Role of human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination on HPV infection and recurrence of HPV related disease after local surgical treatment: systematic review and meta-analysis

被引:57
|
作者
Kechagias, Konstantinos S. [1 ,2 ]
Kalliala, Ilkka [1 ,2 ,3 ,4 ]
Bowden, Sarah J. [1 ,2 ]
Athanasiou, Antonios [1 ,2 ]
Paraskevaidi, Maria [1 ,2 ]
Paraskevaidis, Evangelos [5 ]
Dillner, Joakim [6 ,7 ]
Nieminen, Pekka [3 ,4 ]
Strander, Bjorn [8 ]
Sasieni, Peter [9 ]
Veroniki, Areti Angeliki [1 ,2 ,10 ]
Kyrgiou, Maria [1 ,2 ,11 ]
机构
[1] Imperial Coll London, Dept Metab Digest & Reprod, London, England
[2] Imperial Coll London, Dept Surg & Canc, Fac Med, London, England
[3] Univ Helsinki, Dept Obstet & Gynaecol, Helsinki, Finland
[4] Helsinki Univ Hosp, Helsinki, Finland
[5] Univ Ioannina, Dept Obstet & Gynaecol, Ioannina, Greece
[6] Karolinska Univ Hosp, Ctr Cerv Canc Prevent, Med Diagnost Karolinska, Stockholm, Sweden
[7] Karolinska Inst, Stockholm, Sweden
[8] Univ Gothenburg, Sahlgrenska Acad, Inst Clin Sci, Dept Obstet & Gynaecol, Gothenburg, Sweden
[9] Kings Coll London, Kings Clin Trials Unit, London, England
[10] St Michaels Hosp, Unity Hlth Toronto, Li Ka Shing Knowledge Inst, Toronto, ON, Canada
[11] Imperial Coll Healthcare NHS Trust, London, England
来源
关键词
CERVICAL INTRAEPITHELIAL NEOPLASIA; EFFICACY; HETEROGENEITY; CONIZATION; PREVENTION; PRECANCER; EXCISION; IMPACT; WOMEN; MEN;
D O I
10.1136/bmj-2022-070135
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
OBJECTIVE To explore the efficacy of human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination on the risk of HPV infection and recurrent diseases related to HPV infection in individuals undergoing local surgical treatment. DESIGN Systematic review and meta-analysis DATA SOURCES PubMed (Medline), Scopus, Cochrane, Web of Science, and ClinicalTrials.gov were screened from inception to 31 March 2021. REVIEW METHODS Studies reporting on the risk of HPV infection and recurrence of disease related to HPV infection after local surgical treatment of preinvasive genital disease in individuals who were vaccinated were included. The primary outcome measure was risk of recurrence of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade 2 or higher (CIN2+) after local surgical treatment, with followup as reported by individual studies. Secondary outcome measures were risk of HPV infection or other lesions related to HPV infection. Independent and in duplicate data extraction and quality assessment were performed with ROBINS-I and RoB-2 tools for observational studies and randomised controlled trials, respectively. Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) was implemented for the primary outcome. Observational studies and randomised controlled trials were analysed separately from post hoc analyses of randomised controlled trials. Pooled risk ratios and 95% confidence intervals were calculated with a random effects meta-analysis model. The restricted maximum likelihood was used as an estimator for heterogeneity, and the Hartung-KnappSidik-Jonkman method was used to derive confidence intervals. RESULTS 22 articles met the inclusion criteria of the review; 18 of these studies also reported data from a non-vaccinated group and were included in the meta-analyses (12 observational studies, two randomised controlled trials, and four post hoc analyses of randomised controlled trials). The risk of recurrence of CIN2+ was reduced in individuals who were vaccinated compared with those who were not vaccinated (11 studies, 19 909 participants; risk ratio 0.43, 95% confidence interval 0.30 to 0.60; I-2= 58%, t(2)=0.14, median follow-up 36 months, interquartile range 24-43.5). The effect estimate was even stronger when the risk of recurrence of CIN2+ was assessed for disease related to HPV subtypes HPV16 or HPV18 ( six studies, 1879 participants; risk ratio 0.26, 95% confidence interval 0.16 to 0.43; I-2=0%, t(2)=0). Confidence in the meta-analysis for CIN2+ overall and CIN2+ related to HPV16 or HPV18, assessed by GRADE, ranged from very low to moderate, probably because of publication bias and inconsistency in the studies included in the meta-analysis. The risk of recurrence of CIN3 was also reduced in patients who were vaccinated but uncertainty was large (three studies, 17 757 participants; 0.28, 0.01 to 6.37; I-2=71%, t(2)=1.23). Evidence of benefit was lacking for recurrence of vulvar, vaginal, and anal intraepithelial neoplasia, genital warts, and persistent and incident HPV infections, although the number of studies and participants in each outcome was low. CONCLUSION HPV vaccination might reduce the risk of recurrence of CIN, in particular when related to HPV16 or HPV18, in women treated with local excision. GRADE assessment for the quality of evidence indicated that the data were inconclusive. Large scale, high quality randomised controlled trials are required to establish the level of effectiveness and cost of HPV vaccination in women undergoing treatment for diseases related to HPV infection.
引用
收藏
页数:10
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Systematic literature review on knowledge about infection with human papillomavirus (HPV)
    Klug, J.
    Hukelmann, M.
    Blettner, M.
    EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY, 2006, 21 : 59 - 60
  • [32] School Teachers' Perceptions of Adolescent Human Papillomavirus (HPV) Vaccination: A Systematic Review
    Choi, Jihye
    Gabay, Efrat K.
    Cuccaro, Paula M.
    VACCINES, 2024, 12 (04)
  • [33] Pharmacists' Perceived Barriers to Human Papillomavirus (HPV) Vaccination: A Systematic Literature Review
    Oyedeji, Oluwafemifola
    Maples, Jill M.
    Gregory, Samantha
    Chamberlin, Shaunta M.
    Gatwood, Justin D.
    Wilson, Alexandria Q.
    Zite, Nikki B.
    Kilgore, Larry C.
    VACCINES, 2021, 9 (11)
  • [34] Airborne human papillomavirus (HPV) transmission risk during ablation procedures: A systematic review and meta-analysis
    Palma, Stefano
    Gnambs, Timo
    Crevenna, Richard
    Jordakieva, Galateja
    ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH, 2021, 192
  • [35] Carcinogenicity of Human Papillomavirus (HPV) Types in HIV-Positive Women: A Meta-Analysis From HPV Infection to Cervical Cancer
    Clifford, Gary M.
    Tully, Stephen
    Franceschi, Silvia
    CLINICAL INFECTIOUS DISEASES, 2017, 64 (09) : 1228 - 1235
  • [36] HPV AND BREAST CANCER: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND META-ANALYSIS
    Karachalios, Charalampos
    Petousis, Stamatios
    Margioula-Siarkou, Chrysoula
    Dinas, Konstantinos
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF GYNECOLOGICAL CANCER, 2023, 33 : A218 - A218
  • [37] HPV and lung cancer: A systematic review and meta-analysis
    Karnosky, Julia
    Dietmaier, Wolfgang
    Knuettel, Helge
    Freigang, Viola
    Koch, Myriam
    Koll, Franziska
    Zeman, Florian
    Schulz, Christian
    CANCER REPORTS, 2021, 4 (04)
  • [38] Review: Current knowledge on the role of HPV antibodies after natural infection and vaccination: Implications for monitoring an HPV vaccination programme
    Mollers, Madelief
    Vossen, Jeanique M.
    Scherpenisse, Mirte
    van der Klis, Fiona R. M.
    Meijer, Chris J. L. M.
    de Melker, Hester E.
    JOURNAL OF MEDICAL VIROLOGY, 2013, 85 (08) : 1379 - 1385
  • [39] Persistent HPV infection after conization of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia—— a systematic review and meta-analysis
    Yueyang Zhang
    Zhiwen Ni
    Ting Wei
    Qingsong Liu
    BMC Women's Health, 23
  • [40] Association between human papillomavirus (HPV) infection, HPV-related disease, and HIV status in young women
    Moscicki, AB
    Vermund, S
    Holland, C
    Levin, L
    Wilson, C
    JOURNAL OF ADOLESCENT HEALTH, 1998, 22 (02) : 132 - 132