Effect of a Coordinated Community and Chronic Care Model Team Intervention vs Usual Care on Systolic Blood Pressure in Patients With Stroke or Transient Ischemic Attack The SUCCEED Randomized Clinical Trial

被引:43
|
作者
Towfighi, Amytis [1 ,2 ,3 ,4 ]
Cheng, Eric M. [5 ]
Ayala-Rivera, Monica [1 ,2 ,3 ,4 ]
Barry, Frances [5 ]
McCreath, Heather [5 ]
Ganz, David A. [5 ,6 ]
Lee, Martin L. [5 ,6 ]
Sanossian, Nerses [1 ,4 ]
Mehta, Bijal [5 ,8 ]
Dutta, Tara [3 ,9 ]
Razmara, Ali [3 ,10 ]
Bryg, Robert [5 ,11 ]
Song, Shlee S. [12 ]
Willis, Phyllis [13 ]
Wu, Shinyi [1 ]
Ramirez, Magaly [14 ]
Richards, Adam [15 ]
Jackson, Nicholas [5 ]
Wacksman, Jeremy [16 ]
Mittman, Brian [6 ,7 ]
Tran, Jamie [8 ]
Johnson, Renee R. [3 ,4 ,17 ]
Ediss, Chris [3 ]
Sivers-Teixeira, Theresa [1 ,3 ,4 ]
Shaby, Betty [11 ]
Montoya, Ana L. [8 ,11 ]
Corrales, Marilyn [3 ,4 ,18 ]
Mojarro-Huang, Elizabeth [1 ,4 ]
Castro, Marissa [3 ,12 ]
Gomez, Patricia [3 ]
Munoz, Cynthia [1 ,3 ]
Garcia, Diamond [3 ,8 ]
Moreno, Lilian [3 ]
Fernandez, Maura [1 ,4 ]
Lopez, Enrique [3 ]
Valdez, Sarah [8 ]
Haber, Hilary R. [16 ,19 ]
Hill, Valerie A. [20 ]
Rao, Neal M. [5 ,11 ]
Martinez, Beatrice [1 ,3 ,4 ,8 ]
Hudson, Lillie [1 ,3 ]
Valle, Natalie P. [21 ]
Vickrey, Barbara G. [22 ]
机构
[1] Univ Southern Calif, Los Angeles, CA 90007 USA
[2] Los Angeles Cty Dept Hlth Serv, Los Angeles, CA USA
[3] Rancho Los Amigos Natl Rehabil Ctr, Downey, CA USA
[4] LAC USC Med Ctr, 1100 N State St, Los Angeles, CA 90033 USA
[5] Univ Calif Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA USA
[6] Vet Affairs Greater Los Angeles Healthcare Syst, Los Angeles, CA USA
[7] Kaiser Permanente, Los Angeles, CA USA
[8] Harbor UCLA Med Ctr, Torrance, CA 90509 USA
[9] Univ Maryland, Baltimore, MD 21201 USA
[10] Kaiser Permanente, Irvine, CA USA
[11] Olive View UCLA Med Ctr, 14445 Olive View Dr, Sylmar, CA 91342 USA
[12] Cedars Sinai Med Ctr, Los Angeles, CA 90048 USA
[13] Watts Lab Community Act Comm, Los Angeles, CA USA
[14] Univ Washington, Sch Publ Hlth, Seattle, WA 98195 USA
[15] Community Partners Int, San Francisco, CA USA
[16] Dimagi, Cambridge, MA USA
[17] Calif State Univ Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA 90032 USA
[18] Univ Calif Riverside, Riverside, CA 92521 USA
[19] Brigham & Womens Hosp, 75 Francis St, Boston, MA 02115 USA
[20] Univ Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH USA
[21] St Jude Med Ctr, Fullerton, CA USA
[22] Icahn Sch Med Mt Sinai, New York, NY 10029 USA
基金
美国国家卫生研究院;
关键词
SELF-MANAGEMENT PROGRAM; IMPROVING PRIMARY-CARE; RISK-FACTORS; CHRONIC ILLNESS; WARNING SIGNS; HEALTH-STATUS; PREVENTION; OUTCOMES; DISPARITIES; MORTALITY;
D O I
10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.36227
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
IMPORTANCE Few stroke survivors meet recommended cardiovascular goals, particularly among racial/ethnic minority populations, such as Black or Hispanic individuals, or socioeconomically disadvantaged populations. OBJECTIVE To determine if a chronic care model-based, community health worker (CHW), advanced practice clinician (APC; including nurse practitioners or physician assistants), and physician team intervention improves risk factor control after stroke in a safety-net setting (ie, health care setting where all individuals receive care, regardless of health insurance status or ability to pay). DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS This randomized clinical trial included participants recruited from 5 hospitals serving low-income populations in Los Angeles County, California, as part of the Secondary Stroke Prevention by Uniting Community and Chronic Care Model Teams Early to End Disparities (SUCCEED) clinical trial. Inclusion criteria were age 40 years or older; experience of ischemic or hemorrhagic stroke or transient ischemic attack (TIA) no more than 90 days prior; systolic blood pressure (BP) of 130 mm Hg or greater or 120 to 130 mm Hg with history of hypertension or using hypertensive medications; and English or Spanish language proficiency. The exclusion criterion was inability to consent. Among 887 individuals screened for eligibility, 542 individuals were eligible, and 487 individuals were enrolled and randomized, stratified by stroke type (ischemic or TIA vs hemorrhagic), language (English vs Spanish), and site to usual care vs intervention in a 1:1 fashion. The study was conducted from February 2014 to September 2018, and data were analyzed from October 2018 to November 2020. INTERVENTIONS Participants randomized to intervention were offered a multimodal coordinated care intervention, including hypothesized core components (ie, >= 3 APC clinic visits, >= 3 CHW home visits, and Chronic Disease Self-Management Program workshops), and additional telephone visits, protocol-driven risk factor management, culturally and linguistically tailored education materials, and self-management tools. Participants randomized to the control group received usual care, which varied by site but frequently included a free BP monitor, self-management tools, and linguistically tailored information materials. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES The primary outcome was change in systolic BP at 12 months. Secondary outcomes were non-high density lipoprotein cholesterol, hemoglobin A(1c), and C-reactive protein (CRP) levels, body mass index, antithrombotic adherence, physical activity level, diet, and smoking status at 12 months. Potential mediators assessed included access to care, health and stroke literacy, self-efficacy, perceptions of care, and BP monitor use. RESULTS Among 487 participants included, the mean (SD) age was 57.1 (8.9) years; 317 (65.1%) were men, and 347 participants (71.3%) were Hispanic, 87 participants (18.3%) were Black, and 30 participants (6.3%) were Asian. A total of 246 participants were randomized to usual care, and 241 participants were randomized to the intervention. Mean (SD) systolic BP improved from 143 (17) mm Hg at baseline to 133 (20) mm Hg at 12 months in the intervention group and from 146 (19) mm Hg at baseline to 137 (22) mm Hg at 12 months in the usual care group, with no significant differences in the change between groups. Compared with the control group, participants in the intervention group had greater improvements in self-reported salt intake (difference, 15.4 [95% CI, 4.4 to 26.0]; P = .004) and serum CRP level (difference in log CRP, -0.4 [95% CI, -0.7 to -0.1] mg/dL; P = .003); there were no differences in other secondary outcomes. Although 216 participants (89.6%) in the intervention group received some of the 3 core components, only 35 participants (14.5%) received the intended full dose. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE This randomized clinical trial of a complex multilevel, multimodal intervention did not find vascular risk factor improvements beyond that of usual care; however, further studies may consider testing the SUCCEED intervention with modifications to enhance implementation and participant engagement.
引用
收藏
页数:19
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Randomized controlled trial of a coordinated care intervention to improve risk factor control after stroke or transient ischemic attack in the safety net: Secondary stroke prevention by Uniting Community and Chronic care model teams Early to End Disparities (SUCCEED)
    Amytis Towfighi
    Eric M. Cheng
    Monica Ayala-Rivera
    Heather McCreath
    Nerses Sanossian
    Tara Dutta
    Bijal Mehta
    Robert Bryg
    Neal Rao
    Shlee Song
    Ali Razmara
    Magaly Ramirez
    Theresa Sivers-Teixeira
    Jamie Tran
    Elizabeth Mojarro-Huang
    Ana Montoya
    Marilyn Corrales
    Beatrice Martinez
    Phyllis Willis
    Mireya Macias
    Nancy Ibrahim
    Shinyi Wu
    Jeremy Wacksman
    Hilary Haber
    Adam Richards
    Frances Barry
    Valerie Hill
    Brian Mittman
    William Cunningham
    Honghu Liu
    David A. Ganz
    Diane Factor
    Barbara G. Vickrey
    BMC Neurology, 17
  • [2] Randomized controlled trial of a coordinated care intervention to improve risk factor control after stroke or transient ischemic attack in the safety net: Secondary stroke prevention by Uniting Community and Chronic care model teams Early to End Disparities (SUCCEED)
    Towfighi, Amytis
    Cheng, Eric M.
    Ayala-Rivera, Monica
    McCreath, Heather
    Sanossian, Nerses
    Dutta, Tara
    Mehta, Bijal
    Bryg, Robert
    Rao, Neal
    Song, Shlee
    Razmara, Ali
    Ramirez, Magaly
    Sivers-Teixeira, Theresa
    Tran, Jamie
    Mojarro-Huang, Elizabeth
    Montoya, Ana
    Corrales, Marilyn
    Martinez, Beatrice
    Willis, Phyllis
    Macias, Mireya
    Ibrahim, Nancy
    Wu, Shinyi
    Wacksman, Jeremy
    Haber, Hilary
    Richards, Adam
    Barry, Frances
    Hill, Valerie
    Mittman, Brian
    Cunningham, William
    Liu, Honghu
    Ganz, David A.
    Factor, Diane
    Vickrey, Barbara G.
    BMC NEUROLOGY, 2017, 17
  • [3] Effect of a Collaborative Care Intervention vs Usual Care on Health Status of Patients With Chronic Heart Failure The CASA Randomized Clinical Trial
    Bekelman, David B.
    Allen, Larry A.
    McBryde, Connor F.
    Hattler, Brack
    Fairclough, Diane L.
    Havranek, Edward P.
    Turvey, Carolyn
    Meek, Paula M.
    JAMA INTERNAL MEDICINE, 2018, 178 (04) : 511 - 519
  • [4] Effect of Remote Ischemic Conditioning vs Usual Care on Neurologic Function in Patients With Acute Moderate Ischemic Stroke The RICAMIS Randomized Clinical Trial
    Chen, Hui-Sheng
    Cui, Yu
    Li, Xiao-Qiu
    Wang, Xin-Hong
    Ma, Yu-Tong
    Zhao, Yong
    Han, Jing
    Deng, Chang-Qing
    Hong, Mei
    Bao, Ying
    Zhao, Li-Hong
    Yan, Ting-Guang
    Zou, Ren-Lin
    Wang, Hui
    Li, Zhuo
    Wan, Li-Shu
    Zhang, Li
    Wang, Lian-Qiang
    Guo, Li-Yan
    Li, Ming-Nan
    Wang, Dong-Qing
    Zhang, Qiang
    Chang, Da-Wei
    Zhang, Hong-Li
    Sun, Jing
    Meng, Chong
    Zhang, Zai-Hui
    Shen, Li-Ying
    Ma, Li
    Wang, Gui-Chun
    Li, Run-Hui
    Zhang, Ling
    Bi, Cheng
    Wang, Li-Yun
    Wang, Duo-Lao
    JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 2022, 328 (07): : 627 - 636
  • [5] Effect of a Quality Improvement Intervention on Adherence to Therapies for Patients With Acute Ischemic Stroke and Transient Ischemic Attack: A Cluster Randomized Clinical Trial
    Julia Machline-Carrion, M.
    Santucci, Eliana Vieira
    Damiani, Lucas Petri
    Cecilia Bahit, M.
    Malaga, German
    Pontes-Neto, Octavio Marques
    Ouriques Martins, Sheila Cristina
    Zetola, Viviane Flumignan
    Normilio-Silva, Karina
    de Freitas, Gabriel Rodrigues
    Gorgulho, Alessandra
    De Salles, Antonio
    Pacheco da Silva, Beatriz Gonzales
    Santos, Juliana Yamashita
    Jesuino, Isabella de Andrade
    Torres Bueno, Priscila Regina
    Cavalcanti, Alexandre Biasi
    Guimaraes, Helio Penna
    Xian, Ying
    Bettger, Janet Prvu
    Lopes, Renato D.
    Peterson, Eric D.
    Berwanger, Otavio
    Machline-Carrion, Maria Julia
    Berwanger, Otavio
    Santucci, Eliana Vieira
    Damiani, Lucas Petri
    Bahit, Cecilia M.
    Malaga, German
    Neto, Octavio Marques Pontes
    Zetola, Viviane Flumignan
    Normilio-Silva, Karina
    Bettger, Janet Prvu
    Xian, Ying
    Lopes, Renato Delascio
    Peterson, Eric
    Machline-Carrion, Maria Julia
    Berwanger, Otavio
    Bahit, M. Cecilia
    Malaga, German
    Martins, Sheila Cristina Ouriques
    Neto, Octavio Marques Pontes
    Zetola, Viviane Flumignan
    Guimaraes, Helio Penna
    Cavalcanti, Alexandre Biasi
    de Freitas, Gabriel Rodrigues
    De Salles, Antonio
    Gorgulho, Alessandra
    Xian, Ying
    Bettger, Janet Prvu
    JAMA NEUROLOGY, 2019, 76 (08) : 932 - 941
  • [6] A post-discharge care management model for stroke and transient ischemic attack: A randomized controlled trial
    Allen, KR
    Hazelett, SE
    Jarjoura, D
    Wickstrom, G
    Hua, K
    Weinhardt, JA
    Wright, K
    STROKE, 2002, 33 (01) : 417 - 417
  • [7] Effect of a Collaborative Palliative Care Intervention vs Usual Care on Quality of Life of Patients with Symptomatic Heart and Lung Diseases: A Randomized Clinical Trial
    Bekelman, David
    Baron, Anna
    Paden, Grady
    McBryde, Connor
    Welsh, Carolyn
    Parsons, Elizabeth
    Cheng, Andrew
    Turvey, Carolyn
    Au, David
    JOURNAL OF PAIN AND SYMPTOM MANAGEMENT, 2022, 63 (06) : 1063 - 1063
  • [8] Efficacy of a Discharge Educational Strategy vs Standard Discharge Care on Reduction of Vascular Risk in Patients With Stroke and Transient Ischemic Attack The DESERVE Randomized Clinical Trial
    Boden-Albala, Bernadette
    Goldmann, Emily
    Parikh, Nina S.
    Carman, Heather
    Roberts, Eric T.
    Lord, Aaron S.
    Torrico, Veronica
    Appleton, Noa
    Birkemeier, Joel
    Parides, Michael
    Quarles, Leigh
    JAMA NEUROLOGY, 2019, 76 (01) : 20 - 27
  • [9] Prourokinase vs Standard Care for Patients With Mild Ischemic Stroke The PUMICE Randomized Clinical Trial
    Xiong, Yunyun
    Meng, Xia
    Jin, Aoming
    Campbell, Bruce C. V.
    Xu, Anding
    Dong, Qiang
    Xu, Yun
    Pan, Yuesong
    Jiang, Yong
    Niu, Siying
    Li, Zhiliang
    Zhuang, Xianbo
    Guo, Na
    Yuan, Zhimei
    Kong, Zhenyu
    Zong, Lixia
    Duan, Chunmiao
    Cao, Zhixin
    Wang, Liyuan
    Hao, Manjun
    Wu, Shuangzhe
    Feng, Xueyan
    Li, Hao
    Wu, Na
    Li, Zixiao
    Zhao, Xingquan
    Wang, Yongjun
    PUMICE Investigators
    JAMA NEUROLOGY, 2025, 82 (03) : 258 - 266
  • [10] Effect of Pain Reprocessing Therapy vs Placebo and Usual Care for Patients With Chronic Back Pain A Randomized Clinical Trial
    Ashar, Yoni K.
    Gordon, Alan
    Schubiner, Howard
    Uipi, Christie
    Knight, Karen
    Anderson, Zachary
    Carlisle, Judith
    Polisky, Laurie
    Geuter, Stephan
    Flood, Thomas F.
    Kragel, Philip A.
    Dimidjian, Sona
    Lumley, Mark A.
    Wager, Tor D.
    JAMA PSYCHIATRY, 2022, 79 (01) : 13 - 23