Effects of soil particle size on metal bioaccessibility and health risk assessment

Oral ingestion is the main exposure pathway through which humans ingest trace metals in the soil, particularly for children. Metals in different soil particle size fractions may vary in terms of concentration and properties. Urban school/kindergarten soil samples were collected from three cities: Lanzhou in northwest China, Wuhan in central China, and Shenzhen in southeast China. Soil samples were classified according to particle size (< 63 mu m, 63-150 mu m, 150-250 mu m, and 250-2000 mu m) to estimate the effects of soil particle size on the total content and bioaccessibility of metals (Cd, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb, and Zn). Based on the results, we assessed whether the standard size < 150 mu m (containing < 63 mu m and 63-150 mu m), recommended by the Technical Review Workgroup (TRW) of the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), and < 250 mu m (containing < 63 mu m, 63-150 mu m, and 150-250) recommended by the Bioaccessibility Research Group of Europe (BARGE), are suitable where the largest proportion adhering to hands is the finest soil (< 63 mu m). The results showed that different metals exhibited different relationships between soil particle size and content and between soil particle size and bioaccessibility. Pb and Zn generally exhibited the greatest bioaccessibility in the coarsest particle sizes (250-2000 mu m); whereas the highest Ni bioaccessibility occurred in the finest sizes (< 63 mu m); the bioaccessibility of other metals did not exhibit any obvious relationships with particle size. When assessing health risks using bioaccessible metal content in the recommended soil particle size ranges (< 150 mu m and < 250 mu m) and in finer particles (< 63 mu m), the results for noncarcinogenic risks to children exhibited no obvious difference, while the actual carcinogenic risks may be underestimated with the use of soil particle size ranges < 150 mu m and < 250 mu m. Therefore, when choosing an optimal particle size fraction to evaluate the health risk of oral soil ingestion, we recommend the use of the bioaccessible metal content in < 63 mu m soil fraction.