Human rights without democracy? A critique of the separationist thesis

被引:16
|
作者
Langlois, AJ [1 ]
机构
[1] Flinders Univ S Australia, Adelaide, SA 5001, Australia
关键词
D O I
10.1353/hrq.2003.0047
中图分类号
D0 [政治学、政治理论];
学科分类号
0302 ; 030201 ;
摘要
The internationalization of democracy and human rights since World War 11 is an achievement of great proportions and significance. However, while human rights are regularly seen as universally applicable, not all see democracy as the most appropriate form of government for all peoples. Some proponents of human rights have therefore come to the conclusion that insisting on a link between human rights and democracy will be harmful for the further acceptance of human rights within the international society. They claim that human rights and democratization should be separated. The author calls this claim the separationist thesis and examines this thesis and the various grounds which may be presented in its favor, before mounting a series of critical arguments against it. He concludes that human rights without democracy are standards or norms, but not rights as such.
引用
收藏
页码:990 / 1019
页数:30
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] THE MODERN POSSIBILITIES OF HUMAN RIGHTS. A CRITIQUE OF THE NEGATIVE CRITIQUE OF LAW AND RIGHTS
    Tapia Arguello, Sergio Martin
    MEXICAN LAW REVIEW, 2018, 10 (02) : 139 - 154
  • [22] Globalizing Democracy and Human Rights
    Talbott, William J.
    PHILOSOPHICAL REVIEW, 2007, 116 (02): : 294 - 297
  • [23] LAITY, HUMAN RIGHTS AND DEMOCRACY
    Jamil Cury, Carlos Roberto
    REVISTA CONTEMPORANEA DE EDUCACAO, 2013, 8 (16): : 36 - 58
  • [24] Militant Democracy and Human Rights
    Greenberg, Udi
    NEW GERMAN CRITIQUE, 2015, (126) : 169 - 195
  • [25] Democracy and human rights.
    Savage, M
    INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS, 2000, 76 (04) : 863 - 863
  • [26] Globalizing democracy and human rights
    Gray, Kevin
    DIALOGUE-CANADIAN PHILOSOPHICAL REVIEW, 2006, 45 (04) : 779 - 782
  • [27] Globalizing Democracy and Human Rights
    Gilabert, Pablo
    RES PUBLICA-A JOURNAL OF MORAL LEGAL AND POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY, 2006, 12 (04): : 435 - 443
  • [28] The Korean democracy and human rights
    Serrano, Gustavo Hernandez
    Cueto, Maria del Carmen Hernandez
    Parra, Irene Rodriguez
    PORTES-REVISTA MEXICANA DE ESTUDIOS SOBRE LA CUENCA DEL PACIFICO, 2023, 17 (33): : 103 - 118
  • [29] Globalizing democracy and human rights
    Prempeh, EOK
    CANADIAN JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE-REVUE CANADIENNE DE SCIENCE POLITIQUE, 2005, 38 (03): : 814 - 815
  • [30] Nationalism, democracy, and human rights
    Cardus S.
    Human Rights Review, 2000, 2 (1) : 104 - 108