Saliva is a reliable and accessible source for the detection of SARS-CoV-2

被引:45
|
作者
Herrera, Luis A. [1 ,2 ]
Hidalgo-Miranda, Alfredo [3 ]
Reynoso-Noveron, Nancy [2 ]
Meneses-Garcia, Abelardo A. [4 ]
Mendoza-Vargas, Alfredo [5 ]
Reyes-Grajeda, Juan P. [5 ]
Vadillo-Ortega, Felipe [6 ]
Cedro-Tanda, Alberto [1 ]
Penaloza, Fernando [2 ]
Frias-Jimenez, Emmanuel [1 ]
Arriaga-Canon, Cristian [2 ]
Ruiz, Rosaura [7 ]
Angulo, Ofelia [7 ]
Lopez-Villasenor, Imelda [8 ]
Amador-Bedolla, Carlos [9 ]
Vilar-Compte, Diana [4 ]
Cornejo, Patricia [4 ]
Cisneros-Villanueva, Mireya [3 ]
Hurtado-Cordova, Eduardo [3 ]
Cendejas-Orozco, Mariana [3 ]
Hernandez-Morales, Jose S. [5 ]
Moreno, Bernardo [2 ]
Hernandez-Cruz, Irwin A. [2 ]
Herrera, Cesar A. [2 ]
Garcia, Francisco [2 ]
Gonzalez-Woge, Miguel A. [2 ]
Munguia-Garza, Paulina [2 ]
Luna-Maldonado, Fernando [2 ]
Sanchez-Vizcarra, Antonia [2 ]
Osnaya, Vincent G. [2 ]
Medina-Molotla, Nelly [5 ]
Alfaro-Mora, Yair [2 ]
Caceres-Gutierrez, Rodrigo E. [2 ]
Tolentino-Garcia, Laura [2 ]
Rosas-Escobar, Patricia [5 ]
Roman-Gonzalez, Sergio A. [1 ]
Escobar-Arrazola, Marco A. [2 ]
Canseco-Mendez, Julio C. [5 ]
Ortiz-Soriano, Diana R. [1 ]
Dominguez-Ortiz, Julieta [2 ]
Gonzalez-Barrera, Ana D. [1 ]
Aparicio-Bautista, Diana, I [1 ]
Cruz-Rangel, Armando [1 ]
Alarcon-Zendejas, Ana Paula [2 ]
Contreras-Espinosa, Laura [2 ]
Gonzalez, Rodrigo [2 ]
Guerra-Calderas, Lissania [2 ]
Meraz-Rodriguez, Marco A. [2 ]
Montalvo-Casimiro, Michel [2 ]
Montiel-Manriquez, Rogelio [2 ]
机构
[1] Inst Nacl Med Genom, INMEGEN, Mexico City, DF, Mexico
[2] Univ Nacl Autonoma Mexico, Inst Nacl Cancerol, Inst Invest Biomed, Unidad Invest Biomed Canc, Mexico City, DF, Mexico
[3] Inst Nacl Med Genom, Lab Genom Canc, INMEGEN, Mexico City, DF, Mexico
[4] Inst Nacl Cancerol, INCAN, Unidad Secuenciac, Mexico City, DF, Mexico
[5] Inst Nacl Med Genom, INMEGEN, Unidad Secuenciac, Mexico City, DF, Mexico
[6] INMEGEN, Unidad Vinculac Cient Fac Med, Mexico City, DF, Mexico
[7] Secretaria Educ Ciencia Tecnol & Innovat, Mexico City, DF, Mexico
[8] Univ Nacl Autonoma Mexico, Inst Invest Biomed, Mexico City, DF, Mexico
[9] Univ Nacl Autonoma Mexico, Fac Quim, Dept Fis & Quim Teor, Mexico City, DF, Mexico
[10] Unidad Temporal COVID 19, Mexico City, DF, Mexico
[11] Unidad Invest Preclin, Fac Quim, Mexico City, DF, Mexico
[12] Univ Nacl Autonoma Mexico, Fac Quim, Dept Alimentos & Biotecnol, Mexico City, DF, Mexico
[13] Inst Diagnost & Referencia Epidemiol, InDRE, Mexico City, DF, Mexico
关键词
COVID-19; SARS-CoV-2; Diagnostic test; Saliva testing; Pooling strategy;
D O I
10.1016/j.ijid.2021.02.009
中图分类号
R51 [传染病];
学科分类号
100401 ;
摘要
Objectives: The aim of this study was to investigate the feasibility of saliva sampling as a non-invasive and safer tool to detect severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) and to compare its reproducibility and sensitivity with nasopharyngeal swab samples (NPS). The use of sample pools was also investigated. Methods: A total of 2107 paired samples were collected from asymptomatic healthcare and office workers in Mexico City. Sixty of these samples were also analyzed in two other independent laboratories for concordance analysis. Sample processing and analysis of virus genetic material were performed according to standard protocols described elsewhere. A pooling analysis was performed by analyzing the saliva pool and the individual pool components. Results: The concordance between NPS and saliva results was 95.2% (kappa 0.727, p = 0.0001) and 97.9% without considering inconclusive results (kappa 0.852, p = 0.0001). Saliva had a lower number of inconclusive results than NPS (0.9% vs 1.9%). Furthermore, saliva showed a significantly higher concentration of both total RNA and viral copies than NPS. Comparison of our results with those of the other two laboratories showed 100% and 97% concordance. Saliva samples are stable without the use of any preservative, and a positive SARS-CoV-2 sample can be detected 5, 10, and 15 days after collection when the sample is stored at 4 degrees C. Conclusions: The study results indicate that saliva is as effective as NPS for the identification of SARS-CoV-2-infected asymptomatic patients. Sample pooling facilitates the analysis of a larger number of samples, with the benefit of cost reduction. (C) 2021 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Ltd on behalf of International Society for Infectious Diseases.
引用
收藏
页码:83 / 90
页数:8
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] A Community Study of SARS-CoV-2 Detection by RT-PCR in Saliva: A Reliable and Effective Method
    Fronza, Filippo
    Groff, Nelli
    Martinelli, Angela
    Passerini, Beatrice Zita
    Rensi, Nicolo
    Cortelletti, Irene
    Vivori, Nicolo
    Adami, Valentina
    Helander, Anna
    Bridi, Simone
    Pancher, Michael
    Greco, Valentina
    Garritano, Sonia Iolanda
    Piffer, Elena
    Stefani, Lara
    De Sanctis, Veronica
    Bertorelli, Roberto
    Pancheri, Serena
    Collini, Lucia
    Dassi, Erik
    Quattrone, Alessandro
    Capobianchi, Maria Rosaria
    Icardi, Giancarlo
    Poli, Guido
    Caciagli, Patrizio
    Ferro, Antonio
    Pizzato, Massimo
    [J]. VIRUSES-BASEL, 2022, 14 (02):
  • [22] Comparison of SARS-CoV-2 detection in nasopharyngeal swab and saliva
    Iwasaki, Sumio
    Fujisawa, Shinichi
    Nakakubo, Sho
    Kamada, Keisuke
    Yamashita, Yu
    Fukumoto, Tatsuya
    Sato, Kaori
    Oguri, Satoshi
    Taki, Keisuke
    Senjo, Hajime
    Sugita, Junichi
    Hayasaka, Kasumi
    Konno, Satoshi
    Nishida, Mutsumi
    Teshima, Takanori
    [J]. JOURNAL OF INFECTION, 2020, 81 (02) : E145 - E147
  • [23] Serial semiquantitative detection of SARS-CoV-2 in saliva samples
    Mao, Ming-Hui
    Guo, Jing-Jing
    Qin, Li-Zheng
    Han, Zheng-Xue
    Wang, Ya-Jie
    Yang, Di
    [J]. JOURNAL OF INFECTION, 2021, 82 (03) : 446 - 448
  • [24] Saliva as a possible tool for the SARS-CoV-2 detection: A review
    Medeiros da Silva, Regia Carla
    Nogueira Marinho, Liliane Cristina
    de Araujo Silva, Davi Neto
    de Lima, Kenio Costa
    Pirih, Flavia Queiroz
    Luz de Aquino Martins, Ana Rafaela
    [J]. TRAVEL MEDICINE AND INFECTIOUS DISEASE, 2020, 38
  • [25] Saliva or Nasopharyngeal Swab Specimens for Detection of SARS-CoV-2
    Wyllie, Anne L.
    Fournier, John
    Casanovas-Massana, Arnau
    Campbell, Melissa
    Tokuyama, Maria
    Vijayakumar, Pavithra
    Warren, Joshua L.
    Geng, Bertie
    Muenker, M. Catherine
    Moore, Adam J.
    Vogels, Chantal B. F.
    Petrone, Mary E.
    Ott, Isabel M.
    Lu, Peiwen
    Venkataraman, Arvind
    Lu-Culligan, Alice
    Klein, Jonathan
    Earnest, Rebecca
    Simonov, Michael
    Datta, Rupak
    Handoko, Ryan
    Naushad, Nida
    Sewanan, Lorenzo R.
    Valdez, Jordan
    White, Elizabeth B.
    Lapidus, Sarah
    Kalinich, Chaney C.
    Jiang, Xiaodong
    Kim, Daniel J.
    Kudo, Eriko
    Linehan, Melissa
    Mao, Tianyang
    Moriyama, Miyu
    Oh, Ji E.
    Park, Annsea
    Silva, Julio
    Song, Eric
    Takahashi, Takehiro
    Taura, Manabu
    Weizman, Orr-El
    Wong, Patrick
    Yang, Yexin
    Bermejo, Santos
    Odio, Camila D.
    Omer, Saad B.
    Dela Cruz, Charles S.
    Farhadian, Shelli
    Martinello, Richard A.
    Iwasaki, Akiko
    Grubaugh, Nathan D.
    [J]. NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2020, 383 (13): : 1283 - 1286
  • [26] Salivary glands are a target for SARS-CoV-2: a source for saliva contamination
    Matuck, Bruno Fernandes
    Dolhnikoff, Marisa
    Duarte-Neto, Amaro Nunes
    Maia, Gilvan
    Gomes, Sara Costa
    Sendyk, Daniel Isaac
    Zarpellon, Amanda
    de Andrade, Nathalia Paiva
    Monteiro, Renata Aparecida
    Pinho, Joao Renato Rebello
    Gomes-Gouvea, Michele Soares
    Souza, Suzana C. O. M.
    Kanamura, Cristina
    Mauad, Thais
    Saldiva, Paulo Hilario Nascimento
    Braz-Silva, Paulo H.
    Caldini, Elia Garcia
    da Silva, Luiz Fernando Ferraz
    [J]. JOURNAL OF PATHOLOGY, 2021, 254 (03): : 239 - 243
  • [27] Practical challenges to the clinical implementation of saliva for SARS-CoV-2 detection
    Matic, Nancy
    Stefanovic, Aleksandra
    Leung, Victor
    Lawson, Tanya
    Ritchie, Gordon
    Li, Lynne
    Champagne, Sylvie
    Romney, Marc G.
    Lowe, Christopher F.
    [J]. EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF CLINICAL MICROBIOLOGY & INFECTIOUS DISEASES, 2021, 40 (02) : 447 - 450
  • [28] SARS-CoV-2 Omicron detection by antigen tests using saliva
    Murakami, Kaoru
    Iwasaki, Sumio
    Oguri, Satoshi
    Tanaka, Kumiko
    Suzuki, Rigel
    Hayasaka, Kasumi
    Fujisawa, Shinichi
    Watanabe, Chiaki
    Konno, Satoshi
    Yokota, Isao
    Fukuhara, Takasuke
    Murakami, Masaaki
    Teshima, Takanori
    [J]. JOURNAL OF CLINICAL VIROLOGY PLUS, 2022, 2 (04):
  • [29] Saliva as a gold-standard sample for SARS-CoV-2 detection
    Tan, Steph H.
    Allicock, Orchid
    Armstrong-Hough, Mari
    Wyllie, Anne L.
    [J]. LANCET RESPIRATORY MEDICINE, 2021, 9 (06): : 562 - 564
  • [30] Saliva as a diagnostic specimen for SARS-CoV-2 detection: A scoping review
    Wang, Yifei
    Upadhyay, Akshaya
    Pillai, Sangeeth
    Khayambashi, Parisa
    Tran, Simon D.
    [J]. ORAL DISEASES, 2022, 28 : 2362 - 2390