Participatory Frustration: The Unintended Cultural Effect of Local Democratic Innovations

被引：21

作者：

Luis Fernandez-Martinez, Jose ^{[1
,2
]}

Garcia-Espin, Patricia ^{[1
]}

Jimenez-Sanchez, Manuel ^{[3
]}

机构：

[1] CSIC, Inst Estudios Sociales Avanzados, Cordoba, Spain

[2] Univ Granada, Granada, Spain

[3] Univ Pablo de Olavide, Sociol, Seville, Spain

来源：

ADMINISTRATION & SOCIETY | 2020年 / 52卷 / 05期

关键词：

participatory processes; local politics; participatory budgeting; advisory councils; civil society; frustration; REPRESENTATION; GOVERNANCE; INCLUSION;

D O I：

10.1177/0095399719833628

中图分类号：

C93 [管理学]; D035 [国家行政管理]; D523 [行政管理]; D63 [国家行政管理];

学科分类号：

12 ; 1201 ; 1202 ; 120202 ; 1204 ; 120401 ;

摘要：

Most research on participatory processes has stressed the positive effects that these institutions have in the relationships between public authorities and civil society. This article analyzes a more negative product that has received scant attention: participatory frustration. Departing from Hirschman's cycles of involvement and detachment, the article shows four paths toward frustration after engaging in institutional participatory processes: (a) inflated expectations, (b) the failure of design and adjusting mechanisms, (c) poor results, and (d) abrupt discontinuations. Drawing on six cases in Spanish cities, this article proposes a reflection on how participatory reforms can contribute to feed frustration and political disenchantment.

引用

页码：718 / 748

页数：31

共 46 条

[21] Effect of participatory dissemination of fodder innovations in mango orchards of livestock farmers on fodder availability
Biradar, Nagaratna
Kulkarni, Narendra
Kumar, Vinod
RANGE MANAGEMENT AND AGROFORESTRY, 2019, 40 (01) : 156 - 161
[22] Institutions and Cultural Diversity: Effects of Democratic and Propaganda Processes on Local Convergence and Global Diversity
Ulloa, Roberto
Kacperski, Celina
Sancho, Fernando
PLOS ONE, 2016, 11 (04):
[23] Citizen experts in participatory governance: Democratic and epistemic assets of service user involvement, local knowledge and citizen science
Krick, Eva
CURRENT SOCIOLOGY, 2022, 70 (07) : 994 - 1012
[24] The democratic city as field, system and power of social and cultural integration: new challenges for local governments
Belkis, Cartay
PROVINCIA, 2007, (18): : 81 - 95
[25] Natural and Cultural Resources as a 'Vehicle' for Paving Alternative Local Tourist Development Paths: A Participatory Methodological Framework
Panagiotopoulou, M.
Stratigea, A.
CULTURAL TOURISM IN A DIGITAL ERA, 2015, : 397 - 417
[26] In Search of Participatory Sustainable Cultural Paths at the Local Level-The Case of Kissamos Province-Crete
Panagiotopoulou, Maria
Somarakis, Giorgos
Stratigea, Anastasia
Katsoni, Vicky
TOURISM, CULTURE AND HERITAGE IN A SMART ECONOMY, 2017, : 339 - 363
[27] Participatory approaches, local stakeholders and cultural relevance facilitate an impactful community-based project in Uganda
O'Donovan, James
Thompson, Andrew
Stiles, Christina
Opintan, Japheth A.
Kabali, Ken
Willis, Ian
Mutimba, Mwebe Edward
Nalweyiso, Elizabeth
Mugabi, Henry
Kateete, David P.
Ameniko, Matthew
Govina, George
Weberman, Rachel
O'Neil, Edward, Jr.
Winters, Niall
Mutreja, Ankur
HEALTH PROMOTION INTERNATIONAL, 2020, 35 (06) : 1353 - 1368
[28] Local Adaptation and Unintended Coastal Vulnerability: The Effect of Beach Nourishment on Residential Development in North Carolina
Li, Xiaoyu
Gopalakrishnan, Sathya
Klaiber, H. Allen
JOURNAL OF THE ASSOCIATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL AND RESOURCE ECONOMISTS, 2024, 11 (03) : 523 - 548
[29] ENHANCING LOCAL-LEVEL DEMOCRATIC PROCESSES WITHIN A HYBRID REGIME: INSIGHTS INTO PARTICIPATORY BUDGETING FROM JÓZSEFVÁROS, BUDAPEST
Gosztonyi, Marton
CORVINUS JOURNAL OF SOCIOLOGY AND SOCIAL POLICY, 2024, 15 (01)
[30] The effect of cultural factors, networks of voluntary associations, and democratic institutions on economic development - An international comparison
Kunz, V
KOLNER ZEITSCHRIFT FUR SOZIOLOGIE UND SOZIALPSYCHOLOGIE, 2000, 52 (02): : 195 - +

← 1 2 3 4 5 →