Hsp70:CHIP Ubiquitinates Dysfunctional but Not Native Neuronal NO Synthase

Heat shock protein (Hsp) 70 modulators are being developed to enhance the removal of toxic proteins in a variety of protein misfolding diseases. In the course of our studies on neuronal nitric oxide synthase (nNOS), a client of the Hsp90 and Hsp70 chaperone system, we have established that inactivation of nNOS by heme or tetrahydrobiopterin (BH4) alteration and loss triggers ubiquitination by the Hsp70-associated E3 ligase c-terminus of Hsp70-interacting protein (CHIP) and subsequent degradation in cells. Although in cells Hsp90 and Hsp70 work together to maintain protein quality control, in this study, we specifically developed an assay to assess the selectivity of the Hsp70:CHIP complex for inactivated nNOS. We developed a highly sensitive ELISA to measure Hsp70:CHIP-dependent nNOS ubiquitination without interference from direct ubiquitination by CHIP, as evidenced by Bcl-2 associated athanogene 1-M completely abolishing ubiquitination. To further validate the assay we demonstrated, JG-98, a rhodocyanin compound that acts on Hsp70 but not its inactive structural analog JG-258, enhances the ubiquitination of nNOS 3-fold. Utilizing this assay, we have shown that the Hsp70:CHIP complex preferentially ubiquitinates heme-deficient nNOS (apo-n NOS) over heme-containing nNOS (holo-nNOS). Moreover, depletion of nNOS-bound BH4 triggers ubiquitination of holo-nNOS by the Hsp70:CHIP complex. Most importantly, JG-98 was shown to enhance the ubiquitination of only dysfunctional nNOS while leaving the native functional nNOS untouched. Thus, the finding that enhancing Hsp70:CHIP-mediated ubiquitination does not affect native proteins has important pharmacological implications. Moreover, development of a facile in vitro method for Hsp70:CHIP-mediated ubiquitination will be beneficial for testing other Hsp70 modulators. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT The heat shock protein 70 (Hsp70):c-terminus of Hsp70-interacting protein (CHIP) complex facilitates the ubiquitination and subsequent degradation of several hundred-client proteins, and activation of Hsp70 has been suggested as a therapeutic strategy to enhance the degradation of disease-causing proteins. The current study shows that the pharmacological activation of Hsp70 enhances the ubiquitination of dysfunctional but not native nNOS, and it suggests that this therapeutic strategy will likely be highly selective.