Sniffer dogs performance is stable over time in detecting COVID-19 positive samples and agrees with the rapid antigen test in the field

被引:0
|
作者
Federica Pirrone
Patrizia Piotti
Massimo Galli
Roberto Gasparri
Aldo La Spina
Lorenzo Spaggiari
Mariangela Albertini
机构
[1] University of Milan (UNIMI),Department of Veterinary Medicine and Animal Sciences
[2] ASST Fatebenefratelli-Sacco,III Infectious Diseases Unit, L. Sacco Hospital
[3] University of Milan,Department of Biomedical and Clinical Sciences DIBIC, Luigi Sacco
[4] European Institute of Oncology IRCCS,Division of Thoracic Surgery, IEO
[5] Medical Detection Dogs Italy,Department of Oncology and Hemato
[6] University of Milan,Oncology–DIPO
来源
关键词
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
学科分类号
摘要
Rapid antigen diagnostic (RAD) tests have been developed for the identification of the SARS-CoV-2 infection. However, they require nasopharyngeal or nasal swab, which is invasive, uncomfortable, and aerosolising. The use of saliva test was also proposed but has not yet been validated. Trained dogs may efficiently smell the presence of SARS-CoV-2 in biological samples of infected people, but further validation is needed both in laboratory and in field. The present study aimed to (1) assess and validate the stability over a specific time period of COVID-19 detection in humans’ armpit sweat by trained dogs thanks to a double-blind laboratory test–retest design, and (2) assess this ability when sniffing people directly. Dogs were not trained to discriminate against other infections. For all dogs (n. 3), the laboratory test on 360 samples yielded 93% sensitivity and 99% specificity, an 88% agreement with the Rt-PCR, and a moderate to strong test–retest correlation. When sniffing people directly (n. 97), dogs’ (n. 5) overall sensitivity (89%) and specificity (95%) were significantly above chance level. An almost perfect agreement with RAD results was found (kappa 0.83, SE 0.05, p = 0.001). Therefore, sniffer dogs met appropriate criteria (e.g., repeatability) and WHO's target product profiles for COVID-19 diagnostics and produced very promising results in laboratory and field settings, respectively. These findings support the idea that biodetection dogs could help reduce the spread of the virus in high-risk environments, including airports, schools, and public transport.
引用
收藏
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Sniffer dogs performance is stable over time in detecting COVID-19 positive samples and agrees with the rapid antigen test in the field
    Pirrone, Federica
    Piotti, Patrizia
    Galli, Massimo
    Gasparri, Roberto
    La Spina, Aldo
    Spaggiari, Lorenzo
    Albertini, Mariangela
    SCIENTIFIC REPORTS, 2023, 13 (01)
  • [2] Analytical and clinical performance of the panbio COVID-19 antigen-detecting rapid diagnostic test
    Alemany, Andrea
    Baro, Barbara
    Ouchi, Dan
    Rodo, Pau
    Ubals, Maria
    Corbacho-Monne, Marc
    Vergara-Alert, Julia
    Rodon, Jordi
    Segales, Joaquim
    Esteban, Cristina
    Fernandez, Gema
    Ruiz, Lidia
    Bassat, Quique
    Clotet, Bonaventura
    Ara, Jordi
    Vall-Mayans, Marti
    G-Beiras, Camila
    Blanco, Ignacio
    Mitja, Oriol
    JOURNAL OF INFECTION, 2021, 82 (05) : 188 - 191
  • [3] Evaluation of the COVID-19 Rapid Antigen Test
    Sanli, Ozlem Oguc
    Kuscu, Ozlem Ozkan
    Incekas, Caner
    FLORA INFEKSIYON HASTALIKLARI VE KLINIK MIKROBIYOLOJI DERGISI, 2023, 28 (03): : 489 - 495
  • [4] The evaluation of a rapid microfluidic immunofluorescence antigen test in detecting the infectiousness of COVID-19 patients
    Ota, Kenji
    Kodama, Hina
    Kawamoto, Yasuhide
    Sasaki, Daisuke
    Mitsumoto-Kaseida, Fujiko
    Sakamoto, Kei
    Kosai, Kosuke
    Hasegawa, Hiroo
    Takazono, Takahiro
    Izumikawa, Koichi
    Mukae, Hiroshi
    Tun, Mya Myat Ngwe
    Morita, Kouichi
    Yanagihara, Katsunori
    BMC INFECTIOUS DISEASES, 2023, 23 (01)
  • [5] The evaluation of a rapid microfluidic immunofluorescence antigen test in detecting the infectiousness of COVID-19 patients
    Kenji Ota
    Hina Kodama
    Yasuhide Kawamoto
    Daisuke Sasaki
    Fujiko Mitsumoto-Kaseida
    Kei Sakamoto
    Kosuke Kosai
    Hiroo Hasegawa
    Takahiro Takazono
    Koichi Izumikawa
    Hiroshi Mukae
    Mya Myat Ngwe Tun
    Kouichi Morita
    Katsunori Yanagihara
    BMC Infectious Diseases, 23
  • [6] Field evaluation of a rapid antigen test (Panbio™ COVID-19 Ag Rapid Test Device) for COVID-19 diagnosis in primary healthcare centres
    Albert, Eliseo
    Torres, Ignacio
    Bueno, Felipe
    Huntley, Dixie
    Molla, Estefania
    Angel Fernandez-Fuentes, Miguel
    Martinez, Mireia
    Poujois, Sandrine
    Forque, Lorena
    Valdivia, Arantxa
    Solano de la Asuncion, Carlos
    Ferrer, Josep
    Colomina, Javier
    Navarro, David
    CLINICAL MICROBIOLOGY AND INFECTION, 2021, 27 (03) : 472.e7 - 472.e10
  • [7] False Positive Covid-19 Rapid Antigen Tests
    Yang, Chengliang
    Espin, Estefania
    Tebbutt, Scott J.
    NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2024, 390 (19): : 1835 - 1836
  • [8] Field evaluation of COVID-19 rapid antigen test: Are rapid antigen tests less reliable among the elderly?
    Irena Tabain
    Djivo Cucevic
    Nikola Skreb
    Anna Mrzljak
    Ivana Ferencak
    Zeljka Hruskar
    Anita Misic
    Josipa Kuzle
    Ana Marija Skoda
    Hrvojka Jankovic
    Tatjana Vilibic-Cavlek
    World Journal of Clinical Cases, 2022, 10 (19) : 6456 - 6463
  • [9] Field evaluation of COVID-19 rapid antigen test: Are rapid antigen tests less reliable among the elderly?
    Tabain, Irena
    Cucevic, Djivo
    Skreb, Nikola
    Mrzljak, Anna
    Ferencak, Ivana
    Hruskar, Zeljka
    Misic, Anita
    Kuzle, Josipa
    Skoda, Ana Marija
    Jankovic, Hrvojka
    Vilibic-Cavlek, Tatjana
    WORLD JOURNAL OF CLINICAL CASES, 2022, 10 (19) : 6456 - 6463
  • [10] Dogs Detecting COVID-19 From Sweat and Saliva of Positive People: A Field Experience in Mexico
    Mancilla-Tapia, Juan Manuel
    Lozano-Esparza, Victoria
    Orduna, Adrian
    Osuna-Chavez, Reyna Fabiola
    Robles-Zepeda, Ramon Enrique
    Maldonado-Cabrera, Blayra
    Bejar-Cornejo, Jorge Ruben
    Ruiz-Leon, Ivan
    Gonzalez-Becuar, Carlos Gabriel
    Hielm-Bjoerkman, Anna
    Novelo-Gonzalez, Ana
    Vidal-Martinez, Victor Manuel
    FRONTIERS IN MEDICINE, 2022, 9