Effectiveness of bonding systems on bonding durability of a prefabricated porcelain material

The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the bond strength and durability of four bonding systems joined to a prefabricated porcelain material (Vita Celay Blanks). Two sizes of porcelain block were bonded with one of the following systems: (1) Clapearl Bonding Agent and Clapearl DC; (2) Imperva Porcelain Primer and Imperva Dual; (3) Monobond S and Variolink H; or (4) Tokuso Ceramics Primer and Bistite II. Shear bond strength was measured after 24-hour immersion in water and after subsequent thermocycling. The average pre- and post-thermocycling bond strengths in MPa (n=8) were: 52.5 and 42.5 for bonding system (1), 47.7 and 32.8 for (2), 55.0 and 48.8 for (3), and 51.5 and 25.6 for (4). Although prethermocycling results were not statistically different from each other, Group (3) exhibited the greatest strength after thermocycling.