Publication Inaccuracies Listed in General Surgery Residency Training Program Applications

被引:3
|
作者
Yeh, Daniel Dante [1 ]
Reynolds, John M. [2 ]
Pust, Gerd Daniel [1 ]
Sleeman, Danny [1 ]
Meizoso, Jonathan P. [1 ]
Menzel, Christopher [3 ]
Horkan, Davis [1 ]
Lineberry, Matthew [4 ]
Yudkowsky, Rachel [5 ]
Park, Yoon Soo [5 ]
机构
[1] Univ Miami, Jackson Mem Hosp, Ryder Trauma Ctr, Miller Sch Med, Miami, FL 33101 USA
[2] Univ Miami, Calder Med Lib, Miami, FL 33101 USA
[3] Vanderbilt Univ, Med Ctr, Nashville, TN USA
[4] Univ Kansas, Med Ctr, Kansas City, KS 66103 USA
[5] Univ Illinois, Chicago, IL USA
关键词
DEANS LETTERS; MISREPRESENTATION; APPLICANTS; PREVALENCE; AUTHORSHIP;
D O I
10.1016/j.jamcollsurg.2021.07.002
中图分类号
R61 [外科手术学];
学科分类号
摘要
BACKGROUND: Professionalism is a core competency that is difficult to assess. We examined the incidence of publication inaccuracies in Electronic Residency Application Service applications to our training program as potential indicators of unprofessional behavior. STUDY DESIGN: We reviewed all 2019-2020 National Resident Matching Program applicants being considered for interview. Applicant demographic characteristics recorded included standard-ized examination scores, gender, medical school, and medical school ranking (2019 US News & World Report). Publication verification by a medical librarian was performed for peer-reviewed journal articles/abstracts, peer-reviewed book chapters, and peer-reviewed online publications. Inaccuracies were classified as "nonserious" (eg incorrect author order without author rank promotion) or "serious" (eg miscategorization, non-peer-reviewed journal, incorrect author order with author rank promotion, nonauthorship of cited exist-ing publication, and unverifiable publication). Multivariate logistic regression analysis was performed for demographic characteristics to identify predictors of overall inaccuracy and serious inaccuracy. RESULTS: Of 319 applicants, 48 (15%) had a total of 98 inaccuracies; after removing nonserious inac-curacies, 37 (12%) with serious inaccuracies remained. Seven publications were reported in predatory open access journals. In the regression model, none of the variables (US vs non -US medical school, gender, or medical school ranking) were significantly associated with overall inaccuracy or serious inaccuracy. CONCLUSIONS: One in 8 applicants (12%) interviewing at a general surgery residency program were found to have a serious inaccuracy in publication reporting on their Electronic Residency Application Service application. These inaccuracies might represent inattention to detail or professional-ism transgressions. (C) 2021 by the American College of Surgeons. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码:545 / 553
页数:9
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Public Perceptions of General Surgery Residency Training
    Dickinson, Karen J.
    Bass, Barbara L.
    Pei, Kevin Y.
    JOURNAL OF SURGICAL EDUCATION, 2021, 78 (03) : 717 - 727
  • [22] IMPACT OF A SIMULATED LAPAROSCOPIC TRAINING PROGRAM IN A THREE-YEAR GENERAL SURGERY RESIDENCY
    Tejos, Rodrigo
    Avila, Ruben
    Inzunza, Martin
    Achurra, Pablo
    Castillo, Richard
    Romberg, Anne
    Cordero, Octavio
    Kusanovich, Rodrigo
    Bellolio, Felipe
    Varas, Julian
    Martinez, Jorge
    ABCD-ARQUIVOS BRASILEIROS DE CIRURGIA DIGESTIVA-BRAZILIAN ARCHIVES OF DIGESTIVE SURGERY, 2019, 32 (02):
  • [23] Should Robotic Surgery Training Become a General Surgery Residency Requirement? A National Survey of Program Directors in Surgery
    Rodriguez, Paula Porras
    Kapadia, Sonam
    Moazzez, Ashkan
    Singer, George
    Neville, Angela
    Yetasook, Amy
    Dauphine, Christine
    JOURNAL OF SURGICAL EDUCATION, 2022, 79 (06) : E242 - E247
  • [24] Should Robotic Surgery Training Be Prioritized in General Surgery Residency? A Survey of Fellowship Program Director Perspectives
    Kapadia, Sonam
    Shellito, Adam
    Tom, Cynthia M.
    Ozao-Choy, Junko
    Simms, Eric
    Neville, Angela
    Petrie, Beverley A.
    Dauphine, Christine
    JOURNAL OF SURGICAL EDUCATION, 2020, 77 (06) : E245 - E250
  • [25] Rural Surgery Experiences in General Surgery Residency Training-The Current State an ACGME Sponsored Survey of General Surgery Program Directors
    Heller, Stephanie F.
    Brasel, Karen J.
    Dissanaike, Sharmila
    Fox, Chris A.
    JOURNAL OF SURGICAL EDUCATION, 2025, 82 (03)
  • [26] Ultimate Publication Rate of Unpublished Manuscripts Listed on Radiology Residency Applications at One Institution
    Grimm, Lars J.
    Maxfield, Charles M.
    ACADEMIC MEDICINE, 2013, 88 (11) : 1719 - 1722
  • [28] Evaluation of the general practice residency training program, by students
    Carrier, Helene
    Janczewski, Aurelie
    EXERCER-LA REVUE FRANCOPHONE DE MEDECINE GENERALE, 2016, 27 (124): : 24S - 25S
  • [29] Identifying inaccuracies on emergency medicine residency applications
    Katz E.D.
    Shockley L.
    Kass L.
    Howes D.
    Tupesis J.P.
    Weaver C.
    Sayan O.R.
    Hogan V.
    Begue J.
    Vrocher D.
    Frazer J.
    Evans T.
    Hern G.
    Riviello R.
    Rivera A.
    Kinoshita K.
    Ferguson E.
    BMC Medical Education, 5 (1)
  • [30] The General Surgery Residency Program in Italy: a changing scenario
    Marco Montorsi
    Nicolò De Manzini
    Updates in Surgery, 2019, 71 : 195 - 196