THE OPPOSITION 'WEST/NON-WEST' IN THE SOCIAL THOUGHT: PRO ET CONTRA

被引:0
|
作者
Radkevich, K., V [1 ]
Shabaga, A., V [1 ]
机构
[1] Peoples Friendship Univ Russia, RUDN Univ, Miklukho Maklaya St 6, Moscow 117198, Russia
关键词
West; Non-West; Non-Western theories; orientalism; identity; problems of social knowledge; multiculturalism; political doctrines;
D O I
10.22363/2313-2272-2018-18-1-20-32
中图分类号
C91 [社会学];
学科分类号
030301 ; 1204 ;
摘要
The article considers the phenomenon of social science debates in the form of the opposition 'West/Non-West' and its social-political and identification consequences. The authors focus on the history of this opposition, the ways to overcome the scientific and social confrontations that were determined by it, and on the methodological significance of the concept `Non-Western theories'. The authors study the features of social and political knowledge of the countries of Asia, Africa and Latin America; compare social values of Western Europe, China and other countries to identify the ways for its integration in the course of postcolonial political and scientific development. In particular, the article compares the axio logical triad of T. Heuss (democracy, Roman law, Christian ethics) and the Chinese dyad - the will of the people (minxin suoxiang) and three convents (sangang). Within the West/Non-West opposition, the Western European, Chinese, Japanese, Indian, African, Latin-American social-political constructs are considered to assess the productivity of some categorical oppositions and contaminations adopted in the sphere of social knowledge and to prove the theoretical inconsistency of multiculturalism. The authors also consider the issues of eurocentrism and Western-European messianism on the examples of their relationship with Sino-Centrism, and the ideas of African and Latin-American nationalism. Such comparisons prove the metatheoretical status of the West/Non-West' opposition that can be explained within the paradigm of the social construction of reality. The authors conclude that the concepts 'West' and 'Non-West' do not have a truly scientific status; they are rather markers of social values claiming a special identification value, i.e. having a direct relation to self-representation. The concepts 'West' and 'Non-West' are a kind of political declarations tather than an evidence of epistemological differences in the foundations of social knowledge in different parts of the globe.
引用
收藏
页码:20 / 32
页数:13
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] The "Non-west" Methodological Concept for Building a System of International Relations in the Eurasian Space
    Vasilieva, Natalia
    Bakhturidse, Zeinab
    Ivannikov, Nikita
    Tsyb, Alexey
    PROCEEDINGS OF TOPICAL ISSUES IN INTERNATIONAL POLITICAL GEOGRAPHY, 2021, : 3 - 10
  • [22] West Nile Virus and Non-West Nile Virus Mortality and Coinfection of American Crows (Corvus brachyrhynchos) in California
    Wheeler, Sarah S.
    Woods, Leslie W.
    Boyce, Walter M.
    Eckstrand, Christina D.
    Langevin, Stanley A.
    Reisen, William K.
    Townsend, Andrea K.
    AVIAN DISEASES, 2014, 58 (02) : 255 - 261
  • [23] Interrogating hegemonic embraces: Representative bureaucracy, methodological Whiteness, and non-West exclusions
    Moloney, Kim
    Sanabria-Pulido, Pablo
    Demircioglu, Mehmet Akif
    PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION REVIEW, 2023, 83 (01) : 195 - 202
  • [24] German Cosmopolitan Social Thought and the Idea of the West
    Gusejnova, Dina
    GERMAN HISTORY, 2017, 35 (02) : 335 - 337
  • [25] Are ESR/CRP ratios helpful in differentiating West Nile encephalitis from non-West Nile virus meningitis/encephalitis?
    Hage, Jean E.
    Cunha, Burke A.
    SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF INFECTIOUS DISEASES, 2013, 45 (08) : 652 - 654
  • [26] Russification - Pro et Contra: Polemic in the Russian Conservative Thought in the late XIX century
    Krot, Maxim N.
    Dmitrieva, Natalia V.
    BYLYE GODY, 2018, 47 (01) : 360 - 369
  • [27] The barbarian West: marginalization of the non western thought
    Zeraoui, Zidane
    DESAFIOS, 2007, 17 : 12 - 30
  • [28] "East - West" Problem in Social Thought of the Bengal Renaissance
    Skorokhodova, Tatiana G.
    VOPROSY FILOSOFII, 2017, (12) : 147 - 158
  • [29] TEACHER EDUCATION AND 7TH GRADE NON-WEST STUDIES COURSE IN INDIANA - FINAL SOLUTION
    ENGELLAN.CW
    CONTEMPORARY EDUCATION, 1974, 45 (03): : 209 - 215
  • [30] NATURE, COMMUNITY AND WILL - STUDY IN LITERARY AND SOCIAL THOUGHT - WEST,TR
    BARTLETT, IH
    JOURNAL OF AMERICAN HISTORY, 1977, 63 (04) : 1046 - 1047