The effects of monetary policy shocks: Comparing contemporaneous versus long-run identifying restrictions

This study compares the effects of monetary policy shocks on the macroeconomy using four different procedures for identifying policy shocks that use contemporaneous restrictions and a procedure that uses long-run restrictions. Impulse response functions are computed using the same vector autoregressive (VAR) model and sample period. The comparison is done for a model that includes only a short-term interest rate and for a model that adds a long-term rate as well. Sources of differences in the magnitude of effects across identification schemes are examined.