On the Chirality Quantum Phase Transition of the Dirac Oscillator

Dirac oscillator subjects to an external magnetic field is re-examined. We show that this model can be mapped onto different quantum optics models if one insists to introduce two kinds of phonons which associate with the excitations of Dirac oscillator and magnetic field respectively. The conclusion about chirality quantum phase transition in the paper “Chirality quantum phase transition in the Dirac oscillator” (Bermudez et al. Phys. Rev. A, 77, 063815 2008) is only valid for a specific mapped quantum optics models rather than the Dirac oscillator itself. Thus, the conclusions about chirality quantum phase transitions in this paper are not universal.