CAN ART-BASED REFLECTION HELP US COPE WITH ORGANISATIONAL CHANGE IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR?

被引:1
|
作者
Hartley, Catherine [1 ]
Lee, Chris [1 ]
机构
[1] LB Camden, Rehabil & Recovery Community Mental Hlth Team, London NW3 5NU, England
关键词
organisational change; denial; paranoid schizoid position; depressive position; creativity; art;
D O I
10.1080/02650533.2013.794773
中图分类号
C916 [社会工作、社会管理、社会规划];
学科分类号
1204 ;
摘要
Never before have public sector jobs been so threatened. Fear and anxiety have shifted their focus, from performance to survival. With reference to immediately contemporary works on the NHS in particular, such as Mandelstam (2011) and Leys and Player (2011), the paper establishes the factual validity of the crisis.The authors conducted a series of workshops for public sector staff to enable them to explore their reactions to the current situation.It is possible to identify increasing levels of denial and other forms of resistance to change similar to those first identified by Menzies' (1959). Drawing on the work of Bion (cited Obholzer & Roberts, 1994) the paper considers the dangers of a retreat to the paranoid schizoid position, and identifies a theoretical clue in Halton (2004) for turning the trauma of change into a creative opportunity.Art has access to emotional, spiritual and creative facets of the human mind that science cannot explore. Klein's (1975) consideration of the infantile and regressive aspect of art is acknowledged. The paper then considers what is revealed by a study of specific works of art which were presented in the workshops; including paintings by Bosch, Rousseau, Breughel and Goya. The work of Zagier-Roberts (1998) and Winnicott (1971) is called upon to endorse the usefulness of such a playful collage of responses.Art can be used to help people move through Kubler Ross' stages of bereavement (1997); not to acceptance but out of the paranoid schizoid position into the depressive position (Klein 1975). Revisiting the work of Halton (2004) and the concept of evolutionary creativity, a move on from the depressive position can begin. Collective validation can be affirmed through a rebooting of the essential public sector values while a radical turning away from organisational priorities, to face the service user, provides a more far reaching optimism than any envisaged by an essentially limited demand for modernisation.In conclusion the paper considers the recent contributions of Dienst (2011) and Dumenil and Levy (2011) to advocate tactical resistance to the denigration of the public sphere.
引用
收藏
页码:441 / 453
页数:13
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] #finaltrashtination. An art-based intervention to collaboratively generate conversations about climate change
    Weder, Franzisca
    JCOM-JOURNAL OF SCIENCE COMMUNICATION, 2022, 21 (02):
  • [32] Can traditional management practices help mountain livestock farms in the Spanish Pyrenees cope with climate change?
    Munoz-Ulecia, Enrique
    Martin-Collado, Daniel
    Bernues, Alberto
    Peral, Alicia Tenza
    Casasus, Isabel
    Villalba, Daniel
    REGIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGE, 2024, 24 (01)
  • [33] Can traditional management practices help mountain livestock farms in the Spanish Pyrenees cope with climate change?
    Enrique Muñoz-Ulecia
    Daniel Martín-Collado
    Alberto Bernués
    Alicia Tenza Peral
    Isabel Casasús
    Daniel Villalba
    Regional Environmental Change, 2024, 24
  • [34] Robot Co-design Can Help Us Engage Child Stakeholders in Ethical Reflection
    Mott, Terran
    Bejarano, Alexandra
    Williams, Tom
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2022 17TH ACM/IEEE INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON HUMAN-ROBOT INTERACTION (HRI '22), 2022, : 14 - 23
  • [35] 'Give us a break!': using a solution focused programme to help young people cope with loss and negative change
    Whitehead, Lisa
    Allan, Marie Clare
    Allen, Kristen
    Duchak, Valerie
    Mason, Carina
    Tully, Scott
    King, Elizabeth
    Mooney, Lindsay
    BEREAVEMENT CARE, 2018, 37 (01) : 17 - 27
  • [36] A Picture Is Worth 1,000 Words: A Reflection on Art-Based Assignments for the Study of Traditional Jewish Texts
    Jaffe, Yael
    JOURNAL OF JEWISH EDUCATION, 2024, 90 (02) : 93 - 124
  • [37] Causes and Duration of Change Resulting from Art-Based Activities for Members of the Australian Defence Force
    Watt, Tavis
    Kehoe, E. James
    JOURNAL OF MILITARY AND VETERANS HEALTH, 2020, 28 (01): : 7 - 15
  • [38] Can genetics help us rethink communication? Public communication of science as a 'double helix'
    Bucchi, M
    FEBS JOURNAL, 2005, 272 : 23 - 23
  • [39] Can genetics help us rethink communication? Public communication of science as a 'double helix'
    Bucchi, M
    NEW GENETICS AND SOCIETY, 2004, 23 (03) : 269 - 283
  • [40] Public health and politics: how political science can help us move forward
    Bekker, Marleen P. M.
    Greer, Scott L.
    Azzopardi-Muscat, Natasha
    McKee, Martin
    EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, 2018, 28 : 1 - 2