION, 2018, 14 (02): : 103 - 123
  • [37] FREEDOM OF THE PRESS OR PUBLIC-RELATIONS FOR CRIMINALS - CASE-REPORT FROM THE VIEWPOINT OF A JOURNALIST
    NIGGL, P
    KRIMINALISTIK, 1991, (07): : 497 - 499
  • [38] Content analysis of the information processing of Felipe VI proclamation ceremony in the Spanish general press: an approach from the framing theory
    Munoz Boda, Maria Soledad
    SCIRE-REPRESENTACION Y ORGANIZACION DEL CONOCIMIENTO, 2021, 27 (02): : 65 - 75
  • [39] Constitutional Convention versus Constitutional Amendment: Analysis over Irish Deja vu from the point of view of Spanish Constitutional reform
    Seijas Villadangos, Esther
    TEORIA Y REALIDAD CONSTITUCIONAL, 2012, 30 : 411 - 432
  • [40] EUTHANASIA, DIGNITY AND FREEDOM: FROM THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS' CASE LAW TO THE SPANISH CONSTITUTIONAL COURT'S
    Avila, Alonso Pino
    DERECHOS Y LIBERTADES, 2024, (51)