Gender-Affirming Care for Cisgender People

被引:10
|
作者
Schall, Theodore E.
Moses, Jacob D.
机构
基金
美国医疗保健研究与质量局;
关键词
transgender; LGBTQ plus health policy; history of medicine; gender-affirming care; bioethics; TRANSGENDER POPULATION; SURGERY;
D O I
10.1002/hast.1486
中图分类号
B82 [伦理学(道德学)];
学科分类号
摘要
Gender-affirming care is almost exclusively discussed in connection with transgender medicine. However, this article argues that such care predominates among cisgender patients, people whose gender identity matches their sex assigned at birth. To advance this argument, we trace historical shifts in transgender medicine since the 1950s to identify central components of "gender-affirming care" that distinguish it from previous therapeutic models, such as "sex reassignment." Next, we sketch two historical cases-reconstructive mammoplasty and testicular implants-to show how cisgender patients offered justifications grounded in authenticity and gender affirmation that closely mirror rationales supporting gender-affirming care for transgender people. The comparison exposes significant disparities in contemporary health policy regarding care for cis and trans patients. We consider two possible objections to the analogy we draw, but ultimately argue that these disparities are rooted in "trans exceptionalism" that produces demonstrable harm..
引用
收藏
页码:15 / 24
页数:10
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] WHAT EVEN IS GENDER-AFFIRMING CARE?
    Kristensen, Z.
    Bandara, Y.
    Nguyen, T.
    AUSTRALIAN AND NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF PSYCHIATRY, 2024, 58 : 29 - 29
  • [22] Trans* people's access to gender-affirming health care: A European comparison
    Breckenkamp, J.
    Thirugnanamohan, J.
    Stern, A.
    Razum, O.
    Namer, Y.
    EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, 2022, 32
  • [23] Further Considerations on Gender-Affirming Care Reply
    Cavve, Blake S.
    Lin, Ashleigh
    Moore, Julia K.
    JAMA PEDIATRICS, 2024, 178 (08) : 842 - 843
  • [24] What Is the Aim of PEDIATRIC "Gender-Affirming" Care?
    Gorin, Moti
    HASTINGS CENTER REPORT, 2024, 54 (03) : 35 - 50
  • [25] Current approaches to gender-affirming vocal care
    McBrinn, Sarah
    Antoni, Christella
    Al Yaghchi, Chadwan
    CURRENT OPINION IN OTOLARYNGOLOGY & HEAD AND NECK SURGERY, 2024, 32 (03): : 143 - 150
  • [26] TRAINEE PERSPECTIVE ON GENDER-AFFIRMING CARE BANS
    Meyerson, Gabriella
    JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF CHILD AND ADOLESCENT PSYCHIATRY, 2024, 63 (10): : S33 - S33
  • [27] Gender-Affirming Care and Comprehensive Sexuality Education
    Pierce-Weeks, Jennifer
    JOURNAL OF FORENSIC NURSING, 2023, 19 (02) : E11 - E13
  • [28] Further Considerations on Gender-Affirming Care Reply
    Cavve, Blake S.
    Lin, Ashleigh
    Moore, Julia K.
    JAMA PEDIATRICS, 2024,
  • [29] Gender-affirming clinical care pathway for adolescents
    Ristori, Jiska
    Fisher, Alessandra
    JOURNAL OF SEXUAL MEDICINE, 2023, 20 (11): : 1266 - 1267
  • [30] Combating Scientific Disinformation on Gender-Affirming Care
    McNamara, Meredithe
    Abdul-Latif, Hussein
    Boulware, Susan D.
    Kamody, Rebecca
    Kuper, Laura E.
    Olezeski, Christy L.
    Szilagyi, Nathalie
    Alstott, Anne
    PEDIATRICS, 2023, 152 (03)