Comparison of Online Learning Video Platforms Regarding Laparoscopic Adrenalectomy: YouTube and WebSurg

被引:5
|
作者
Citgez, Bulent [1 ]
Aygun, Nurcihan [1 ]
Yigit, Banu [1 ]
Uludag, Mehmet [1 ]
机构
[1] Hlth Sci Univ, Sisli Hamidiye Etfal Training & Res Hosp, Dept Gen Surg, Istanbul, Turkey
关键词
internet; YouTube; WebSurg; laparoscopic adrenalectomy; surgical education; MEDICAL INFORMATION; EDUCATIONAL-TOOL; SURGERY; RELIABILITY; GUIDELINES; QUALITY; TUBE;
D O I
10.1089/lap.2021.0187
中图分类号
R61 [外科手术学];
学科分类号
摘要
Background: The internet is a widely used source for receiving medical information. Nevertheless, the quality of data on online platforms is still questioned. Our aim was to compare the laparoscopic adrenalectomy videos published on the two online platforms, WebSurg(R) (WS) and YouTube(R) (YTb) regarding the quality of data, educational power, and accuracy of the sources. Materials and Methods: Most viewed popular visual content returned by YTb in reply to the keyword "laparoscopic adrenalectomy" were involved in the research protocol. The quality of the data, educational power, and the accuracy and reliability of the sources were assessed by applying new scoring systems. A novel scoring method estimated technical quality. The 10 most viewed videos in the WS were compared with 10 YTb videos with the highest technical scores. Results: Scoring systems measuring the quality of data and educational power of the mostly viewed WS visual content revealed higher scores than those of the most technically qualified 10 YTb videos (10 videos having the highest laparoscopic adrenalectomy scoring system scores [LASS-S]; P = .021; P = .003; P = .025, respectively). Also, there was no significant difference between the top 10 most viewed WS videos and 10 YTb videos having the highest LASS-S in terms of LASS-S (P = .34). Conclusions: Although WS videos were passed through a professional reviewing process, and were mostly provided by academicians, they remained below the expected quality. The presented research showed that attentively chosen YTb content on laparoscopic adrenalectomy is almost as accurate as WS content. Notwithstanding all its limitations, the informative power or potential of YTb should not be neglected.
引用
收藏
页码:366 / 371
页数:6
相关论文
共 34 条
  • [21] Laparoendoscopic single-site adrenalectomy versus conventional laparoscopic adrenalectomy: a comparison of surgical outcomes and an analysis of a single surgeon's learning curve
    Hirasawa, Yosuke
    Miyajima, Akira
    Hattori, Seiya
    Miyashita, Kazutoshi
    Kurihara, Isao
    Shibata, Hirotaka
    Kikuchi, Eiji
    Nakagawa, Ken
    Oya, Mototsugu
    SURGICAL ENDOSCOPY AND OTHER INTERVENTIONAL TECHNIQUES, 2014, 28 (10): : 2911 - 2919
  • [22] An Analytical Study on the Importance and Performance of Factors of Online Video Usage: Focusing on the Comparison of Chinese and Korean Platforms
    Park, So-Hyun
    Kim, Seung-Chul
    Lee, Tae-Won
    JOURNAL OF KOREA TRADE, 2022, 26 (07): : 145 - 166
  • [23] Do social features help in video-centric online learning platforms? A social presence perspective
    Andel, Stephanie A.
    de Vreede, Triparna
    Spector, Paul E.
    Padmanabhan, Balaji
    Singh, Vivek K.
    De Vreede, Gert-Jan
    COMPUTERS IN HUMAN BEHAVIOR, 2020, 113
  • [24] Identifying Political Sentiments on YouTube: A Systematic Comparison Regarding the Accuracy of Recurrent Neural Network and Machine Learning Models
    Roechert, Daniel
    Neubaum, German
    Stieglitz, Stefan
    DISINFORMATION IN OPEN ONLINE MEDIA, MISDOOM 2020, 2020, 12259 : 107 - 121
  • [25] A Comparison of Online, Video Synchronous, and Traditional Learning Modes for an Introductory Undergraduate Physics Course
    Faulconer, E. K.
    Griffith, J.
    Wood, B.
    Acharyya, S.
    Roberts, D.
    JOURNAL OF SCIENCE EDUCATION AND TECHNOLOGY, 2018, 27 (05) : 404 - 411
  • [26] A Comparison of Online, Video Synchronous, and Traditional Learning Modes for an Introductory Undergraduate Physics Course
    E. K. Faulconer
    J. Griffith
    B. Wood
    S. Acharyya
    D. Roberts
    Journal of Science Education and Technology, 2018, 27 : 404 - 411
  • [27] Comparative evaluation of learning technologies using a randomized controlled trial: Virtual reality, augmented reality, online video platforms, and traditional classroom learning
    Wiafe, Isaac
    Ekpezu, Akon Obu
    Gyamera, Gifty Oforiwaa
    Winful, Fiifi Baffoe Payin
    Atsakpo, Elikem Doe
    Nutropkor, Charles
    Gulliver, Stephen
    EDUCATION AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES, 2025,
  • [28] Desktop-based virtual reality social platforms versus video conferencing platforms for online synchronous learning in higher education: An experimental study to evaluate students' learning gains and user experience
    Di Natale, Anna Flavia
    Repetto, Claudia
    Villani, Daniela
    JOURNAL OF COMPUTER ASSISTED LEARNING, 2024, 40 (06) : 3454 - 3473
  • [29] The Comparison of Undergraduate Student's Learning Achievement of Open Video Online in Business Statistics Course
    Ratanothayanon, Kosawat
    PROCEEDINGS OF 2018 5TH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON BUSINESS AND INDUSTRIAL RESEARCH (ICBIR): SMART TECHNOLOGY FOR NEXT GENERATION OF INFORMATION, ENGINEERING, BUSINESS AND SOCIAL SCIENCE, 2018, : 550 - 554
  • [30] A COMPARISON OF BUSINESS STUDENT PERCEPTIONS IN KAZAKHSTAN AND THE UNITED STATES REGARDING WAYS TO ENHANCE THE ONLINE LEARNING PROCESS
    Colvin, Randy G.
    Delcoure, Natalya
    Krueger, Thomas M.
    Singh, Harmeet
    JOURNAL OF EASTERN EUROPEAN AND CENTRAL ASIAN RESEARCH, 2023, 10 (02): : 251 - 263