Variability in HER2 expression between primary colorectal cancer and corresponding metastases

PurposeThis study aimed to investigate the HER2 status of primary colorectal cancer (CRC) and corresponding metastases, and determine the correlation between HER2 and clinicopathological characteristics.MethodsWe collected the clinicopathological features of 98 CRC patients and 66 patients which were previously evaluated for the KRAS status. The tissue samples of primary CRC tumors (n=98), noninvolved colorectal mucosa (n=98), paired lymph nodes (n=98, 69 patients had positive metastatic nodes), and liver metastases (n=22) were evaluated using immunohistochemistry for HER2. The kappa test was used to evaluate the concordance rate of HER2 status. Survival analysis was established according to the Kaplan-Meier method.ResultsHER2 overexpression was more common in primary tumors among the younger patients (P<0.05). No survival significance was revealed in the HER2 status. The HER2-positive rate was 11.2% for the primary CRC tumors, 0% for the normal adjacent mucosa tissues, 10.1% for the matched positive lymph nodes, and 31.8% for the corresponding metastasis. Seven of sixty-nine cases (10.1%) exhibited biomarker discordance in nodal metastases compared with primary tumors (=0.48, P<0.05); 6 out of 22 cases (27.3%) exhibited biomarker discrepancy in liver metastases compared with primary tumors (=0.32, P>0.05). Compared with lymph nodes, HER2 overexpression in the primary tissue was more common in KRAS wild-type patients (P<0.05).ConclusionsThe present study showed a high rate of discordance in matched pairs of primary tumors and metastases, suggesting that the accurate evaluation of HER2 status is essential before any therapeutic decision.