Comparative Study on the Immunogenicity and Efficacy of Different Post-exposure Intramuscular Rabies Vaccination Regimens in China

Objective This study aimed to compare the current Essen rabies post-exposure immunization schedule(0-3-7-14-28) in China and the simple 4-dose schedule(0-3-7-14) newly recommended by the World Health Organization in terms of their safety, efficacy, and protection.Methods Mice were vaccinated according to different immunization schedules, and blood was collected for detection of rabies virus neutralizing antibodies(RVNAs) on days 14, 21, 28, 35, and 120after the first immunization. Additionally, different groups of mice were injected with lethal doses of the CVS-11 virus on day 0, subjected to different rabies immunization schedules, and assessed for morbidity and death status. In a clinical trial, 185 rabies-exposed individuals were selected for post-exposure vaccination according to the Essen schedule, and blood was collected for RVNAs detection on days 28and 42 after the first immunization.Results A statistically significant difference in RVNAs between mice in the Essen and 0-3-7-14 schedule groups was observed on the 35th day(P < 0.05). The groups 0-3-7-14, 0-3-7-21, and 0-3-7-28 showed no statistically significant difference(P > 0.05) in RVNAs levels at any time point. The post-exposure immune protective test showed that the survival rate of mice in the control group was 20%, whereas that in the immunization groups was 40%. In the clinical trial, the RVNAs positive conversion rates on days 28(14 days after 4 doses) and 42(14 days after 5 doses) were both 100%, and no significant difference in RVNAs levels was observed(P > 0.05).Conclusion The simple 4-dose schedule can produce sufficient RVNAs levels, with no significant effect of a delayed fourth vaccine dose(14–28 d) on the immunization potential.