Effect of a Coordinated Community and Chronic Care Model Team Intervention vs Usual Care on Systolic Blood Pressure in Patients With Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack The SUCCEED Randomized Clinical Trial

被引:43
|
作者
Towfighi, Amytis [1 ,2 ,3 ,4 ]
Cheng, Eric M. [5 ]
Ayala-Rivera, Monica [1 ,2 ,3 ,4 ]
Barry, Frances [5 ]
McCreath, Heather [5 ]
Ganz, David A. [5 ,6 ]
Lee, Martin L. [5 ,6 ]
Sanossian, Nerses [1 ,4 ]
Mehta, Bijal [5 ,8 ]
Dutta, Tara [3 ,9 ]
Razmara, Ali [3 ,10 ]
Bryg, Robert [5 ,11 ]
Song, Shlee S. [12 ]
Willis, Phyllis [13 ]
Wu, Shinyi [1 ]
Ramirez, Magaly [14 ]
Richards, Adam [15 ]
Jackson, Nicholas [5 ]
Wacksman, Jeremy [16 ]
Mittman, Brian [6 ,7 ]
Tran, Jamie [8 ]
Johnson, Renee R. [3 ,4 ,17 ]
Ediss, Chris [3 ]
Sivers-Teixeira, Theresa [1 ,3 ,4 ]
Shaby, Betty [11 ]
Montoya, Ana L. [8 ,11 ]
Corrales, Marilyn [3 ,4 ,18 ]
Mojarro-Huang, Elizabeth [1 ,4 ]
Castro, Marissa [3 ,12 ]
Gomez, Patricia [3 ]
Munoz, Cynthia [1 ,3 ]
Garcia, Diamond [3 ,8 ]
Moreno, Lilian [3 ]
Fernandez, Maura [1 ,4 ]
Lopez, Enrique [3 ]
Valdez, Sarah [8 ]
Haber, Hilary R. [16 ,19 ]
Hill, Valerie A. [20 ]
Rao, Neal M. [5 ,11 ]
Martinez, Beatrice [1 ,3 ,4 ,8 ]
Hudson, Lillie [1 ,3 ]
Valle, Natalie P. [21 ]
Vickrey, Barbara G. [22 ]
机构
[1] Univ Southern Calif, Los Angeles, CA 90007 USA
[2] Los Angeles Cty Dept Hlth Serv, Los Angeles, CA USA
[3] Rancho Los Amigos Natl Rehabil Ctr, Downey, CA USA
[4] LAC USC Med Ctr, 1100 N State St, Los Angeles, CA 90033 USA
[5] Univ Calif Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA USA
[6] Vet Affairs Greater Los Angeles Healthcare Syst, Los Angeles, CA USA
[7] Kaiser Permanente, Los Angeles, CA USA
[8] Harbor UCLA Med Ctr, Torrance, CA 90509 USA
[9] Univ Maryland, Baltimore, MD 21201 USA
[10] Kaiser Permanente, Irvine, CA USA
[11] Olive View UCLA Med Ctr, 14445 Olive View Dr, Sylmar, CA 91342 USA
[12] Cedars Sinai Med Ctr, Los Angeles, CA 90048 USA
[13] Watts Lab Community Act Comm, Los Angeles, CA USA
[14] Univ Washington, Sch Publ Hlth, Seattle, WA 98195 USA
[15] Community Partners Int, San Francisco, CA USA
[16] Dimagi, Cambridge, MA USA
[17] Calif State Univ Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA 90032 USA
[18] Univ Calif Riverside, Riverside, CA 92521 USA
[19] Brigham & Womens Hosp, 75 Francis St, Boston, MA 02115 USA
[20] Univ Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH USA
[21] St Jude Med Ctr, Fullerton, CA USA
[22] Icahn Sch Med Mt Sinai, New York, NY 10029 USA
基金
美国国家卫生研究院;
关键词
SELF-MANAGEMENT PROGRAM; IMPROVING PRIMARY-CARE; RISK-FACTORS; CHRONIC ILLNESS; WARNING SIGNS; HEALTH-STATUS; PREVENTION; OUTCOMES; DISPARITIES; MORTALITY;
D O I
10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.36227
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
IMPORTANCE Few stroke survivors meet recommended cardiovascular goals, particularly among racial/ethnic minority populations, such as Black or Hispanic individuals, or socioeconomically disadvantaged populations. OBJECTIVE To determine if a chronic care model-based, community health worker (CHW), advanced practice clinician (APC; including nurse practitioners or physician assistants), and physician team intervention improves risk factor control after stroke in a safety-net setting (ie, health care setting where all individuals receive care, regardless of health insurance status or ability to pay). DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS This randomized clinical trial included participants recruited from 5 hospitals serving low-income populations in Los Angeles County, California, as part of the Secondary Stroke Prevention by Uniting Community and Chronic Care Model Teams Early to End Disparities (SUCCEED) clinical trial. Inclusion criteria were age 40 years or older; experience of ischemic or hemorrhagic stroke or transient ischemic attack (TIA) no more than 90 days prior; systolic blood pressure (BP) of 130 mm Hg or greater or 120 to 130 mm Hg with history of hypertension or using hypertensive medications; and English or Spanish language proficiency. The exclusion criterion was inability to consent. Among 887 individuals screened for eligibility, 542 individuals were eligible, and 487 individuals were enrolled and randomized, stratified by stroke type (ischemic or TIA vs hemorrhagic), language (English vs Spanish), and site to usual care vs intervention in a 1:1 fashion. The study was conducted from February 2014 to September 2018, and data were analyzed from October 2018 to November 2020. INTERVENTIONS Participants randomized to intervention were offered a multimodal coordinated care intervention, including hypothesized core components (ie, >= 3 APC clinic visits, >= 3 CHW home visits, and Chronic Disease Self-Management Program workshops), and additional telephone visits, protocol-driven risk factor management, culturally and linguistically tailored education materials, and self-management tools. Participants randomized to the control group received usual care, which varied by site but frequently included a free BP monitor, self-management tools, and linguistically tailored information materials. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES The primary outcome was change in systolic BP at 12 months. Secondary outcomes were non-high density lipoprotein cholesterol, hemoglobin A(1c), and C-reactive protein (CRP) levels, body mass index, antithrombotic adherence, physical activity level, diet, and smoking status at 12 months. Potential mediators assessed included access to care, health and stroke literacy, self-efficacy, perceptions of care, and BP monitor use. RESULTS Among 487 participants included, the mean (SD) age was 57.1 (8.9) years; 317 (65.1%) were men, and 347 participants (71.3%) were Hispanic, 87 participants (18.3%) were Black, and 30 participants (6.3%) were Asian. A total of 246 participants were randomized to usual care, and 241 participants were randomized to the intervention. Mean (SD) systolic BP improved from 143 (17) mm Hg at baseline to 133 (20) mm Hg at 12 months in the intervention group and from 146 (19) mm Hg at baseline to 137 (22) mm Hg at 12 months in the usual care group, with no significant differences in the change between groups. Compared with the control group, participants in the intervention group had greater improvements in self-reported salt intake (difference, 15.4 [95% CI, 4.4 to 26.0]; P = .004) and serum CRP level (difference in log CRP, -0.4 [95% CI, -0.7 to -0.1] mg/dL; P = .003); there were no differences in other secondary outcomes. Although 216 participants (89.6%) in the intervention group received some of the 3 core components, only 35 participants (14.5%) received the intended full dose. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE This randomized clinical trial of a complex multilevel, multimodal intervention did not find vascular risk factor improvements beyond that of usual care; however, further studies may consider testing the SUCCEED intervention with modifications to enhance implementation and participant engagement.
引用
收藏
页数:19
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Effect of Colchicine vs Usual Care Alone on Intubation and 28-Day Mortality in Patients Hospitalized With COVID-19 A Randomized Clinical Trial
    Diaz, Rafael
    Orlandini, Andres
    Castellana, Noelia
    Caccavo, Alberto
    Corral, Pablo
    Corral, Gonzalo
    Chacon, Carolina
    Lamelas, Pablo
    Botto, Fernando
    Luz Diaz, Maria
    Manuel Dominguez, Juan
    Pascual, Andrea
    Rovito, Carla
    Galatte, Agustina
    Scarafia, Franco
    Sued, Omar
    Gutierrez, Omar
    Jolly, Sanjit S.
    Miro, Jose M.
    Eikelboom, John
    Loeb, Mark
    Maggioni, Aldo Pietro
    Bhatt, Deepak L.
    Yusuf, Salim
    JAMA NETWORK OPEN, 2021, 4 (12)
  • [32] Effect of a Home-Based, Walking Exercise Behavior Change Intervention vs Usual Care on Walking in Adults With Peripheral Artery Disease The MOSAIC Randomized Clinical Trial
    Bearne, LindsayM.
    Volkmer, Brittannia
    Peacock, Janet
    Sekhon, Mandeep
    Fisher, Graham
    Holmes, Melissa N. Galea
    Douiri, Abdel
    Amirova, Aliya
    Farran, Dina
    Quirke-McFarlane, Sophia
    Modarai, Bijan
    Sackley, Catherine
    Weinman, John
    Bieles, Julie
    JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 2022, 327 (14): : 1344 - 1355
  • [33] Effect of a Strategy of Comprehensive Vasodilation vs Usual Care on Mortality and Heart Failure Rehospitalization Among Patients With Acute Heart Failure The GALACTIC Randomized Clinical Trial
    Kozhuharov, Nikola
    Goudev, Assen
    Flores, Dayana
    Maeder, Micha T.
    Walter, Joan
    Shrestha, Samyut
    Gualandro, Danielle Menosi
    de Oliveira Junior, Mucio Tavares
    Sabti, Zaid
    Mueller, Beat
    Noveanu, Markus
    Socrates, Thenral
    Ziller, Ronny
    Bayes-Genis, Antoni
    Sionis, Alessandro
    Simon, Patrick
    Michou, Eleni
    Gujer, Samuel
    Gori, Tommaso
    Wenzel, Philip
    Pfister, Otmar
    Conen, David
    Kapos, Ioannis
    Kobza, Richard
    Rickli, Hans
    Breidthardt, Tobias
    Muenzel, Thomas
    Erne, Paul
    Mueller, Christian
    Dimov, Bojidar
    Hartwiger, Sabine
    Herr, Natascha
    Isenrich, Rahel
    Mosimann, Tamina
    Twerenbold, Raphael
    Boeddinghaus, Jasper
    Nestelberger, Thomas
    Puelacher, Christian
    Freese, Michael
    Vogele, Janine
    Meissner, Kathrin
    Martin, Jasmin
    Strebel, Ivo
    Wussler, Desiree
    Schumacher, Carmela
    Osswald, Stefan
    Vogt, Fabian
    Hilti, Jonas
    Schwarz, Jonas
    Fitze, Brigitte
    JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 2019, 322 (23): : 2292 - 2302
  • [34] Effect of a Comprehensive Telehealth Intervention vs Telemonitoring and Care Coordination in Patients With Persistently Poor Type 2 Diabetes Control A Randomized Clinical Trial
    Crowley, Matthew J.
    Tarkington, Phillip E.
    Bosworth, Hayden B.
    Jeffreys, Amy S.
    Coffman, Cynthia J.
    Maciejewski, Matthew L.
    Steinhauser, Karen
    Smith, Valerie A.
    Dar, Moahad S.
    Fredrickson, Sonja K.
    Mundy, Amy C.
    Strawbridge, Elizabeth M.
    Marcano, Teresa J.
    Overby, Donna L.
    Elliott, Nadya T. Majette
    Danus, Susanne
    Edelman, David
    JAMA INTERNAL MEDICINE, 2022, 182 (09) : 943 - 952
  • [35] Efficacy of self-monitoring blood glucose as a key component of a chronic care model versus usual care in type 2 diabetes patients treated with oral agents: results of a randomized trial
    Nicoletta Musacchio
    Ilaria Ciullo
    Marco Scardapane
    Annalisa Giancaterini
    Laura Pessina
    Silvia Maino
    Rosana Gaiofatto
    Antonio Nicolucci
    Maria Chiara Rossi
    Acta Diabetologica, 2018, 55 : 295 - 299
  • [36] Efficacy of self-monitoring blood glucose as a key component of a chronic care model versus usual care in type 2 diabetes patients treated with oral agents: results of a randomized trial
    Musacchio, Nicoletta
    Ciullo, Ilaria
    Scardapane, Marco
    Giancaterini, Annalisa
    Pessina, Laura
    Maino, Silvia
    Gaiofatto, Rosana
    Nicolucci, Antonio
    Rossi, Maria Chiara
    ACTA DIABETOLOGICA, 2018, 55 (03) : 295 - 299
  • [37] Effect of Long-term Continuous Cardiac Monitoring vs Usual Care on Detection of Atrial Fibrillation in Patients With Stroke Attributed to Large- or Small-Vessel Disease The STROKE-AF Randomized Clinical Trial
    Bernstein, Richard A.
    Kamel, Hooman
    Granger, Christopher B.
    Piccini, Jonathan P.
    Sethi, Pramod P.
    Katz, Jeffrey M.
    Vives, Carola Alfaro
    Ziegler, Paul D.
    Franco, Noreli C.
    Schwamm, Lee H.
    JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 2021, 325 (21): : 2169 - 2177
  • [38] Effect of a Community Health Worker-Led Multicomponent Intervention on Blood Pressure Control in Low-Income Patients in Argentina A Randomized Clinical Trial
    He, Jiang
    Irazola, Vilma
    Mills, Katherine T.
    Poggio, Rosana
    Beratarrechea, Andrea
    Dolan, Jacquelyn
    Chen, Chung-Shiuan
    Gibbons, Luz
    Krousel-Wood, Marie
    Bazzano, Lydia A.
    Nejamis, Analia
    Gulayin, Pablo
    Santero, Marilina
    Augustovski, Federico
    Chen, Jing
    Rubinstein, Adolfo
    JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 2017, 318 (11): : 1016 - 1025
  • [39] Severity and etiology of incident stroke in patients screened for atrial fibrillation vs usual care and the impact of prior stroke: a post hoc analysis of the LOOP randomized clinical trial (vol 79, pg 997, 2022)
    Diederichsen, S. Z.
    Frederiksen, K. S.
    Xing, L. Y.
    JAMA NEUROLOGY, 2023, 80 (02) : 216 - 216
  • [40] A randomized clinical trial of hospital-based, comprehensive cardiac rehabilitation versus usual care for patients with congestive heart failure, ischemic heart disease, or high risk of ischemic heart disease (the DANREHAB trial) - design, intervention, and population
    Zwisler, ADO
    Schou, O
    Soja, AMB
    Bronnum-Hansen, H
    Gluud, C
    Iversen, L
    Sigurd, B
    Madsen, M
    Fischer-Hansen, J
    AMERICAN HEART JOURNAL, 2005, 150 (05) : 899.e7 - 899.e16