Modeling gravitational waves from exotic compact objects

Exotic compact objects can be difficult to distinguish from black holes in the inspiral phase of the binaries observed by gravitational-wave detectors, but significant differences may be present in the merger and post-merger signal. We introduce a toy model capturing the salient features of binaries of exotic compact objects with compactness below 0.2, which do not collapse promptly following the merger. We use it to assess their detectability with current and future detectors, and whether they can be distinguished from black hole binaries. We find that the Einstein Telescope (LISA) could observe exotic binaries with total mass O(10(2)) M-circle dot (10(4)-10(6) M-circle dot), and potentially distinguish them from black hole binaries, throughout the observable Universe, as compared to z less than or similar to 1 for Advanced LIGO. Moreover, we show that using standard black hole templates for detection could lead to a loss of up to 60% in the signal-to-noise ratio, greatly reducing our chances of observing these signals. Finally, we estimate that if the loudest events in the O1/O2 catalog released by the LIGO/Virgo collaboration were ECO binaries as the ones considered in this paper, they would have left a post-merger signal detectable with model-agnostic searches, making this hypothesis unlikely.