The dynamics of alternative male mating tactics in a population of Black Grouse Tetrao tetrix in the Italian Alps

The Black Grouse Tetrao tetrix is primarily a lekking species, although in some populations solitary display is also common. We analysed data from a 25-year-long survey of an increasing Black Grouse population in the western Italian Alps in order to test whether the numbers of males adopting different tactics conformed to patterns expected, based on the hypothesis that dominant birds occupy the leks and solitary displaying birds are subordinate, and that the tendency for birds to be excluded from leks increases with lek size. Four predictions were made to test this hypothesis: (1) the proportion of solitary males would increase as the overall population increases, (2) there would be a threshold at which there is little or no increase in the size of the lekking population, but continued increase in the population of solitary displaying birds, (3) available lek habitat would be occupied prior to an increase in solitary displaying males, and (4) there would be an increase in the use of less preferred habitat by solitary displaying males as the total population increases. Population trends varied according to display status, in that the lekking population reached an apparent threshold while the number of solitary males continued to increase, and there was an expansion of the range of solitary males into higher altitudes in years when the population was larger. However, there was no increase in the proportion of solitary males as the total population increased. Furthermore, there was no suggestion that suitable lek habitat was limiting, as the number of leks and the mean size of those leks continued to increase throughout the study period. Although two predictions were supported, the precise patterns of trends, and results of additional analyses, suggested that solitary display is more likely to be an alternative rather than a subordinate tactic. Several factors may promote this apparent dual display tactic in Black Grouse, but habitat structure in this and other Alpine populations is likely to be a key influence.