Are social contracts possible without actual negotiation?

被引:0
|
作者
Holcombe, Randall G. [1 ]
Robson, Gregory J. [2 ]
机构
[1] Florida State Univ, Tallahassee, FL USA
[2] Univ Notre Dame, Notre Dame, IN 46556 USA
关键词
Social contract; Role of government; Veil of ignorance; Consent; Constitutional economics; Public Economics; Structure and Scope of Government; COSTS;
D O I
10.1007/s10602-024-09452-1
中图分类号
D9 [法律]; DF [法律];
学科分类号
0301 ;
摘要
This article addresses one of the several moral arguments for the state, the social contract argument, showing that this argument has been inadequately justified. The terms of any contract are determined by negotiation among the parties to the contract. The terms of any contract cannot be known absent actual negotiation to produce them. Social contract theorists widely believe that actual negotiation and actual agreement with a social contract did not occur, so their theories rest on hypothetical scenarios in which people would agree to the contract's terms. Because actual negotiations did not produce a social contract, one cannot know its terms. This calls into question whether people could be obligated to abide by a social contract whose terms were not negotiated and hence are unknowable.
引用
收藏
页码:68 / 79
页数:12
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Perceived versus actual transparency of goals in negotiation
    Vorauer, JD
    Claude, SD
    PERSONALITY AND SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY BULLETIN, 1998, 24 (04) : 371 - 385
  • [22] Social negotiation
    Jobert, A
    SOCIOLOGIE DU TRAVAIL, 2001, 43 (01) : 141 - 142
  • [23] Negotiation Without Confrontation
    Wachs, Peter
    WORKPLACE HEALTH & SAFETY, 2012, 60 (06) : 255 - 256
  • [24] ACTUAL, POTENTIAL, OR POSSIBLE
    CARPENITO, LJ
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF NURSING, 1985, 85 (04) : 458 - 458
  • [25] NEGOTIATION PROBLEMS AND POSSIBLE SOLUTIONS
    TOCKLIN, AM
    NEGOTIATION JOURNAL-ON THE PROCESS OF DISPUTE SETTLEMENT, 1989, 5 (03): : 313 - 315
  • [26] Bilateral Negotiation of Energy Contracts from the Buyer Perspective
    Mateus, J. C.
    Cuervo, P.
    2009 IEEE POWER & ENERGY SOCIETY GENERAL MEETING, VOLS 1-8, 2009, : 347 - 353
  • [27] NEGOTIATION AND ADMINISTRATION OF HOTEL MANAGEMENT CONTRACTS - EYSTER,JJ
    CALLNIN, WJ
    REAL ESTATE REVIEW, 1978, 8 (01): : 99 - 100
  • [28] Automated combination of bilateral energy contracts negotiation tactics
    Pinto, Angelo
    Pinto, Tiago
    Silva, Francisco
    Praca, Isabel
    Vale, Zita
    Manuel Corchado, Juan
    2018 IEEE POWER & ENERGY SOCIETY GENERAL MEETING (PESGM), 2018,
  • [29] CONTRACTS WITHOUT PAPER
    WRIGHT, B
    TECHNOLOGY REVIEW, 1992, 95 (05): : 57 - 62
  • [30] Dynamic Negotiation Model of Bilateral Contracts in Electricity Market
    Zou Xiao-yan
    MEASURING TECHNOLOGY AND MECHATRONICS AUTOMATION, PTS 1 AND 2, 2011, 48-49 : 466 - 469