Can genomics tell me who I am? Essentialistic rhetoric in direct-to-consumer DNA testing

被引:61
|
作者
Nordgren, A. [1 ]
Juengst, E. T. [2 ]
机构
[1] Linkoping Univ, Ctr Appl Eth, Linkoping, Sweden
[2] Case Western Reserve Univ, Dept Bioeth, Cleveland, OH 44106 USA
基金
美国国家卫生研究院;
关键词
consumer genomics; identity; essentialism; RISK; SERVICES; GENETICS; IDENTITY;
D O I
10.1080/14636770902901595
中图分类号
Q81 [生物工程学(生物技术)]; Q93 [微生物学];
学科分类号
071005 ; 0836 ; 090102 ; 100705 ;
摘要
Recently, a high number of companies have emerged that offer online direct-to-consumer DNA testing. We investigate these consumer genomics companies through the lens of identity. We find that many of them appeal to a kind of ogenetic essentialismo. We suggest that this appeal is key to understanding why consumers are attracted to their services. There seem to be three very different currents within contemporary culture at work: the pre-modern search for a naturalistic understanding of identity, the modern enthusiasm for science, and the post-modern emphasis on radical individual self-determination. The support for our hypothesis comes from the companies' websites and the online testimonials of satisfied customers. We discuss the risk of distortion of the subjective experience of identity due to unreliable or uninformative test results, inadequate or misleading explanation, and the fact that the science is still too weak to yield meaningful results.
引用
收藏
页码:157 / 172
页数:16
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] "Trust is not something you can reclaim easily": patenting in the field of direct-to-consumer genetic testing
    Sterckx, Sigrid
    Cockbain, Julian
    Howard, Heidi
    Huys, Isabelle
    Borry, Pascal
    GENETICS IN MEDICINE, 2013, 15 (05) : 382 - 387
  • [32] "I'm trying to figure out who the hell I am": Examining the psychosocial and mental health experience of individuals learning "Not Parent Expected" news from a direct-to-consumer DNA ancestry test
    Careau, Juliette
    Larmuseau, Maarten H. D.
    Drumsta, Rebekah
    Whitley, Rob
    BMC PSYCHIATRY, 2025, 25 (01)
  • [33] Direct-to-consumer DNA testing: the fallout for individuals and their families unexpectedly learning of their donor conception origins
    Crawshaw, Marilyn
    HUMAN FERTILITY, 2018, 21 (04) : 225 - 228
  • [34] THE 3-I FRAMEWORK: CONSIDERATIONS FOR DEVELOPING REGULATIONS FOR DIRECT-TO-CONSUMER GENETIC TESTING IN CANADA
    Cernat, Alexandra
    Bashir, Naazish
    Ungar, Wendy J.
    MEDICAL DECISION MAKING, 2021, 41 (04) : E219 - E220
  • [35] Tell Me What You Drink, I'll Tell You Who You Are: Status and Fashion Effects on Consumer Conformity
    Lana, Jailson
    Barbosa de Souza, Maria Jose
    Lana, Jeferson
    Partyka, Raul Beal
    JOURNAL OF FOOD PRODUCTS MARKETING, 2022, 28 (07) : 295 - 314
  • [36] Direct-to-consumer prenatal testing for multigenic or polygenic disorders: a position statement of the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG)
    ACMG Board of Directors
    GENETICS IN MEDICINE, 2021, 23 (11) : 2027 - 2028
  • [37] Donor conception and Commercial Genomics: how are donor conceived people, their parents and donors using direct-to-consumer genetic testing?
    Frith, L.
    Gilman, L.
    Redhead, C.
    Fox, M.
    Hudson, N.
    MacCallum, F.
    Brown, J. Kirkham
    HUMAN REPRODUCTION, 2022, 37 : I129 - I130
  • [38] Utilization of Genetic Counseling after Direct-to-Consumer Genetic Testing: Findings from the Impact of Personal Genomics (PGen) Study
    Koeller, Diane R.
    Uhlmann, Wendy R.
    Carere, Deanna Alexis
    Green, Robert C.
    Roberts, J. Scott
    JOURNAL OF GENETIC COUNSELING, 2017, 26 (06) : 1270 - 1279
  • [39] Who am I? whom can I love? and why me?: Queer Christians and the spirituality of struggle
    Cornelio, Jayeel S.
    Dagle, Robbin Charles M.
    CRITICAL RESEARCH ON RELIGION, 2024, 12 (03) : 266 - 284