Smart strategies for doctors and doctors-in-training: heuristics in medicine

被引:77
|
作者
Wegwarth, Odette [1 ,2 ]
Gaissmaier, Wolfgang [1 ,2 ]
Gigerenzer, Gerd [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Max Planck Inst Human Dev, Ctr Adapt Behav & Cognit, D-14195 Berlin, Germany
[2] Max Planck Inst Human Dev, Harding Ctr Risk Literacy, D-14195 Berlin, Germany
关键词
ISCHEMIC-HEART-DISEASE; CORONARY-CARE-UNIT; DECISION-MAKING; PREDICTIVE INSTRUMENT; NEURAL NETWORKS; BIASES; PROBABILITY; INFORMATION; JUDGMENT;
D O I
10.1111/j.1365-2923.2009.03359.x
中图分类号
G40 [教育学];
学科分类号
040101 ; 120403 ;
摘要
Context How do doctors make sound decisions when confronted with probabilistic data, time pressures and a heavy workload? One theory that has been embraced by many researchers is based on optimisation, which emphasises the need to integrate all information in order to arrive at sound decisions. This notion makes heuristics, which use less than complete information, appear as second-best strategies. In this article, we challenge this pessimistic view of heuristics. Methods We introduce two medical problems that involve decision making to the reader: one concerns coronary care issues and the other macrolide prescriptions. In both settings, decision-making tools grounded in the principles of optimisation and heuristics, respectively, have been developed to assist doctors in making decisions. We explain the structure of each of these tools and compare their performance in terms of their facilitation of correct predictions. Results For decisions concerning both the coronary care unit and the prescribing of macrolides, we demonstrate that sacrificing information does not necessarily imply a forfeiting of predictive accuracy, but can sometimes even lead to better decisions. Subsequently, we discuss common misconceptions about heuristics and explain when and why ignoring parts of the available information can lead to the making of more robust predictions. Conclusions Heuristics are neither good nor bad per se, but, if applied in situations to which they have been adapted, can be helpful companions for doctors and doctors-in-training. This, however, requires that heuristics in medicine be openly discussed, criticised, refined and then taught to doctors-in-training rather than being simply dismissed as harmful or irrelevant. A more uniform use of explicit and accepted heuristics has the potential to reduce variations in diagnoses and to improve medical care for patients.
引用
收藏
页码:721 / 728
页数:8
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] Training Mode of Outstanding Doctors of Clinical Medicine by Distance Education
    Jin, Shikai
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2015 INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON ENGINEERING MANAGEMENT, ENGINEERING EDUCATION AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY, 2015, 36 : 475 - 478
  • [42] Why our doctors are leaving Irish emergency medicine training
    Jessica Pflipsen
    Cian McDermott
    Eva Mary Doherty
    Niamh Humphries
    Irish Journal of Medical Science (1971 -), 2019, 188 : 1397 - 1399
  • [44] OVERSEAS DOCTORS TRAINING SCHEME - PLIGHT OF REFUGEE DOCTORS
    ROSENTHAL, J
    SINGH, S
    BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1994, 309 (6950): : 339 - 339
  • [45] Teaching general practitioners and doctors-in-training to discuss advance care planning: evaluation of a brief multimodality education programme
    Detering, Karen
    Silvester, William
    Corke, Charlie
    Milnes, Sharyn
    Fullam, Rachael
    Lewis, Virginia
    Renton, Jodie
    BMJ SUPPORTIVE & PALLIATIVE CARE, 2014, 4 (03) : 313 - 321
  • [46] Introduction of a structured training course for medical doctors in training in the field of reproductive medicine
    Kissel, C
    Keck, C
    GEBURTSHILFE UND FRAUENHEILKUNDE, 2004, 64 (02) : 160 - 163
  • [47] Emergency Medicine training and working conditions in Europe: a joint EuSEM young doctors - European Junior Doctors Survey
    Van Asbroeck, Pieter Jan
    Heiser, Jochen
    Leto, Riccardo
    Capizzi, Marco
    Mohrhardt, Carsten
    Carenzo, Luca
    European Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2015, 22 (06) : 445 - 447
  • [48] MOBILIZATION AND THE TRAINING OF DOCTORS
    SHUMACKER, HB
    SURGERY, 1951, 29 (03) : 480 - 482
  • [49] Training of Doctors project
    Ward, SJ
    MEDICAL EDUCATION, 2002, 36 (06) : 587 - 588
  • [50] Training of doctors in the UK
    Sataline, L
    LANCET, 1997, 349 (9049): : 436 - 436