Maxwell and creation: Acceptance, criticism, and his anonymous publication

被引:4
|
作者
Marston, Philip L. [1 ]
机构
[1] Washington State Univ, Dept Phys & Astron, Pullman, WA 99164 USA
关键词
D O I
10.1119/1.2735631
中图分类号
G40 [教育学];
学科分类号
040101 ; 120403 ;
摘要
Although James Clerk Maxwell's religious views and discussions on atoms having the properties of "manufactured articles" have been discussed, some aspects of the responses by his contemporaries to his remarks on creation have been neglected. Various responses quoted here include a book from 1878 by "Physicus" (George John Romanes) attributing "arrogance" to Maxwell for his inferences. Relevant aspects of the evolution of the perspective of Romanes are noted. A response by B. F. Westcott indicated that Maxwell was the author of a related anonymous publication concerned with what eventually became known as the heat death of the universe. In his teaching to theology students, Westcott, a friend of Maxwell, emphasized Maxwell's reasoning based on the dissipation of energy. There are similarities between Maxwell's perspective on creation and Biblical commentaries by fellow Eranus Club members Westcott and J. B. Lightfoot. Interest in Maxwell's remarks extended into the twentieth century. The principal Baptist chapel attended by Maxwell and his wife when in London in the 1860s is identified and some relevant attributes of the chapel and of its pastor are described. (C) 2007 American Association of Physics Teachers.
引用
收藏
页码:731 / 740
页数:10
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] PUBLICATION BIAS VIA SUPPRESSED CRITICISM
    LANDI, G
    CICCONE, A
    LANCET, 1993, 341 (8846): : 697 - 698
  • [32] SAMPAIO,ERNESTO - CRITICISM AS CREATION
    MARTINHO, FJB
    COLOQUIO-LETRAS, 1989, (110-11): : 138 - 141
  • [33] "Do it again!". Criticism and creation
    Escola, Marc
    CUADERNOS LIRICO, 2024, (27)
  • [34] MAXWELL,JC AND HIS WORK
    GRAFFI, D
    ELETTROTECNICA, 1981, 68 (11): : 939 - 943
  • [35] CREATION AND CRITICISM IN THE WORKS OF CASTILLOPUCHE
    EMBEITA, M
    CUADERNOS HISPANOAMERICANOS, 1976, (310): : 205 - 211
  • [36] Artistic Creation and Ethical Criticism
    Jovanovic, Iris Vidmar
    Stupnik, Valentina Marianna
    PROLEGOMENA, 2021, 20 (01): : 156 - 161
  • [37] Artistic Creation and Ethical Criticism
    Bokiniec, Monika
    ESTETIKA-THE EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF AESTHETICS, 2022, 59 (01): : 80 - 84
  • [38] Translation between Criticism and Creation
    Masson, Jean-Yves
    RLC-REVUE DE LITTERATURE COMPAREE, 2019, (369): : 85 - +
  • [39] ON CRITICISM + ART CREATION AND CONSUMPTION
    ABELL, W
    ARTSCANADA, 1982, (244-): : 15 - 16
  • [40] WILDE,OSCAR HIS CRITICISM AND HIS CRITICS
    BASHFORD, B
    ENGLISH LITERATURE IN TRANSITION 1880-1920, 1977, 20 (04) : 181 - 187