Reducing COVID-19 airborne transmission risks on public transportation buses: an empirical study on aerosol dispersion and control

被引:37
|
作者
Edwards, Nathan J. [1 ]
Widrick, Rebecca [2 ]
Wilmes, Justin [3 ]
Breisch, Ben [1 ]
Gerschefske, Mike [4 ]
Sullivan, Jon [5 ]
Potember, Richard [6 ]
Espinoza-Calvio, Angelica [6 ]
机构
[1] Mitre Corp, Syst Engn Innovat Ctr, 1155 Acad Pk Loop, Colorado Springs, CO 80910 USA
[2] Mitre Corp, Space Div, Burlington Rd, Bedford, MA 01730 USA
[3] Mitre Corp, Space Div, Colorado Springs, CO 80910 USA
[4] Mitre Corp, Integrated All Domain Effects Div, Colorado Springs, CO 80910 USA
[5] Mitre Corp, Mech & Reliable Syst Dept, Burlington Rd, Bedford, MA 01730 USA
[6] Mitre Corp, Syst Engn Innovat Ctr, Mclean, VA USA
关键词
Kihong Park;
D O I
10.1080/02786826.2021.1966376
中图分类号
TQ [化学工业];
学科分类号
0817 ;
摘要
This study is one of the first COVID-19 related bus studies to fully characterize cough aerosol dispersion and control in the highly turbulent real-world environment of driving regular bus routes on both a school bus and a transit bus. While several other bus studies have been conducted, they were limited to clinical contact tracing, simulation, or partial characterization of aerosol transmission in the passenger areas with constraint conditions. When considering the risk of transmission of SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19) and other highly infectious airborne diseases, ground based public transportation systems are high-risk environments for airborne transmission particularly since social distancing of six feet is not practical on most buses. This study demonstrates that wearing of masks reduced the overall particle count released into the bus by an average of 50% or more depending on mask quality and reduced the dispersion distance by several feet. The study also demonstrates an 84.36% reduction in aerosol particles and an 80.28% reduction in the mean aerosol residence time for some test cases. We conducted 84 experimental runs using nebulized 10% sodium chloride and a mechanical exhalation simulator that resulted in 78.3 million data points and 124 miles of on-the-road testing. Our study not only captures the dispersion patterns using 28 networked particle counters, it also quantifies the effectiveness of using on-board fans, opening of various windows, use of face coverings or masks, and the use of the transit bus HVAC system. This work additionally provides empirical observations of aerosol dispersion in a real-world turbulent air environment, which are remarkably different than many existing fluid dynamics simulations, and also offers substantial discussion on the implications for inclement weather conditions, driver safety, retrofit applications to improve bus air quality, and operational considerations for public transportation organizations.
引用
收藏
页码:1378 / 1397
页数:20
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] The impact of natural ventilation on airborne biocontaminants: a study on COVID-19 dispersion in an open office
    Abbas, Gunsu Merin
    Gursel Dino, Ipek
    ENGINEERING CONSTRUCTION AND ARCHITECTURAL MANAGEMENT, 2022, 29 (04) : 1609 - 1641
  • [22] Tracing contacts to evaluate the transmission of COVID-19 from highly exposed individuals in public transportation
    Ponte, Caio
    Carmona, Humberto A.
    Oliveira, Erneson A.
    Caminha, Carlos
    Neto, Antonio S. Lima
    Andrade, Jose S., Jr.
    Furtado, Vasco
    SCIENTIFIC REPORTS, 2021, 11 (01)
  • [23] Tracing contacts to evaluate the transmission of COVID-19 from highly exposed individuals in public transportation
    Caio Ponte
    Humberto A. Carmona
    Erneson A. Oliveira
    Carlos Caminha
    Antonio S. Lima
    José S. Andrade
    Vasco Furtado
    Scientific Reports, 11
  • [24] COVID-19 transmission risk minimization at public transportation stops using Differential Evolution algorithm
    Mutlu, Mehmet Metin
    Aksoy, Ilyas Cihan
    Alver, Yalcin
    EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF TRANSPORT AND INFRASTRUCTURE RESEARCH, 2021, 21 (01): : 53 - 69
  • [25] Ventilation measures to control aerosol transmission based on COVID-19 outbreaks in hospitals in Japan
    Hayashi, Motoya
    Honma, Yoshinori
    Kikuta, Koki
    Hasegawa, Asako
    Murata, Sayaka
    Yamada, Hiromi
    Ogata, Masayuki
    Kagi, Naoki
    Yanagi, U.
    Yamanaka, Toshio
    Kim, Hoon
    Kobayashi, Kenichi
    Kaihara, Noriko
    Ito, Akira
    Shinohara, Fumihiko
    Morimoto, Shoichi
    JAPAN ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW, 2024, 7 (01):
  • [26] Barrier Devices for Reducing Aerosol and Droplet Transmission in COVID-19 Patients: Advantages, Disadvantages, and Alternative Solutions
    Endersby, Ryan Vincent William
    Ho, Esther Ching Yee
    Spencer, Adam Oscar
    Goldstein, David Howard
    Schubert, Edward
    ANESTHESIA AND ANALGESIA, 2020, 131 (02): : E121 - E123
  • [27] Transmission dynamics and control methodology of COVID-19: A modeling study
    Zhu, Hongjun
    Li, Yan
    Jin, Xuelian
    Huang, Jiangping
    Liu, Xin
    Qian, Ying
    Tan, Jindong
    APPLIED MATHEMATICAL MODELLING, 2021, 89 : 1983 - 1998
  • [28] Transmission dynamics and control strategies of COVID-19: a modelling study
    Mustapha, U. T.
    Hincal, E.
    Yusuf, A.
    Qureshi, S.
    Sanlidag, T.
    Muhammad, S. M.
    Kaymakamzade, B.
    Gokbulut, N.
    BULLETIN OF THE KARAGANDA UNIVERSITY-MATHEMATICS, 2021, 102 (02): : 92 - 105
  • [29] Transmission Dynamics and Control of COVID-19: A Mathematical Modelling Study
    Das, Kalyan
    Srinivas, M. N.
    Shahrear, Pabel
    Rahman, S. M. Saydur
    Nahid, Md M. H.
    Murthy, B. S. N.
    JOURNAL OF APPLIED NONLINEAR DYNAMICS, 2023, 12 (02) : 405 - 425
  • [30] Transportation of intubated COVID-19 patients: Bain circuit with underwater seal system is an option to prevent aerosol transmission
    Kumar, Amarjeet
    Kumar, Ajeet
    Kumar, Neeraj
    Sinha, Chandni
    Kumar, Abhyuday
    JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ANESTHESIA, 2020, 65