Economic knowledge and the scientization of policy advice

被引:31
|
作者
Christensen, Johan [1 ]
机构
[1] Leiden Univ, Inst Publ Adm, POB 13228, NL-2501 EE The Hague, Netherlands
关键词
Economics profession; Expertise; Knowledge; Policy advice; Policy advisory systems; Advisory commissions; Scientization; ADVISORY SYSTEMS; EUROPEAN-UNION; DYNAMICS; EXTERNALIZATION; POLITICIZATION;
D O I
10.1007/s11077-018-9316-6
中图分类号
C93 [管理学]; D035 [国家行政管理]; D523 [行政管理]; D63 [国家行政管理];
学科分类号
12 ; 1201 ; 1202 ; 120202 ; 1204 ; 120401 ;
摘要
The growing role of economic expertise in contemporary policy-making has received increasing scholarly attention. Yet, so far, this discussion has only been tenuously linked to relevant debates in public policy and administration, such as the work on policy advisory systems. The article attempts to bridge this gap by examining the changing reliance on academic economic knowledge within policy advisory bodies. It does so by analysing appointments and citation patterns in Norwegian advisory commissions in economic policy over the last 45 years. The analysis shows a marked increase in the number of academic economists appointed to commissions and in citations to economic literature. Moreover, it reveals an orientation towards the most prestigious outlets of the international economics discipline. This development can be interpreted as a scientization of policy advice in the economic field, that is, a growing reliance on academic expertise for analysis and arguments about public policy.
引用
收藏
页码:291 / 311
页数:21
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] Knowledge rationales in human geography: Economic, policy, empowerment, and methodological
    Hautala, Johanna
    Hoyssa, Maria
    NORSK GEOGRAFISK TIDSSKRIFT-NORWEGIAN JOURNAL OF GEOGRAPHY, 2017, 71 (05) : 269 - 287
  • [42] How Heterodox is the Mainstream? Economic Theory and Economic Policy Advice in the English-speaking Area Survey by the journal INTERVENTION
    Niechoj, Torsten
    Arestis, Philip
    Bauder, Harald
    Bhaduri, Amit
    Collignon, Stefan
    Davidson, Paul
    Fontana, Giuseppe
    Lee, Frederic S.
    O'Hara, Phillip Anthony
    EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS AND ECONOMIC POLICIES-INTERVENTION, 2007, 4 (01): : 7 - 12
  • [43] GOVERNMENTS RESEARCH POLICY AND ECONOMIC-GROWTH - CAPITAL, KNOWLEDGE AND ECONOMIC-STRUCTURE
    ZHANG, WB
    RESEARCH POLICY, 1993, 22 (04) : 327 - 336
  • [44] For a policy of first resort advice
    Couve, Marine
    Buxeraud, Jacques
    ACTUALITES PHARMACEUTIQUES, 2021, 60 (606): : 31 - 34
  • [45] Policy advice as an investment problem
    Heine, K
    Mause, K
    KYKLOS, 2004, 57 (03) : 403 - 427
  • [46] Policy advice and Lobbying in Brussels
    Fischer, Alex
    SWISS POLITICAL SCIENCE REVIEW, 2011, 17 (01) : 92 - 95
  • [47] Bioethics and (public) policy advice
    Schüklenk, U
    Lott, JP
    BIOETHICS IN A SMALL WORLD, 2005, 24 : 129 - 138
  • [48] EVALUATING POLICY ADVICE - A COMMENT
    EDWARDS, M
    AUSTRALIAN JOURNAL OF PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION, 1992, 51 (04) : 447 - 449
  • [49] Decision markets for policy advice
    Hanson, Robin
    Promoting the General Welfare: New Perspectives on Government Performance, 2006, : 151 - 173
  • [50] Policy Advice: Demand, Response
    Maeding, Heinrich
    RAUMFORSCHUNG UND RAUMORDNUNG, 2005, 63 (06) : 462 - 463