Comparison of "bottom-up" and "top-down" strategies for the estimation of the uncertainty in organic elemental analysis

The estimation of uncertainty in organic elemental analysis for C, H, N and S is reported. Both "bottom up" and "top down" strategies are used for uncertainty calculations. The bottom up approach used the results of C, H, N, and S obtained from the homogeneity study of two pure chemicals (toluene-4-sulfonamide and 4(6)-methyl-2-thiouracil). Two calibration systems, K factor and calibration curve, were applied in this study and no significant differences were obtained. For the "top down" approach, we used the data obtained from a proficiency test on both pure chemicals from among 45 Spanish laboratories. Both approaches are compared and discussed below.