Whistle-blowing and morality

被引:47
|
作者
Bouville, Mathieu [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Inst Mat Res & Engn, Singapore 117602, Singapore
[2] Inst High Performance Comp, Singapore 117528, Singapore
关键词
business ethics; code of ethics; duty; engineering ethics; moral luck; moral obligation;
D O I
10.1007/s10551-007-9529-7
中图分类号
F [经济];
学科分类号
02 ;
摘要
Whistle-blowing is generally considered from the viewpoint of professional morality. Morality rejects the idea of choice and the interests of the professional as immoral. Yet the dreadful retaliations against the messengers of the truth make it necessary for morality to leave a way out of whistle-blowing. This is why it forges rights (sometimes called duties) to trump the duty to the public prescribed by professional codes. This serves to hide the obvious fact that whether to blow the whistle is indeed a choice, not a matter of objective duty. One should also notice that if it fails to achieve anything then blowing the whistle was the wrong decision (or maybe the right decision that nobody would want to make). There is nevertheless a tendency to judge it based on the motivation of the whistle blower. In a way, whistle blowers should strive to act like saints. Yet, it is logically impossible to hold both whistle-blowing as mandatory and whistle-blowers as heroes or saints. Moreover, this tends to value the great deeds of a few over the lives of the many, which is incompatible with the basic assumptions of morality. But consistency is not a main feature of professional morality.
引用
收藏
页码:579 / 585
页数:7
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] THE BIGGEST WHISTLE-BLOWING OF THEM ALL
    STONE, IF
    [J]. NATION, 1982, 234 (18) : 548 - 548
  • [42] Whistle-Blowing Systems and Legitimacy Theory: A Study of the Motivation to Implement Whistle-Blowing Systems in German Organizations
    Esther Pittroff
    [J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2014, 124 : 399 - 412
  • [43] Whistle-Blowing Systems and Legitimacy Theory: A Study of the Motivation to Implement Whistle-Blowing Systems in German Organizations
    Pittroff, Esther
    [J]. JOURNAL OF BUSINESS ETHICS, 2014, 124 (03) : 399 - 412
  • [44] Whistle-blowing in Organizations: Retrospect and Prospect
    Wang, Shuliang
    Zhou, Hanming
    Wen, Peng
    [J]. 2014 2ND INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON ECONOMIC, BUSINESS MANAGEMENT AND EDUCATION INNOVATION (EBMEI 2014), VOL 39, 2014, 39 : 260 - 268
  • [45] Is Whistle-blowing Compatible with Employee Loyalty?
    Jukka Varelius
    [J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2009, 85 : 263 - 275
  • [46] ORGANIZATIONAL DISSIDENCE - THE CASE OF WHISTLE-BLOWING
    NEAR, JP
    MICELI, MP
    [J]. JOURNAL OF BUSINESS ETHICS, 1985, 4 (01) : 1 - 16
  • [47] The influence of dispositional affect on whistle-blowing
    Reckers-Sauciuc, Ashley K.
    Lowe, D. Jordan
    [J]. ADVANCES IN ACCOUNTING, 2010, 26 (02) : 259 - 269
  • [48] Title IX Whistle-Blowing Is Protected
    Epstein, Adam
    Pittman, Andrew T.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL EDUCATION RECREATION AND DANCE, 2005, 76 (06): : 6 - +
  • [49] WHISTLE-BLOWING BY NURSES - A MATTER OF ETHICS
    FRY, ST
    [J]. NURSING OUTLOOK, 1989, 37 (01) : 56 - 56
  • [50] The Consequences of Whistle-blowing: An Integrative Review
    Lim, Charmaine R.
    Zhang, Melvyn W. B.
    Hussain, Syeda F.
    Ho, Roger C. M.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF PATIENT SAFETY, 2021, 17 (06) : e497 - e502