On a fallacy in the Kaldor-Hicks efficiency-equity analysis

被引:4
|
作者
Ellerman, David [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Calif Riverside, Riverside, CA 92521 USA
关键词
Kaldor-Hicks criterion; Wealth maximization; Efficiency; Equity; Law and economics; Cost-benefit analysis;
D O I
10.1007/s10602-014-9159-x
中图分类号
D9 [法律]; DF [法律];
学科分类号
0301 ;
摘要
This paper shows that implicit assumptions about the numeraire good in the Kaldor-Hicks efficiency-equity analysis involve a "same-yardstick'' fallacy (a fallacy pointed out by Paul Samuelson in another context). These results have negative implications for cost-benefit analysis, the wealth-maximization approach to law and economics, and other parts of applied welfare economics-as well as for the whole vision of economics based on the "production and distribution of social wealth''.
引用
收藏
页码:125 / 136
页数:12
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] The efficiency-equity trade-off, self-interest, and moral principles in health and safety valuation
    Arroyos-Calvera, Danae
    Covey, Judith
    Loomes, Graham
    McDonald, Rebecca
    SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE, 2019, 238
  • [42] Identifying Spatial Efficiency-Equity Trade-offs in Territorial Development Policies: Evidence from Uganda
    Lall, Somik V.
    Schroeder, Elizabeth
    Schmidt, Emily
    JOURNAL OF DEVELOPMENT STUDIES, 2014, 50 (12): : 1717 - 1733
  • [43] The fallacy of the equity-efficiency trade off: rethinking the efficient health system
    Daniel D Reidpath
    Anna Elisabet Olafsdottir
    Subhash Pokhrel
    Pascale Allotey
    BMC Public Health, 12
  • [44] The fallacy of the equity-efficiency trade off: rethinking the efficient health system
    Reidpath, Daniel D.
    Olafsdottir, Anna Elisabet
    Pokhrel, Subhash
    Allotey, Pascale
    BMC PUBLIC HEALTH, 2012, 12
  • [45] Efficiency-equity trade-off in the Irish carbon tax: A CGE investigation of mixed revenue recycling schemes
    de Bruin, Kelly
    Yakut, Aykut Mert
    ECONOMIC MODELLING, 2024, 134
  • [46] Explaining the Persistence of Health Disparities: Social Stratification and the Efficiency-Equity Trade-off in the Kidney Transplantation System
    Daw, Jonathan
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF SOCIOLOGY, 2015, 120 (06) : 1595 - 1640
  • [47] Recipient choice can address the efficiency-equity trade-off in kidney transplantation: A mechanism design model
    Su, Xuanming
    Zenios, Stefanos A.
    MANAGEMENT SCIENCE, 2006, 52 (11) : 1647 - 1660
  • [48] EFFICIENCY-EQUITY TRADE-OFFS IN COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSES: AN UMBRELLA REVIEW OF PREVIOUS SYSTEMATIC LITERATURE REVIEWS
    Radhakrishnan, A.
    Muir, J.
    Freitag, A.
    Ozer, Stillman, I
    Sarri, G.
    VALUE IN HEALTH, 2023, 26 (06) : S98 - S98
  • [49] Air Traffic Flow Management Integrating Separation Management and Ground Holding: An Efficiency-Equity Bi-objective Perspective
    Guo, Yechenfeng
    Hu, Minghua
    Zou, Bo
    Hansen, Mark
    Zhang, Ying
    Xie, Hua
    TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART B-METHODOLOGICAL, 2022, 155 : 394 - 423
  • [50] How to Have your Cake and Eat it Too: Resolving the Efficiency-Equity Trade-off in Minimum Wage Legislation
    Mukerji, Nikil
    Schumacher, Christoph R.
    JOURNAL OF INTERDISCIPLINARY ECONOMICS, 2008, 19 (04) : 315 - 334