Genetic ancestry testing among white nationalists: From identity repair to citizen science

被引:74
|
作者
Panofsky, Aaron [1 ]
Donovan, Joan [2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Calif Los Angeles, Inst Soc & Genet, 621 Charles E Young Dr South,Box 957221,3360 LSB, Los Angeles, CA 90095 USA
[2] Harvard Univ, John F Kennedy Sch Govt, Cambridge, MA 02138 USA
基金
美国国家科学基金会; 美国国家卫生研究院;
关键词
genetic ancestry testing; identity; lay expertise; race and racism; white nationalism; white supremacy; DNA; ME;
D O I
10.1177/0306312719861434
中图分类号
N09 [自然科学史]; B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ; 010108 ; 060207 ; 060305 ; 0712 ;
摘要
White nationalists have a genetic essentialist understanding of racial identity, so what happens when using genetic ancestry tests (GATs) to explore personal identities, they receive upsetting results they consider evidence of non-white or non-European ancestry? Our answer draws on qualitative analysis of posts on the white nationalist website Stormfront, interpreted by synthesizing the literatures on white nationalism and GATs and identity. We show that Stormfront posters exert much more energy repairing individuals' bad news than using it to exclude or attack them. Their repair strategies combine anti-scientific, counter-knowledge attacks on the legitimacy of GATs and quasi-scientific reinterpretations of GATs in terms of white nationalist histories. However, beyond individual identity repair they also reinterpret the racial boundaries and hierarchies of white nationalism in terms of the relationships GATs make visible. White nationalism is not simply an identity community or political movement but should be understood as bricoleurs with genetic knowledge displaying aspects of citizen science.
引用
收藏
页码:653 / 681
页数:29
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] The right to know your genetic parents: from open-identity gamete donation to universal paternity testing
    Ravelingien, A.
    Pennings, G.
    HUMAN REPRODUCTION, 2013, 28 : 66 - 66
  • [42] The Right to Know Your Genetic Parents: From Open-Identity Gamete Donation to Routine Paternity Testing
    Ravelingien, An
    Pennings, Guido
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF BIOETHICS, 2013, 13 (05): : 33 - 41
  • [43] Predictors of Repeated PSA Testing Among Black and White Men From the Maryland Cancer Survey, 2006
    Zhu, Yue
    Sorkin, John D.
    Dwyer, Diane
    Groves, Carmela
    Steinberger, Eileen K.
    PREVENTING CHRONIC DISEASE, 2011, 8 (05):
  • [44] Comprehensive genetic testing combined with citizen science reveals a recently characterized ancient MC1R mutation associated with partial recessive red phenotypes in dog
    Heidi Anderson
    Leena Honkanen
    Päivi Ruotanen
    Julia Mathlin
    Jonas Donner
    Canine Medicine and Genetics, 7 (1):
  • [45] Disparities in germline genetic testing results from a cohort of 493,515 black and white patients.
    Wyatt, Rachel
    Nielsen, Sarah M.
    Chen, Elaine
    Heald, Brandie
    Esplin, Edward D.
    Tomlinson, Gail Elizabeth
    JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY, 2023, 41 (16)
  • [46] Genetic variation within and among white clover populations from managed permanent pastures of the northeastern USA
    Gustine, DL
    Huff, DR
    CROP SCIENCE, 1999, 39 (02) : 524 - 530
  • [47] RACIAL DISPARITIES IN HOMOLOGOUS RECOMBINATION REPAIR (HRR) BIOMARKER TESTING IN THE UNITED STATES: A REAL-WORLD DATABASE ANALYSIS AMONG WHITE AND NON-WHITE PATIENTS WITH METASTATIC PROSTATE CANCER
    Schoenewald, J.
    Khilfeh, I
    Stevens, A. L.
    Francis, P.
    Zhang, C.
    Ayala, Tinajero B.
    Heerdegen, A. C.
    VALUE IN HEALTH, 2024, 27 (06) : S201 - S201
  • [48] ATTITUDES TOWARD GENETIC TESTING AMONG THE GENERAL-POPULATION AND RELATIVES OF PATIENTS WITH A SEVERE GENETIC-DISEASE - A SURVEY FROM FINLAND
    HIETALA, M
    HAKONEN, A
    ARO, AR
    NIEMELA, P
    PELTONEN, L
    AULA, P
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF HUMAN GENETICS, 1995, 56 (06) : 1493 - 1500
  • [49] BIOCHEMICAL POLYMORPHISMS AND GENETIC-RELATIONSHIPS AMONG LANDRACE, LARGE WHITE AND DUROC PIGS FROM SOUTHERN BRAZIL
    TAGLIARO, CH
    FRANCO, MHLP
    MEINCKE, W
    REVISTA BRASILEIRA DE GENETICA, 1993, 16 (03): : 671 - 678
  • [50] Comparison of phenotype by mismatch repair gene mutation among probands undergoing clinical genetic testing for mlh1 and msh2
    Stoffel, Elena M.
    Kastrinos, Fay
    Balmana, Judith
    Stockwell, David
    Steyerberg, Ewout
    Mercado, Rowena
    Syngal, Sapna
    GASTROENTEROLOGY, 2007, 132 (04) : A67 - A68