'Liking then CATA' or 'CATA then liking'? Impact of the hedonic question positioning on the wine sensory description and appreciation

被引:1
|
作者
Geffroy, Olivier [1 ]
Maza, Elie [2 ]
Lytra, Georgia [3 ]
Chervin, Christian [2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Toulouse, PPGV, INP Purpan, 75 Voie TOEC, FR-31076 Toulouse 3, France
[2] Univ Toulouse, AgroToulouse, INP ENSAT, BP 32607, F-31326 Castanet Tolosan, France
[3] Univ Bordeaux, INRAE, Bordeaux INP, Bordeaux Sci Agro,UMR 1366,OENO,ISVV, F-33882 Villenave Dornon, France
关键词
Sensory analysis; CATA; hedonic; wine;
D O I
10.20870/oeno-one.2024.58.3.8165
中图分类号
TS2 [食品工业];
学科分类号
0832 ;
摘要
The sequence of the questions asked in sensory testing is crucial and remains a topic of ongoing debate. This study examines the impact of question order in CATA (Check-All-That-Apply) analyses combined with hedonic evaluations, comparing two sequences: administering the liking question before the CATA question versus the reverse order. Conducted across four different times of the year, the study utilised four distinct panels and matrices of wines: two sets of red wines with various sweeteners, one set of ros & eacute; wines, and one set of white wines. The findings indicate that placing the CATA analysis before the liking question results in: (i) an enhanced product differentiation in correspondence analysis, (ii) a reduced number of panellists needed to achieve a strong dependence between products and attributes, and (iii) a greater number of significant differences in product liking scores as determined by ANOVA, compared to when the liking question precedes the CATA analysis. In summary, our findings show that positioning CATA before the liking question yields more detailed and discriminative results, at least with wines under our test conditions. This indicates a need for further research to understand the influence of question order, especially regarding the dependency between food products and their attributes.
引用
收藏
页数:8
相关论文
共 44 条
  • [31] LIKING AND SENSORY DESCRIPTION OF PROTEIN SUBSTITUTES IN PHENYLKETONURIA SUBJECTS: A CASE-STUDY IN NORTHERN AND SOUTHERN ITALY
    Proserpio, C.
    Verduci, E.
    Scala, I
    Strisciuglio, P.
    Zuvadelli, J.
    Pagliarini, E.
    ITALIAN JOURNAL OF FOOD SCIENCE, 2019, 31 (04) : 705 - 715
  • [32] Maximising umami taste in meat using natural ingredients: effects on chemistry, sensory perception and hedonic liking in young and old consumers
    Dermiki, Maria
    Mounayar, Rana
    Suwankanit, Chutipapha
    Scott, Jennifer
    Kennedy, Orla B.
    Mottram, Donald S.
    Gosney, Margot A.
    Blumenthal, Heston
    Methven, Lisa
    JOURNAL OF THE SCIENCE OF FOOD AND AGRICULTURE, 2013, 93 (13) : 3312 - 3321
  • [33] Sugar reduction in probiotic chocolate-flavored milk: Impact on dynamic sensory profile and liking
    Oliveira, Denize
    Antunez, Lucia
    Gimenez, Ana
    Castura, John C.
    Deliza, Rosires
    Ares, Gaston
    FOOD RESEARCH INTERNATIONAL, 2015, 75 : 148 - 156
  • [34] Impact of consumption frequency on generations of sensory product profiles using CATA questions: Case studies with two drink categories
    Xia, Yixun
    Song, Jiahui
    Lee, PuiYee
    Shen, Huijuan
    Hou, Jiaoliang
    Yang, Jian
    Gao, Boyang
    Zhong, Fang
    FOOD RESEARCH INTERNATIONAL, 2020, 137
  • [35] Impact of aging on the overall liking and sensory characteristics of sourdough breads and comparison of two methods to determine their sensory shelf life
    Gauchez, Helene
    Loiseau, Anne-Laure
    Schlich, Pascal
    Martin, Christophe
    JOURNAL OF FOOD SCIENCE, 2020, 85 (10) : 3517 - 3526
  • [36] Impact of product information and repeated exposure on consumer liking, sensory perception and concept associations of local apple juice
    Stolzenbach, Sandra
    Bredie, Wender L. P.
    Christensen, Rune H. B.
    Byrne, Derek V.
    FOOD RESEARCH INTERNATIONAL, 2013, 52 (01) : 91 - 98
  • [37] Impact of defatting and drying methods on the overall liking and sensory profile of a cereal bar incorporating edible insect species
    Ribeiro, Jose Carlos
    Santos, Carla
    Lima, Rui Costa
    Pintado, Manuela E.
    Cunha, Luis Miguel
    FUTURE FOODS, 2022, 6
  • [38] Impact of information and in-home sensory exposure on liking and willingness to pay: The beginning of Fairtrade labeled coffee in France
    Lange, C.
    Combris, P.
    Issanchou, S.
    Schlich, P.
    FOOD RESEARCH INTERNATIONAL, 2015, 76 : 317 - 324
  • [39] Consumer Response to Tomato Pomace Powder as an Ingredient in Bread: Impact of Sensory Liking and Benefit Information on Purchase Intent
    Concha-Meyer, Anibal A.
    Durham, Catherine A.
    Colonna, Ann E.
    Hasenbeck, Aimee
    Saez, Barbara
    Adams, Michael R.
    JOURNAL OF FOOD SCIENCE, 2019, 84 (12) : 3774 - 3783
  • [40] Hedonic rating coupled with sensory profiles using CATA for six whole roasted or deep-fried insects among Danish 11-13-year-old children
    Sick, Julia
    Hartmann, Anna Loraine
    Frost, Michael Bom
    FOOD QUALITY AND PREFERENCE, 2024, 114