This paper describes an investigation into the nonlinear response of flames to harmonic forcing. The am-plitude dependent response of the heat release to imposed forcing plays a key role in determining con-ditions where self-excited oscillations occur, and their amplitudes. This paper particularly focuses on the flame response amplitude. Several prior results, both experimental and theoretical have noted the satu-rating character of the flame response as the disturbance amplitude increases. In addition, some experi-ments have also shown more complex amplitude dependencies, including inflection points and even non monotonic response behaviors. In the latter case, the flame response decreases with increasing disturbance amplitude over a range of amplitudes. This paper analyzes the conditions under which such non-monotonic behavior occurs. By expanding the unsteady heat release response in an expansion of the form, Q(t) = Q(0) + is an element of Q(1) (t) + is an element of(2)Q(2)(t) + is an element of(3) Q(3)(t) + O(is an element of(4)), we show that non-monotonic behavior occurs when the phase be-tween the O(is an element of(3)) term and the linear term fall in a certain band. The model is then applied to representative measured data from the literature where non-monotonic behavior is observed, to extract the different flame response contributions. Finally, results are presented from nonlinear premixed flame calculations to explicitly show the parameter regions where such behavior occurs. (C) 2020 The Combustion Institute. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.