Estimating Stability for Efficient Argument-Based Inquiry

被引:10
|
作者
Odekerken, Daphne [1 ,2 ]
Borg, AnneMarie [1 ]
Bex, Floris [1 ,3 ]
机构
[1] Univ Utrecht, Dept Informat & Comp Sci, Utrecht, Netherlands
[2] Netherlands Police, Natl Police Lab AI, Driebergen, Netherlands
[3] Tilburg Univ, Tilburg Inst Law Technol & Soc, Tilburg, Netherlands
关键词
dynamic argumentation; structured argumentation; inquiry;
D O I
10.3233/FAIA200514
中图分类号
TP18 [人工智能理论];
学科分类号
081104 ; 0812 ; 0835 ; 1405 ;
摘要
We study the dynamic argumentation task of detecting stability: given a specific structured argumentation setting, can adding information change the acceptability status of some propositional formula? Detecting stability is not tractable for every input, but efficient computation is essential in practical applications. We present a sound approximation algorithm that recognises stability for many inputs in polynomial time and we discuss several of its properties. In particular, we show under which constraints on the input our algorithm is complete. The proposed algorithm is currently applied for fraud inquiry at the Dutch National Police - we provide an English demo version that also visualises the output of the algorithm.
引用
收藏
页码:307 / 318
页数:12
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Examining Science Teacher Reflections on Argument-Based Inquiry Through a Critical Discourse Lens
    Nathan Anderson Quarderer
    Mark A. McDermott
    Research in Science Education, 2020, 50 : 2483 - 2504
  • [22] SUCCESS, DIFFICULTY, AND INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGY TO ENACT AN ARGUMENT-BASED INQUIRY APPROACH: EXPERIENCES OF ELEMENTARY TEACHERS
    Choi, Aeran
    Klein, Vanessa
    Hershberger, Susan
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SCIENCE AND MATHEMATICS EDUCATION, 2015, 13 (05) : 991 - 1011
  • [23] Examining Elementary Students’ Development of Oral and Written Argumentation Practices Through Argument-Based Inquiry
    Ying-Chih Chen
    Brian Hand
    Soonhye Park
    Science & Education, 2016, 25 : 277 - 320
  • [24] SUCCESS, DIFFICULTY, AND INSTRUCTIONAL STRATEGY TO ENACT AN ARGUMENT-BASED INQUIRY APPROACH: EXPERIENCES OF ELEMENTARY TEACHERS
    Aeran Choi
    Vanessa Klein
    Susan Hershberger
    International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 2015, 13 : 991 - 1011
  • [25] Prospective biology teachers' critical thinking skills in microbiology argument-based inquiry laboratory activities
    Roviati, E.
    Widodo, A.
    Purwianingsih, W.
    Riandi, R.
    INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON MATHEMATICS AND SCIENCE EDUCATION (ICMSCE 2018), 2019, 1157
  • [26] Talking Science Argument-Based Inquiry, Teachers' Talk Moves, and Students' Critical Thinking in the Classroom
    Soysal, Yilmaz
    SCIENCE & EDUCATION, 2021, 30 (01) : 33 - 65
  • [27] The Effects of Argument-Based Inquiry Activities On Elementary School Students' Claims and Evidence in Science Writing
    Park, Jiaeng
    Jung, Dojun
    Kim, Geonu
    Jun, Jaekyoung
    Nam, Jeonghee
    JOURNAL OF THE KOREAN CHEMICAL SOCIETY-DAEHAN HWAHAK HOE JEE, 2020, 64 (06): : 389 - 400
  • [28] Quality Indicators of an Experienced Middle School Science Teacher's Argument-Based Inquiry Teaching
    Soysal, Yilmaz
    SCIENCE & EDUCATION, 2023, 32 (03) : 689 - 736
  • [29] Examining Elementary Students' Development of Oral and Written Argumentation Practices Through Argument-Based Inquiry
    Chen, Ying-Chih
    Hand, Brian
    Park, Soonhye
    SCIENCE & EDUCATION, 2016, 25 (3-4) : 277 - 320
  • [30] Argument-based applications to knowledge engineering
    Carbogim, DV
    Robertson, D
    Lee, J
    KNOWLEDGE ENGINEERING REVIEW, 2000, 15 (02): : 119 - 149