On gravity as a medium property in Maxwell equations

The effect of gravity in Maxwell’s equations is often treated as a medium property. The commonly used formulation is based on managing Maxwell’s equations in exactly the same form as in Minkowski spacetime and expressing the effect of gravity as a set of constitutive relations. We show that such a set of Maxwell’s equations is, in fact, a combination of the electric and magnetic fields defined in two different non-covariant ways, both of which fail to identify the associated observer’s four-vectors. The suggested constitutive relations are also ad hoc and unjustified. To an observer with a proper four-vector, the effect of gravity can be arranged as effective polarizations and magnetizations appearing in both the homogeneous and inhomogeneous parts. Modifying the homogeneous part by gravity is inevitable to any observer, and the result cannot be interpreted as the medium property. For optical properties one should directly handle Maxwell’s equations in curved spacetime.