Evaluation of the reporting quality of guidelines for gastric cancer using the RIGHT checklist

被引:5
|
作者
Wu, Xuan [1 ]
Li, Ding [2 ]
Chen, Haiyang [1 ]
Han, Jing [1 ]
Zhou, Hanqiong [1 ]
He, Zhen [1 ]
Ma, Yanfang [3 ]
Dong, Bingqi [4 ]
Wu, Yingxi [1 ]
Matkowskyj, Kristina A. [5 ]
Ejaz, Aslam [6 ]
Almhanna, Khaldoun [7 ]
Wang, Qiming [1 ]
机构
[1] Zhengzhou Univ, Dept Internal Med, Henan Canc Hosp, 127 Dong Ming Rd, Zhengzhou 450008, Henan, Peoples R China
[2] Zhengzhou Univ, Dept Pharm, Henan Canc Hosp, Zhengzhou, Peoples R China
[3] Hong Kong Baptist Univ, Sch Chinese Med, Hong Kong, Peoples R China
[4] Zhengzhou Univ, Henan Canc Hosp, Affiliated Canc Hosp, Dept Urol, Zhengzhou, Peoples R China
[5] Univ Wisconsin, Carbone Canc Ctr, Dept Pathol & Lab Med, Madison, WI USA
[6] Ohio State Univ, Comprehens Canc Ctr, Div Surg Oncol, Columbus, OH 43210 USA
[7] Brown Univ, Rhode Isl Hosp, Div Hematol Oncol, Warren Alpert Med Sch,Lifespan Canc Inst, Providence, RI 02903 USA
关键词
Gastric cancer; Reporting Items for Practice Guidelines in Healthcare (RIGHT); practice guideline; reporting quality; CLINICAL-PRACTICE GUIDELINES; ASSOCIATION; APPRAISAL;
D O I
10.21037/atm-21-2491
中图分类号
R73 [肿瘤学];
学科分类号
100214 ;
摘要
Background: Gastric cancer is the fifth most common type of cancer globally. We aimed to evaluate the reporting quality of clinical practice guidelines in the field of gastric cancer. Methods: We searched Medline (via PubMed), China Biology Medicine, Chinese National Knowledge Infrastructure and WanFang databases and the websites of the main guideline development organizations from 2018 to 2020 for guidelines on gastric cancer. Data were extracted and the reporting quality evaluated by two researchers independently using the Reporting Items for Practice Guidelines in Healthcare (RIGHT) checklist. We assessed the compliance of the guidelines to each of the 35 items of RIGHT and summarized the reporting proportions of the seven domains of RIGHT. Results: Eighteen guidelines were included. The mean proportion of appropriately reported RIGHT items was 52.4%. Among the seven domains of the RIGHT checklist, Basic information had the highest reporting rate (78.7%), and Review and quality assurance domain the lowest rate (16.7%). The domains Evidence (40.0%), Funding and declaration and management of interests (43.1%), and Other information (31.5%) had also reporting rates below 50%. Two RIGHT items (17 and 19b) were not reported by any of the guidelines. Conclusions: The reporting quality of gastric cancer guidelines published in the years 2018-2020 was suboptimal, especially regarding the reporting of review, quality assurance and evidence. Guideline developers should pay attention on rigorous reporting following international standard to improve the quality of guidelines.
引用
收藏
页数:13
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Reporting quality of practice guidelines on colorectal cancer: evaluation using the RIGHT reporting checklist
    Han, Jing
    Tao, Meng
    Wu, Xuan
    Li, Ding
    Ma, Yanfang
    Dawood, Shaheenah
    Steele, Colin W.
    Tan, Ker-Kan
    Wang, Qiming
    [J]. ANNALS OF TRANSLATIONAL MEDICINE, 2021, 9 (14)
  • [2] Evaluation of the reporting quality of clinical practice guidelines on prostate cancer using the RIGHT checklist
    Liu, Kefeng
    Ma, Yanfang
    Yang, Yongjie
    Lu, Jingli
    Zhao, Jie
    Du, Shuzhang
    Zhang, Xuepei
    Liu, Chunlei
    Del Giudice, Francesco
    Shiota, Masaki
    Hatakeyama, Shingo
    Zhang, Xiaojian
    Kang, Jian
    [J]. ANNALS OF TRANSLATIONAL MEDICINE, 2021, 9 (14)
  • [3] Evaluation of the reporting quality of clinical practice guidelines on pancreatic cancer using the RIGHT checklist
    Zhang, Qiwen
    Lu, Jingli
    Jia, Mengmeng
    Ma, Yanfang
    Sun, Mingyang
    Chen, Xiaoxu
    Ma, Xiaohua
    Yang, Yongjie
    Kang, Jian
    Zhang, Xiaojian
    Paiella, Salvatore
    Katz, Matthew H. G.
    Tsuchida, Kunihiro
    Schattner, Mark
    Du, Shuzhang
    [J]. ANNALS OF TRANSLATIONAL MEDICINE, 2021, 9 (13)
  • [4] Evaluation of the reporting quality of clinical practice guidelines on lung cancer using the RIGHT checklist
    Yang, Yongjie
    Lu, Jingli
    Ma, Yanfang
    Xi, Chen
    Kang, Jian
    Zhang, Qiwen
    Jia, Xuedong
    Liu, Kefeng
    Du, Shuzhang
    Kocher, Florian
    Seeber, Andreas
    Gridelli, Cesare
    Provencio, Mariano
    Seki, Nobuhiko
    Tomita, Yusuke
    Zhang, Xiaojian
    [J]. TRANSLATIONAL LUNG CANCER RESEARCH, 2021, 10 (06) : 2588 - +
  • [5] Evaluation of the reporting quality of clinical practice guidelines on gliomas using the RIGHT checklist
    Yang, Yongjie
    Ma, Yanfang
    Lu, Jingli
    Du, Shuzhang
    Zhang, Jingmin
    Meng, Haiyang
    Chen, Zhe
    Zhang, Qiwen
    Zhang, Xiaojian
    Shi, Wenyin
    Girolamo, Francesco
    Cepeda, Santiago
    Kang, Jian
    [J]. ANNALS OF TRANSLATIONAL MEDICINE, 2021, 9 (12)
  • [6] Evaluation of the reporting quality of clinical practice guidelines on melanoma using the RIGHT checklist
    Yang, Yongjie
    Ma, Yanfang
    Lu, Jingli
    Zhang, Qiwen
    Guan, Kelei
    Liu, Kefeng
    kang, Jian
    Du, Shuzhang
    Tang, Shu
    Liu, Xuehui
    Zhang, Ailing
    Schadendorf, Dirk
    Agarwala, Sanjiv S.
    Zhang, Xiaojian
    [J]. ANNALS OF TRANSLATIONAL MEDICINE, 2021, 9 (14)
  • [7] A reporting quality evaluation of the clinical practice guidelines for bladder cancer based on the RIGHT checklist
    Cheng, Cheng
    Wu, Xuan
    Song, Wenping
    Li, Dongbei
    Hao, Lidan
    Li, Xiaojing
    Zhang, Wenzhou
    Li, Ding
    [J]. TRANSLATIONAL ANDROLOGY AND UROLOGY, 2022, : 1586 - 1597
  • [8] An evaluation of the reporting quality in clinical practice guidelines for hepatocellular carcinoma using the RIGHT checklist
    Chen, Haiyang
    Tao, Meng
    Li, Ding
    Han, Jing
    Cheng, Cheng
    Ma, Yanfang
    Wu, Yingxi
    Shelat, Vishal G.
    Tustumi, Francisco
    Satapathy, Sanjaya K.
    Kang, Koo Jeong
    Wang, Qiming
    [J]. ANNALS OF TRANSLATIONAL MEDICINE, 2021, 9 (12)
  • [9] Evaluation of reporting quality in clinical practice guidelines for acute myeloid leukemia using the RIGHT checklist
    Li, Ding
    Cheng, Cheng
    Wang, Ziming
    Zhang, Yi
    Li, Dongbei
    Song, Wenping
    He, Baoxia
    Wu, Xuan
    Zhang, Wenzhou
    [J]. ANNALS OF TRANSLATIONAL MEDICINE, 2021, 9 (18)
  • [10] A quality evaluation of the clinical practice guidelines on breast cancer using the RIGHT checklist
    Zhou, Hanqiong
    Chen, Haiyang
    Cheng, Cheng
    Wu, Xuan
    Ma, Yanfang
    Han, Jing
    Li, Ding
    Lim, Geok Hoon
    Rozen, Warren M.
    Ishii, Naohiro
    Roy, Pankaj G.
    Wang, Qiming
    [J]. ANNALS OF TRANSLATIONAL MEDICINE, 2021, 9 (14)