Neurocentrism and Name-Calling: Let's Agree to Agree. Reply to Satel & Lilienfeld

被引：0
|
作者：
Lewis, Marc [1 ]
机构：
[1] Univ Toronto, Dev Psychol, 27 Kings Coll Cir, Toronto, ON M5S, Canada
来源：
NEUROETHICS | 2017年 / 10卷 / 01期
关键词：
Enough fruitless debates; Levels of explanation; Neurocentrism" not; Use of "disease" nomenclature; Neurobiology doesn't mean pathology;
D O I：
10.1007/s12152-017-9325-8
中图分类号：
B82 [伦理学（道德学）];
学科分类号：
摘要：
Although these authors sometimes resort to medical terminology, we strongly agree that addiction is not a disease and that the Brain Disease Model of Addiction (BDMA) captures only one part of the story and distorts the big picture. Yet Satel and Lilienfeld continue to conflate a neurobiological model (such as mine) with a disease model. They also complain that my modeling of addiction reveals a hidden "neurocentric" bias, despite my integration of multiple levels of analysis, exactly as they recommend.
引用
收藏
页码：25 / 27
页数：3
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] That's not how you agree: A reply to Zeijlstra
    Preminger, Omer
    LINGUISTIC REVIEW, 2013, 30 (03): : 491 - 500
  • [22] Science and Industry: Let's Agree on Goals and Shared Wins
    Aaltonen, Pamela
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, 2019, 109 (07) : 949 - 949
  • [23] Let’s not agree to disagree: the role of strategic disagreement in science
    Carlos Santana
    Synthese, 2021, 198 : 6159 - 6177
  • [24] Let's not agree to disagree: the role of strategic disagreement in science
    Santana, Carlos
    SYNTHESE, 2021, 198 (SUPPL 25) : 6159 - 6177
  • [25] Let's Agree to Disagree: A Strategy for Trade-Security
    Pinchis-Paulsen, Mona
    JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL ECONOMIC LAW, 2022, 25 (04) : 527 - 547
  • [26] Uncivil Name-Calling in the U.S. Presidency, 1933-2018
    Coe, Kevin
    Park-Ozee, Dakota
    PRESIDENTIAL STUDIES QUARTERLY, 2020, 50 (02) : 264 - 285
  • [27] Chasing Pulmonary Emboli: Let's Agree on One Big Thing
    Stern, Robert G.
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2013, 126 (01): : 3 - 3
  • [28] Don't You Agree with My Ethics? Let's Negotiate!
    Memon, Mashal Afzal
    Scoccia, Gian Luca
    Inverardi, Paola
    Autili, Marco
    HHAI 2023: AUGMENTING HUMAN INTELLECT, 2023, 368 : 385 - 388
  • [29] Let's agree to disagree: Partisan strategies in the Argentinean primary elections
    Santoro, Ignacio
    ICONOS, 2024, 28 (79): : 167 - 184
  • [30] Let's Agree to Disagree: Learning Highly Debatable Multirater Labelling
    Sudre, Carole H.
    Anson, Beatriz Gomez
    Ingala, Silvia
    Lane, Chris D.
    Jimenez, Daniel
    Haider, Lukas
    Varsavsky, Thomas
    Tanno, Ryutaro
    Smith, Lorna
    Ourselin, Sebastien
    Jager, Rolf H.
    Cardoso, M. Jorge
    MEDICAL IMAGE COMPUTING AND COMPUTER ASSISTED INTERVENTION - MICCAI 2019, PT IV, 2019, 11767 : 665 - 673
12345