Challenges of Clustering Multimodal Clinical Data: Review of Applications in Asthma Subtyping

被引:25
|
作者
Horne, Elsie [1 ]
Tibble, Holly [1 ]
Sheikh, Aziz [1 ]
Tsanas, Athanasios [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Edinburgh, Edinburgh Med Sch, Usher Inst, Nine Edinburgh Bio Quarter,9 Little France Rd, Edinburgh EH16 4UX, Midlothian, Scotland
基金
英国医学研究理事会; 英国经济与社会研究理事会; 英国惠康基金; 英国工程与自然科学研究理事会;
关键词
asthma; cluster analysis; data mining; machine learning; unsupervised machine learning; SYSTEMATIC ANALYSIS; YOUNG-CHILDREN; GLOBAL BURDEN; 195; COUNTRIES; PHENOTYPES; DISEASE; HETEROGENEITY; TERRITORIES; PREVALENCE; VALIDATION;
D O I
10.2196/16452
中图分类号
R-058 [];
学科分类号
摘要
Background: In the current era of personalized medicine, there is increasing interest in understanding the heterogeneity in disease populations. Cluster analysis is a method commonly used to identify subtypes in heterogeneous disease populations. The clinical data used in such applications are typically multimodal, which can make the application of traditional cluster analysis methods challenging. Objective: This study aimed to review the research literature on the application of clustering multimodal clinical data to identify asthma subtypes. We assessed common problems and shortcomings in the application of cluster analysis methods in determining asthma subtypes, such that they can be brought to the attention of the research community and avoided in future studies. Methods: We searched PubMed and Scopus bibliographic databases with terms related to cluster analysis and asthma to identify studies that applied dissimilarity-based cluster analysis methods. We recorded the analytic methods used in each study at each step of the cluster analysis process. Results: Our literature search identified 63 studies that applied cluster analysis to multimodal clinical data to identify asthma subtypes. The features fed into the cluster algorithms were of a mixed type in 47 (75%) studies and continuous in 12 (19%), and the feature type was unclear in the remaining 4 (6%) studies. A total of 23 (37%) studies used hierarchical clustering with Ward linkage, and 22 (35%) studies used k-means clustering. Of these 45 studies, 39 had mixed-type features, but only 5 specified dissimilarity measures that could handle mixed-type features. A further 9 (14%) studies used a preclustering step to create small clusters to feed on a hierarchical method. The original sample sizes in these 9 studies ranged from 84 to 349. The remaining studies used hierarchical clustering with other linkages (n=3), medoid-based methods (n=3), spectral clustering (n=1), and multiple kernel k-means clustering (n=1), and in 1 study, the methods were unclear. Of 63 studies, 54 (86%) explained the methods used to determine the number of clusters, 24 (38%) studies tested the quality of their cluster solution, and 11 (17%) studies tested the stability of their solution. Reporting of the cluster analysis was generally poor in terms of the methods employed and their justification. Conclusions: This review highlights common issues in the application of cluster analysis to multimodal clinical data to identify asthma subtypes. Some of these issues were related to the multimodal nature of the data, but many were more general issues in the application of cluster analysis. Although cluster analysis may be a useful tool for investigating disease subtypes, we recommend that future studies carefully consider the implications of clustering multimodal data, the cluster analysis process itself, and the reporting of methods to facilitate replication and interpretation of findings.
引用
收藏
页数:20
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] An Empirical Study on Multimodal Activity Clustering of Android Applications
    Choi, Sungmin
    Seo, Hyeon-Tae
    Han, Yo-Sub
    IEEE ACCESS, 2023, 11 : 53598 - 53614
  • [32] New clustering method and its applications in multimodal optimization
    Yu, X.J.
    Wang, Z.J.
    Qinghua Daxue Xuebao/Journal of Tsinghua University, 2001, 41 (04): : 159 - 162
  • [33] Review of Smart Meter Data Analytics: Applications, Methodologies, and Challenges
    Wang, Yi
    Chen, Qixin
    Hong, Tao
    Kang, Chongqing
    IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON SMART GRID, 2019, 10 (03) : 3125 - 3148
  • [34] Vortioxetine, a novel antidepressant with multimodal activity: Review of preclinical and clinical data
    Sanchez, Connie
    Asin, Karen E.
    Artigas, Francesc
    PHARMACOLOGY & THERAPEUTICS, 2015, 145 : 43 - 57
  • [35] Applications of Blockchain Technology in Clinical Trials: Review and Open Challenges
    Omar, Ilhaam A.
    Jayaraman, Raja
    Salah, Khaled
    Yaqoob, Ibrar
    Ellahham, Samer
    ARABIAN JOURNAL FOR SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING, 2021, 46 (04) : 3001 - 3015
  • [36] Applications of Blockchain Technology in Clinical Trials: Review and Open Challenges
    Ilhaam A. Omar
    Raja Jayaraman
    Khaled Salah
    Ibrar Yaqoob
    Samer Ellahham
    Arabian Journal for Science and Engineering, 2021, 46 : 3001 - 3015
  • [37] Data clustering: A review
    Jain, AK
    Murty, MN
    Flynn, PJ
    ACM COMPUTING SURVEYS, 1999, 31 (03) : 264 - 323
  • [38] Clinical data in asthma
    Witts, LJ
    LANCET, 1934, 1 : 275 - 280
  • [39] Advancing healthcare through multimodal data fusion: a comprehensive review of techniques and applications
    Teoh, Jing Ru
    Dong, Jian
    Zuo, Xiaowei
    Lai, Khin Wee
    Hasikin, Khairunnisa
    Wu, Xiang
    PEERJ COMPUTER SCIENCE, 2024, 10
  • [40] Advancing healthcare through multimodal data fusion: a comprehensive review of techniques and applications
    Teoh, Jing Ru
    Dong, Jian
    Zuo, Xiaowei
    Lai, Khin Wee
    Hasikin, Khairunnisa
    Wu, Xiang
    PeerJ Computer Science, 2024, 10