Comparative Effectiveness of Injection Therapies for Hemiplegic Shoulder Pain in Stroke: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis

被引:15
|
作者
Chiu, Yi-Hsiang [1 ]
Chang, Ke-Vin [1 ,2 ,3 ]
Wu, Wei-Ting [2 ]
Hsu, Po-Cheng [2 ]
Ozcakar, Levent [4 ]
机构
[1] Natl Taiwan Univ, Dept Phys Med & Rehabil, Coll Med, Taipei 10048, Taiwan
[2] Natl Taiwan Univ Hosp, Bei Hu Branch, Dept Phys Med & Rehabil, Taipei 10845, Taiwan
[3] Taipei Med Univ, Wang Fang Hosp, Ctr Reg Anesthesia & Pain Med, Taipei 11600, Taiwan
[4] Hacettepe Univ, Dept Phys & Rehabil Med, Med Sch, TR-06100 Ankara, Turkey
关键词
corticosteroid; hemiplegic shoulder; hyaluronic acid; injection; rehabilitation; TOXIN TYPE-A; SUPRASCAPULAR NERVE BLOCK; BOTULINUM-TOXIN; DOUBLE-BLIND; SPASTIC HEMIPLEGIA; SUBSTANCE-P; SURVIVORS;
D O I
10.3390/ph14080788
中图分类号
R914 [药物化学];
学科分类号
100701 ;
摘要
Hemiplegic shoulder pain (HSP) hampers post-stroke functional recovery and is not well managed with conservative treatments. This systematic review aimed to examine the various injection therapies for HSP and investigate their effectiveness at different time points. The protocol of this meta-analysis was registered on INPLASY with a registration number of INPLASY202180010. PubMed, EMBASE, and Scopus were searched from their inception to 4 August 2021 for the clinical studies investigating comparative effectiveness of different injection regimens for treating hemiplegic shoulder pain in patients with stroke. The primary outcome was the weighted mean difference (WMD) on the visual analog scale (VAS) of pain reduction in the fourth-week and between the fourth and twenty-fourth weeks. Ranking probabilities of the WMD for each treatment were obtained using simulations. Seventeen studies with 595 participants were included. The network meta-analysis showed that at the fourth-week, intra-muscular botulinum toxin (BoNT) injections and suprascapular nerve blocks (SSNB) were superior to a placebo, with WMDs of 1.55 (95% CI, 0.09 to 3.01) and 1.44 (95% CI, 0.07 to 2.80), respectively. SSNB possessed the highest probability (53.3%) and appeared to be the best treatment in the fourth-week, followed by intra-muscular BoNT injections (42.6%). Intramuscular BoNT injections were better than the placebo, with a WMD of 1.57 (95% CI, 0.30 to 2.84) between the 4th and 24th weeks. Intramuscular BoNT injections had the highest probability (79.8%) as the best treatment between the 4th and 24th weeks. SSNB was likely to rank first in relieving HSP at the fourth post-treatment week, whereas intra-muscular BoNT injections had the highest probability to achieve the best treatment effectiveness in the post-injection period between the fourth and twenty-fourth weeks. However, as some of the included studies used a non-randomized controlled design, more randomized controlled trials are needed in the future to validate and better understand the short- and long-term efficacy of different injection therapies for management of HSP.
引用
收藏
页数:19
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Comparative effectiveness of multiple acupuncture therapies for primary insomnia: a systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomized trial
    Lu, Yao
    Zhu, Hongfei
    Wang, Qi
    Tian, Chen
    Lai, Honghao
    Hou, Liangying
    Liu, Yafei
    Gao, Ya
    Liu, Ming
    Yang, Fengwen
    Ni, Xiaojia
    Lin, Liyu
    Niu, Junqiang
    Tian, Jinhui
    Ge, Long
    SLEEP MEDICINE, 2022, 93 : 39 - 48
  • [32] Systematic review and network meta-analysis: Comparative effectiveness of therapies for second-line Helicobacter pylori eradication
    Yeo, Yee Hui
    Hsu, Chia-Chen
    Lee, Chiao-Chin
    Ho, Hsiu J.
    Lin, Jaw-Town
    Wu, Ming-Shiang
    Liou, Jyh-Ming
    Wu, Chun-Ying
    JOURNAL OF GASTROENTEROLOGY AND HEPATOLOGY, 2019, 34 (01) : 59 - 67
  • [33] Efficacy and safety of kinesiology tape for hemiplegic shoulder pain: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials
    Li, Lingxin
    Zheng, Yao
    He, Chengqi
    Zhao, Yanmin
    JOURNAL OF BACK AND MUSCULOSKELETAL REHABILITATION, 2022, 35 (01) : 35 - 46
  • [34] Effectiveness of interventions for pain relief in hysterosalpingography: A network meta-analysis and systematic review
    Guo, Xin
    Tan, Zongjian
    PAKISTAN JOURNAL OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, 2017, 33 (04) : 1029 - 1035
  • [35] Effectiveness of acupuncture for pain relief in shoulder-hand syndrome after stroke: a systematic evaluation and Bayesian network meta-analysis
    Huang, Ting
    Yao, Hongfang
    Huang, Junneng
    Wang, Ning
    Zhou, Chunjun
    Huang, Xuyang
    Tan, Xiangyuan
    Li, Yanyan
    Jie, Yuyu
    Wang, Xiang
    Yang, Yu
    Liang, Yingye
    Yue, Siqian
    Mao, Yawen
    Lai, Songxian
    Zheng, Jingyiqi
    He, Yufeng
    FRONTIERS IN NEUROLOGY, 2023, 14
  • [36] Acupuncture for Poststroke Shoulder Pain: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
    Lee, Sook-Hyun
    Lim, Sung Min
    EVIDENCE-BASED COMPLEMENTARY AND ALTERNATIVE MEDICINE, 2016, 2016
  • [37] Effectiveness of non-pharmacological therapies for treating post-stroke depression: A systematic review and network meta-analysis
    Yi, Yunhao
    Zhao, Weijie
    Lv, Shimeng
    Zhang, Guangheng
    Rong, Yuanhang
    Wang, Xin
    Yang, Jingrong
    Li, Ming
    GENERAL HOSPITAL PSYCHIATRY, 2024, 90 : 99 - 107
  • [38] Protocols Used by Occupational Therapists on Shoulder Pain after Stroke: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
    De Souza, Isis Gabriele
    De Souza, Raphael Fabricio
    Barbosa, Felipe Douglas Silva
    Scipioni, Kelly Regina Dias Da Silva
    Aidar, Felipe J.
    Zanona, Aristela De Freitas
    OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY INTERNATIONAL, 2021, 2021
  • [39] Comparative Effectiveness of Botulinum Toxin Injection for Chronic Shoulder Pain: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
    Hsu, Po-Cheng
    Wu, Wei-Ting
    Han, Der-Sheng
    Chang, Ke-Vin
    TOXINS, 2020, 12 (04)
  • [40] Extracorporeal shock wave therapy for shoulder pain after stroke: A systematic review and meta-analysis
    Zhang, Tingyu
    Zhang, Cai
    CLINICAL REHABILITATION, 2023, 37 (06) : 774 - 790