Comparison of vacuum-formed and Hawley retainers: A systematic review

被引:60
|
作者
Mai, Wenjia [1 ]
He, Jin'an [1 ]
Meng, Hongying [1 ]
Jiang, Yanping [1 ]
Huang, Chaoxiao [1 ]
Li, Min [1 ]
Yuan, Kan [1 ]
Kang, Na [1 ]
机构
[1] Guangxi Med Univ, Coll Stomatol, Dept Orthodont, Nanning 530021, Guangxi, Peoples R China
关键词
OCCLUSAL CONTACT CHANGES; RETENTION PROCEDURES; PROTOCOLS;
D O I
10.1016/j.ajodo.2014.01.019
中图分类号
R78 [口腔科学];
学科分类号
1003 ;
摘要
Introduction: Hawley retainers (HRs) and vacuum-formed retainers (VFRs) are the 2 most commonly used retainers in orthodontics. However, the basis for selection of an appropriate retainer is still a matter of debate among orthodontists. In this systematic review, we evaluated the differences between VFRs and HRs. Methods: Electronic databases (PubMed, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, ISI Web of Science, LILACS, and Pro-Quest) were searched with no language restriction. The relevant orthodontic journals and reference lists were checked for all eligible studies. Two article reviewers independently screened the retrieved studies, extracted the data, and evaluated the quality of the primary studies. Results: A total of 89 articles were retrieved in the initial search. However, only 7 articles met the inclusion criteria. Some evidence suggested that no difference exists to distinguish between the HRs and VFRs with respect to changes in intercanine and intermolar widths after orthodontic retention. In terms of occlusal contacts, cost effectiveness, patient satisfaction, and survival time, there was insufficient evidence to support the use of VFRs over HRs. Conclusions: Additional high-quality, randomized, controlled trials concerning these retainers are necessary to determine which retainer is better for orthodontic procedures.
引用
收藏
页码:720 / 727
页数:8
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Changes in occlusal surface area and occlusal force distribution following the wear of vacuum-formed, hawley and bonded retainers: A controlled clinical trial
    Alkan, Ozer
    Kaya, Yesim
    JOURNAL OF ORAL REHABILITATION, 2020, 47 (06) : 766 - 774
  • [22] Comparison of mechanical properties and color stability of various vacuum-formed orthodontic retainers: An in vitro study
    Aldweesh, Aljazi H.
    Al-Maflehi, Nassr S.
    Alghizzi, Muhannad
    Alshayea, Eman
    Albarakati, Sahar F.
    SAUDI DENTAL JOURNAL, 2023, 35 (08) : 953 - 959
  • [23] Assessment of Factors Affecting Adolescent Patients' Compliance with Hawley and Vacuum Formed Retainers
    Mirzakouchaki, Behnam
    Shirazi, Sajjad
    Sharghi, Reza
    Shirazi, Samaneh
    JOURNAL OF CLINICAL AND DIAGNOSTIC RESEARCH, 2016, 10 (06) : ZC24 - ZC27
  • [24] Effectiveness of bonded and vacuum-formed retainers: A prospective randomized controlled clinical trial
    O'Rourke, Niamh
    Albeedh, Hussein
    Sharma, Pratik
    Johal, Ama
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF ORTHODONTICS AND DENTOFACIAL ORTHOPEDICS, 2016, 150 (03) : 406 - 415
  • [25] Retention protocols and use of vacuum-formed retainers among specialist orthodontists in India
    Sandhya, Venkatachalam
    Arun, A. Virupakshappa
    Mahendra, Shivanna
    Chandrashekar, B. S.
    Shetty, Balamohan
    Mahesh, C. M.
    Reddy, Vinay P.
    JOURNAL OF THE WORLD FEDERATION OF ORTHODONTISTS, 2019, 8 (02) : 64 - 67
  • [26] One-year comparative assessment of retention of arch width increases between modified vacuum-formed and Hawley retainers: A multicenter randomized clinical trial
    Ashari, Asma
    Xian, Lew
    Mohamed, Alizae Marny Fadzlin Syed
    Wahab, Rohaya Megat Abdul
    Kit, Yeoh Chiew
    Tata, Malathi Deva
    Sinnasamy, Sindhu
    Kuppusamy, Elavarasi
    ANGLE ORTHODONTIST, 2022, 92 (02) : 197 - 203
  • [27] Effects of aging procedures on the molecular, biochemical, morphological, and mechanical properties of vacuum-formed retainers
    Ahn, Hyo-Won
    Ha, Hye-Ryun
    Lim, Ho-Nam
    Choi, Samjin
    JOURNAL OF THE MECHANICAL BEHAVIOR OF BIOMEDICAL MATERIALS, 2015, 51 : 356 - 366
  • [28] The effectiveness of Hawley and vacuum-formed retainer usage protocols on the stability of fixed orthodontic treatment results
    Gorucu-Coskuner, Hande
    Atik, Ezgi
    Taner, Tulin
    AUSTRALASIAN ORTHODONTIC JOURNAL, 2021, 37 (01): : 69 - 78
  • [29] The origin and evolution of the Hawley retainer for the effectiveness to maintain tooth position after fixed orthodontic treatment compare to vacuum-formed retainer: A systematic review of RCTs
    Outhaisavanh, Souvannasing
    Liu, Yang
    Song, Jinlin
    INTERNATIONAL ORTHODONTICS, 2020, 18 (02) : 225 - 236
  • [30] Impact of simulated gastric acid on the physical and mechanical properties of vacuum-formed retainers: an in vitro study
    Alkawari, Huda M.
    Baidas, Laila F.
    Alyahya, Areen A.
    Alotaibi, Renad A.
    Alshayea, Eman I.
    BMC ORAL HEALTH, 2025, 25 (01):