On the compatibility of a conservation ethic with biological science

被引:9
|
作者
Sagoff, Mark [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Maryland, Inst Philosophy & Publ Policy, College Pk, MD 20817 USA
关键词
aesthetics; conservation ethics; Darwinism; theology;
D O I
10.1111/j.1523-1739.2006.00634.x
中图分类号
X176 [生物多样性保护];
学科分类号
090705 ;
摘要
If value entails or implies purpose, it follows that natural objects (e.g., endangered species) lack value and thus cannot be worth protecting except for a purpose they may serve-either the end for which God created the world (according to natural theology) or some use to which human beings may put them (according to a consequentialist or utilitarian ethic). If value requires purpose, the refutation of natural theology after Darwin implies that humanity has no obligation to respect or preserve the natural world except insofar as it is economically efficient to do so. Drawing on the distinction between explanation and communication found in Calvinist theology, I argue that value does not entail purpose. The expressive, aesthetic, or communicative aspects of nature may be valuable or endow natural objects with value apart from any use or purpose these objects may serve. The crucial distinction between explanation and communication-one scientific, the other aestbetic-offers a rationale for an obligation to protect the natural world that may appeal to members of faith communities and to biologists and other scientists. This approach also helps resolve the "lurking inconsistency" some scholars see in the relationship between a deterministic biological science and a conservationist ethic.
引用
收藏
页码:337 / 345
页数:9
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Chaos: Without a Conservation Ethic for Water
    Schwartz, Franklin W.
    GROUND WATER, 2012, 50 (06) : 819 - 819
  • [22] Compassion as a Practical and Evolved Ethic for Conservation
    Ramp, Daniel
    Bekoff, Marc
    BIOSCIENCE, 2015, 65 (03) : 323 - 327
  • [23] TOWARD A MATERIALS-CONSERVATION ETHIC
    KELLOGG, HH
    METALLURGICAL TRANSACTIONS B-PROCESS METALLURGY, 1978, 9 (04): : 491 - 500
  • [24] Metaphor and the Idea of a Dominant Conservation Ethic
    Martin, Laura
    CONSERVATION BIOLOGY, 2010, 24 (05) : 1172 - 1173
  • [25] CONSERVATION BIOLOGY AND THE EVOLUTION OF A LAND ETHIC
    GAWLIK, DE
    JOURNAL OF RAPTOR RESEARCH, 1992, 26 (03) : 179 - 183
  • [26] The Land Ethic and conservation of native salmonids
    Piccolo, John J.
    ECOLOGY OF FRESHWATER FISH, 2017, 26 (01) : 160 - 164
  • [27] MARKETING THE CONSERVATION-RESTORATION ETHIC
    MILLER, PT
    LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE, 1983, 73 (02): : 86 - 87
  • [28] Modern Science and the Ethic World
    Tian Song
    UNIVERSITAS-MONTHLY REVIEW OF PHILOSOPHY AND CULTURE, 2011, 38 (04): : 175 - 180
  • [29] What Are ILK in Relation to Science? Using the 'Ethic of Equivocation' to Co-Produce New Knowledge for Conservation
    Root-Bernstein, Meredith
    du Plessis, Pierre
    Guerrero-Gatica, Matias
    Narayan, Trupthi
    Roturier, Samuel
    Wheeler, Helen C.
    SUSTAINABILITY, 2023, 15 (03)
  • [30] Biological invasions: winning the science battles but losing the conservation war?
    Hulme, PE
    ORYX, 2003, 37 (02) : 178 - 193