Response to Comment on "Forest microclimate dynamics drive plant responses to warming"

被引：1

作者：

Zellweger, Florian ^{[1
,2
]}

De Frenne, Pieter ^{[3
]}

Lenoir, Jonathan ^{[4
]}

Vangansbeke, Pieter ^{[3
]}

Verheyen, Kris ^{[3
]}

Bernhardt-Roemermann, Markus ^{[5
]}

Baeten, Lander ^{[3
]}

Hedl, Radim ^{[6
,7
,15
]}

Berki, Imre ^{[8
]}

Brunet, Jorg ^{[9
]}

Van Calster, Hans ^{[10
]}

Chudomelova, Marketa ^{[6
]}

Decocq, Guillaume ^{[4
]}

Dirnbock, Thomas ^{[11
]}

Durak, Tomasz ^{[12
]}

Heinken, Thilo ^{[13
]}

Jaroszewicz, Bogdan ^{[14
]}

Kopecky, Martin ^{[15
,16
]}

Malis, Frantisek ^{[17
,18
]}

Macek, Martin ^{[15
]}

Malicki, Marek ^{[19
]}

Naaf, Tobias ^{[20
]}

Nagel, Thomas A. ^{[21
]}

Ortmann-Ajkai, Adrienne ^{[22
]}

Petrik, Petr ^{[15
]}

Pielech, Remigiusz ^{[23
]}

Reczynska, Kamila ^{[24
]}

Schmidt, Wolfgang ^{[25
]}

Standovar, Tibor ^{[26
]}

Swierkosz, Krzysztof ^{[27
]}

Teleki, Balazs ^{[28
,29
]}

Vild, Ondrej ^{[6
]}

Wulf, Monika ^{[20
]}

Coomes, David ^{[1
]}

机构：

[1] Univ Cambridge, Dept Plant Sci, Forest Ecol & Conservat Grp, Cambridge CB2 3EA, England

[2] Swiss Fed Inst Forest Snow & Landscape Res WSL, CH-8903 Birmensdorf, Switzerland

[3] Univ Ghent, Forest & Nat Lab, Dept Environm, Fac Biosci Engn, Melle Gontrode, Belgium

[4] Univ Picardie Jules Verne, UR Ecol & Dynam Syst Anthropises, EDYSAN, CNRS,UMR 7058, F-80037 Amiens 1, France

[5] Friedrich Schiller Univ Jena, Inst Ecol & Evolut, D-07743 Jena, Germany

[6] Czech Acad Sci, Inst Bot, CZ-60200 Brno, Czech Republic

[7] Palacky Univ, Dept Bot, Fac Sci, CZ-78371 Olomouc, Czech Republic

[8] Univ Sopron, Inst Environm & Earth Sci, H-9400 Sopron, Hungary

[9] Swedish Univ Agr Sci, Southern Swedish Forest Res Ctr, Box 49, S-23053 Alnarp, Sweden

[10] Res Inst Nat & Forest INBO, B-1000 Brussels, Belgium

[11] Environm Agcy Austria, A-1090 Vienna, Austria

[12] Univ Rzeszow, Dept Plant Physiol & Ecol, PL-35959 Rzeszow, Poland

[13] Univ Potsdam, Gen Bot, Insitute Biochem & Biol, D-14469 Potsdam, Germany

[14] Univ Warsaw, Bialowieza Geobot Stn, Fac Biol, PL-17230 Bialowieza, Poland

[15] Czech Acad Sci, Inst Bot, CZ-25243 Pruhonice, Czech Republic

[16] Czech Univ Life Sci Prague, Fac Forestry & Wood Sci, CZ-16521 Prague 6, Czech Republic

[17] Tech Univ Zvolen, Fac Forestry, SK-96001 Zvolen, Slovakia

[18] Natl Forest Ctr, SK-96001 Zvolen, Slovakia

[19] Univ Wroclaw, Fac Biol Sci, Dept Bot, Wroclaw, Poland

[20] Leibniz Ctr Agr Landscape Res ZALF, D-15374 Muencheberg, Germany

[21] Univ Ljubljana, Biotech Fac, Dept Forestry & Renewable Forest Resources, Ljubljana 1000, Slovenia

[22] Univ Pecs, Inst Biol, Dept Hydrobiol, H-7624 Pecs, Hungary

[23] Univ Agr, Dept Forest Biodivers, Fac Forestry, Krakow, Poland

[24] Univ Wroclaw, Inst Environm Biol, Dept Bot, PL-50328 Wroclaw, Poland

[25] Univ Gottingen, Dept Silviculture & Forest Ecol Temperate Zones, Gottingen, Germany

[26] Eotvos Lorand Univ, Inst Biol, Dept Plant Systemat Ecol & Theoret Biol, H-1117 Budapest, Hungary

[27] Univ Wroclaw, Museum Nat Hist, PL-50335 Wroclaw, Poland

[28] Univ Pecs, Inst Reg Dev, H-7100 Szekszard, Hungary

[29] Univ Debrecen, Dept Ecol, H-4032 Debrecen, Hungary

来源：

SCIENCE | 2020年 / 370卷 / 6520期

基金：

欧盟地平线“2020”;

关键词：

D O I：

10.1126/science.abd6193

中图分类号：

O [数理科学和化学]; P [天文学、地球科学]; Q [生物科学]; N [自然科学总论];

学科分类号：

07 ; 0710 ; 09 ;

摘要：

Bertrand et al. question our interpretation about warming effects on the thermophilization in forest plant communities and propose an alternative way to analyze climatic debt. We show that microclimate warming is a better predictor than macroclimate warming for studying forest plant community responses to warming. Their additional analyses do not affect or change our interpretations and conclusions.

引用

页数：3

共 50 条

[41] Warming and predator drive functional responses of three subtropical cladocerans
Francieli de Fátima Bomfim
Maria da Graça Gama Melão
Renan Castelhano Gebara
Fábio Amodêo Lansac-Tôha
Aquatic Ecology, 2021, 55 : 903 - 914
[42] Warming and predator drive functional responses of three subtropical cladocerans
Bomfim, Francieli de Fatima
Gama Melao, Maria da Graca
Gebara, Renan Castelhano
Lansac-Toha, Fabio Amodeo
AQUATIC ECOLOGY, 2021, 55 (03) : 903 - 914
[43] Microclimate and ecological threshold responses in a warming and wetting experiment following whole tree harvest
McDaniel, M. D.
Wagner, R. J.
Rollinson, C. R.
Kimball, B. A.
Kaye, M. W.
Kaye, J. P.
THEORETICAL AND APPLIED CLIMATOLOGY, 2014, 116 (1-2) : 287 - 299
[44] Microclimate and ecological threshold responses in a warming and wetting experiment following whole tree harvest
M. D. McDaniel
R. J. Wagner
C. R. Rollinson
B. A. Kimball
M. W. Kaye
J. P. Kaye
Theoretical and Applied Climatology, 2014, 116 : 287 - 299
[45] Landscape attributes drive complex spatial microclimate configuration of Brazilian Atlantic forest fragments
Pinto, Severino R. R.
Mendes, Gabriel
Santos, Andre M. M.
Dantas, Mateus
Tabarelli, Marcelo
Melo, Felipe P. L.
TROPICAL CONSERVATION SCIENCE, 2010, 3 (04): : 389 - 402
[46] Tree and forest functioning in response to global warming
Saxe, H
Cannell, MGR
Johnsen, B
Ryan, MG
Vourlitis, G
NEW PHYTOLOGIST, 2001, 149 (03) : 369 - 399
[47] Light and warming drive forest understorey community development in different environments
Blondeel, Haben
Perring, Michael P.
Depauw, Leen
De Lombaerde, Emiel
Landuyt, Dries
De Frenne, Pieter
Verheyen, Kris
GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY, 2020, 26 (03) : 1681 - 1696
[48] A comparison of forest and moorland stream microclimate, heat exchanges and thermal dynamics
Hannah, David M.
Malcolm, Iain A.
Soulsby, Chris
Youngson, Alan F.
HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES, 2008, 22 (07) : 919 - 940
[49] Acceleration of climate warming and plant dynamics in Antarctica
Cannone, Nicoletta
Malfasi, Francesco
Favero-Longo, Sergio Enrico
Convey, Peter
Guglielmin, Mauro
CURRENT BIOLOGY, 2022, 32 (07) : 1599 - +
[50] Colonization and extinction lags drive non-linear responses to warming in mountain plant communities across the Northern Hemisphere
Bektas, Billur
Chisholm, Chelsea
Egelkraut, Dagmar
Lynn, Joshua
Block, Sebastian
Deola, Thomas
Dommanget, Fanny
Enquist, Brian J.
Goldberg, Deborah E.
Haider, Sylvia
Halbritter, Aud H.
He, Yongtao
Jaunatre, Renaud
Jentsch, Anke
Klanderud, Kari
Kardol, Paul
Lachmuth, Susanne
Loucougaray, Gregory
Munkemuller, Tamara
Niedrist, Georg
Nomoto, Hanna
Seltzer, Lorah
Topper, Joachim Paul
Rew, Lisa J.
Seipel, Tim
Shah, Manzoor A.
Telford, Richard James
Walker, Tom W. N.
Wang, Shiping
Wardle, David A.
Wolff, Peter
Yang, Yan
Vandvik, Vigdis
Alexander, Jake M.
ECOGRAPHY, 2024,

← 1 2 3 4 5 →