Multiple levels of "knowing and being known", their affiliated capital, benefits and challenges

被引:8
|
作者
Natifu, Barbra [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Oslo, Dept Media & Commun, Oslo, Norway
关键词
Uganda; Insider research; Higher education institution; Autoethnography; Forms of capital; Information access capital; Institution;
D O I
10.1108/JOE-09-2015-0022
中图分类号
C93 [管理学];
学科分类号
12 ; 1201 ; 1202 ; 120202 ;
摘要
Purpose - The purpose of this paper is to investigate the extent to which the position of a former insider with multiple levels of knowing and being known, afforded me benefits and challenges in a complex higher education institution in Uganda. A reflexive autoethnographic account of the author's research experience is employed as methodology. The study observes various benefits and challenges of this position. These include: firsthand knowledge of institutional culture and informants, leading to multiple levels of access; ability to conduct enriching interviews; and good rapport with informants. The challenges include: complexity of the institution; ethical challenges; power dilemmas; and anonymization of data. Access was noted to be a key benefit and it was experienced at five levels: personal relational networks; informant's knowledge of a family relation; links to institutional and national networks; the role of media; and situational factors. In accordance with Bourdieu's (1986) concepts of forms of capital, the study established that four levels of knowing were linked to social, cultural, economic or media capital. The study reveals existence of a link between different levels of knowing and being known and their affiliated forms of capital. It shows that possession of any or a combination of these forms of capital leads to what the study defines as "information access capital." The study suggests that the different levels of knowing and being known determine the breadth and depth of a researcher's information access capital. The study implies that power imbued relationships can limit access. Design/methodology/approach - The paper applies a reflexive autoethnographic methodology where the author uses their personal research experience to make sense of the benefits and challenges of gaining access as a former insider with multiple identity positions. The paper draws from the author's personal experience (auto) set in an institutional cultural context (ethno), to analyze the research process (graphy) of gaining access of top and middle management informants. First person (auto) accounts of the author's organizational cultural (ethno) and research process (graphy) experiences and how they link to the benefits and challenges of researching an organization as insider are used as data. Findings - The study observed various benefits and challenges of the insider position. These include: firsthand knowledge of institutional culture and informants, leading to multiple levels of access; ability to conduct enriching interviews; and good rapport with informants. The challenges include: complexity of the institution; ethical challenges; power dilemmas; and anonymization of data. Access was noted to be a key benefit experienced at five levels: personal networks; informant's networks; institutional networks; the role of media; and situational factors. The four levels were linked to social, cultural, economic or media capital. Research limitations/implications - The study is limited to the researcher's personal experience of the institution. The paper shows the role that social, work, political, media, institutional and national networks and their affiliated forms of capital play in affording insider researchers access. It shows that researchers deficient in these capitals have low-information access capital and face challenges of access. It also shows that although friendship may enable access, if infused with power dynamics, power hinders access. The study shows insider researchers in complex organizations have to continually navigate the insider-outsider continuum and challenges thereof. Practicing relational ethics during and after research is key when conducting organizational insider research. Practical implications - The paper shows the role that social, work, political, media, institutional and national networks and their affiliated forms of capital play in affording insider researchers access. It shows that researchers deficient in these forms of capital have low-information access capital and face challenges of access. It also shows that although friendship may enable access, if infused with power dynamics, power serves as hindrance to access. The study also shows insider researchers in complex organizations may have to continually navigate the insider-outsider continuum and challenges thereof. Practicing relational ethics during and after research is a key consideration of insider researchers. Social implications - The paper reveals the challenges of accessing top and middle management in complex, bureaucratic and guarded higher education organizations. It shows that although higher education institutions, by virtue of their research orientated missions, should ideally set the right example for easy access to information at all levels and ranks of the organization. However, the reality of access for an insider research may be far from the ideal due to factors of complexity and previously formed power imbued relationships. Originality/value - The paper contributes to understanding factors at play when gaining and maintaining research access to top and middle management in a higher education context. In accordance with (Bourdieu's, 1986) concepts of forms of capital, the paper contributes to understanding the relationship between multiple levels of knowing and their affiliated forms of capital and how these capital forms may facilitate information access. It shows that possession of any capital form increases a researcher's information access capital. The paper expands Weinreb's (2006) definition of stranger and insider interviews, by showing multiple ways of "knowing or being known" before and during the study.
引用
收藏
页码:219 / 234
页数:16
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Agroecological transitions: multiple scales, levels and challenges
    Tittonell, Pablo
    REVISTA DE LA FACULTAD DE CIENCIAS AGRARIAS, 2019, 51 (01) : 231 - 246
  • [32] Patients with cerebral palsy are being failed on multiple levels
    Thornton, Jacqui
    BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 2018, 360
  • [33] CHALLENGES PROVIDING MULTIPLE ECOSYSTEM BENEFITS FOR SUSTAINABLE MANAGED SYSTEMS
    Hans LAMBERS
    Wen-Feng CONG
    Frontiers of Agricultural Science and Engineering, 2022, 9 (02) : 170 - 176
  • [34] Benefits and challenges of palliative care in patients with advanced multiple sclerosis
    De Almeida, Taynara Emanuella Gomes
    Moreira, Leandro De Almeida
    Varela, Joao Pedro
    JOURNAL OF THE NEUROLOGICAL SCIENCES, 2023, 455
  • [35] CHALLENGES PROVIDING MULTIPLE ECOSYSTEM BENEFITS FOR SUSTAINABLE MANAGED SYSTEMS
    Lambers, Hans
    Cong, Wen-Feng
    FRONTIERS OF AGRICULTURAL SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING, 2022, 9 (02) : 170 - 176
  • [36] The benefits and challenges of multiple health behavior change in research and in practice
    Prochaska, Judith J.
    Nigg, Claudio R.
    Spring, Bonnie
    Velicer, Wayne F.
    Prochaska, James O.
    PREVENTIVE MEDICINE, 2010, 50 (1-2) : 26 - 29
  • [37] Market making in international capital markets Challenges and benefits of its implementation in emerging markets
    Charitou, Andreas
    Panayides, Marios
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MANAGERIAL FINANCE, 2009, 5 (01) : 50 - +
  • [38] The benefits of being a multi-capital: The economic impact of the international and European institutions and interest groups
    Dotti, Nicola Francesco
    Spithoven, Andre
    Ysebaert, Walter
    EUROPEAN URBAN AND REGIONAL STUDIES, 2022, 29 (02) : 255 - 277
  • [39] Should Large Spanish Municipalities Be Financially Compensated? Costs and Benefits of Being a Capital/Central Municipality
    Bosch, Nuria
    Espasa, Marta
    Montolio, Daniel
    HACIENDA PUBLICA ESPANOLA-REVIEW OF PUBLIC ECONOMICS, 2014, (211): : 67 - 91
  • [40] Adventures of the Lone Rangers: The benefits and challenges of being the sole physical chemist in a chemistry department
    Bruce, Chrystal D.
    Calhoun, Allison
    ABSTRACTS OF PAPERS OF THE AMERICAN CHEMICAL SOCIETY, 2011, 242