Genetic ancestry testing among white nationalists: From identity repair to citizen science

被引:74
|
作者
Panofsky, Aaron [1 ]
Donovan, Joan [2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Calif Los Angeles, Inst Soc & Genet, 621 Charles E Young Dr South,Box 957221,3360 LSB, Los Angeles, CA 90095 USA
[2] Harvard Univ, John F Kennedy Sch Govt, Cambridge, MA 02138 USA
基金
美国国家科学基金会; 美国国家卫生研究院;
关键词
genetic ancestry testing; identity; lay expertise; race and racism; white nationalism; white supremacy; DNA; ME;
D O I
10.1177/0306312719861434
中图分类号
N09 [自然科学史]; B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ; 010108 ; 060207 ; 060305 ; 0712 ;
摘要
White nationalists have a genetic essentialist understanding of racial identity, so what happens when using genetic ancestry tests (GATs) to explore personal identities, they receive upsetting results they consider evidence of non-white or non-European ancestry? Our answer draws on qualitative analysis of posts on the white nationalist website Stormfront, interpreted by synthesizing the literatures on white nationalism and GATs and identity. We show that Stormfront posters exert much more energy repairing individuals' bad news than using it to exclude or attack them. Their repair strategies combine anti-scientific, counter-knowledge attacks on the legitimacy of GATs and quasi-scientific reinterpretations of GATs in terms of white nationalist histories. However, beyond individual identity repair they also reinterpret the racial boundaries and hierarchies of white nationalism in terms of the relationships GATs make visible. White nationalism is not simply an identity community or political movement but should be understood as bricoleurs with genetic knowledge displaying aspects of citizen science.
引用
收藏
页码:653 / 681
页数:29
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Association between genetic ancestry and all-cause mortality among Black and White ever-smokers in the PLCO cohort
    Dill, Courtney D.
    Crump, Dontray
    Landy, Rebecca
    Cheung, Li C.
    Huang, Wen-Yi
    Berndt, Sonja
    Freedman, Neal
    Katki, Hormuzd
    CANCER RESEARCH, 2023, 83 (07)
  • [22] From accidental citizen-science observations to genetic confirmation: how to spot new hidden invaders
    Mori, Emiliano
    Baeri, Alberto
    Sforzi, Andrea
    Vitale, Alessandro
    Galimberti, Andrea
    HYSTRIX-ITALIAN JOURNAL OF MAMMALOGY, 2017, 28 (02): : 284 - 287
  • [23] Imputation of race and ethnicity categories using genetic ancestry from real-world genomic testing data
    Rhead, Brooke
    Haffener, Paige E.
    Pouliot, Yannick
    De La Vega, Francisco M.
    BIOCOMPUTING 2024, PSB 2024, 2024, : 433 - 445
  • [24] “Being proactive, not reactive”: exploring perceptions of genetic testing among White, Latinx, and Pacific Islander Populations
    Daniel Chavez-Yenter
    Jennie Vagher
    Margaret F. Clayton
    Mary Rindler
    Masha Shukovich
    Kimberly A. Kaphingst
    Journal of Community Genetics, 2021, 12 : 617 - 630
  • [25] Maximizing the impact of exposure to scientific role models: Testing an intervention to increase science identity among adolescent girls
    Merritt, Sally K.
    Hitti, Aline
    Van Camp, Amanda R.
    Shaffer, Emily
    Sanchez, Michelle H.
    O'Brien, Laurie T.
    JOURNAL OF APPLIED SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY, 2021, 51 (07) : 667 - 682
  • [26] "Being proactive, not reactive": exploring perceptions of genetic testing among White, Latinx, and Pacific Islander Populations
    Chavez-Yenter, Daniel
    Vagher, Jennie
    Clayton, Margaret F.
    Rindler, Mary
    Shukovich, Masha
    Kaphingst, Kimberly A.
    JOURNAL OF COMMUNITY GENETICS, 2021, 12 (04) : 617 - 630
  • [27] Genetic Identity, Ancestry and Parentage in Farmer Selections of Cacao from Aceh, Indonesia Revealed by Single Nucleotide Polymorphism (SNP) Markers
    Lukman
    Zhang, Dapeng
    Susilo, Agung W.
    Dinarti, Diny
    Bailey, Bryan
    Mischke, Sue
    Meinhardt, Lyndel W.
    TROPICAL PLANT BIOLOGY, 2014, 7 (3-4) : 133 - 143
  • [28] Genetic Identity, Ancestry and Parentage in Farmer Selections of Cacao from Aceh, Indonesia Revealed by Single Nucleotide Polymorphism (SNP) Markers
    Dapeng Lukman
    Agung W. Zhang
    Diny Susilo
    Bryan Dinarti
    Sue Bailey
    Lyndel W. Mischke
    Tropical Plant Biology, 2014, 7 : 133 - 143
  • [29] Developmental Trajectories of Science Identity Beliefs: Within-Group Differences among Black, Latinx, Asian, and White Students
    Kayla Puente
    Christine R. Starr
    Jacquelynne S. Eccles
    Sandra D. Simpkins
    Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 2021, 50 : 2394 - 2411
  • [30] Developmental Trajectories of Science Identity Beliefs: Within-Group Differences among Black, Latinx, Asian, and White Students
    Puente, Kayla
    Starr, Christine R.
    Eccles, Jacquelynne S.
    Simpkins, Sandra D.
    JOURNAL OF YOUTH AND ADOLESCENCE, 2021, 50 (12) : 2394 - 2411