Privileges of First-Person Reference and of Third-Person Reference

被引:0
|
作者
Melchior, Guido [1 ]
机构
[1] Graz Univ, Inst Philosophie, A-8010 Graz, Austria
关键词
Reference; Intentionality; Self-knowledge; Self-reference; Perspectives;
D O I
10.1007/s12136-010-0118-5
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
It is a widely held view that persons have privileged knowledge about their own minds, although numerous different views on what this privilege exactly consists of exist. One possible way of interpreting it is to claim that persons can refer to their own mental states in a privileged way. I will argue that this view has to be extended. Our common-sense view about reference to mental states implies that besides privileges of first-person reference to one's own mental states, there also exist privileges of third-person reference to the mental states of others: Other persons can refer to all of the mental states of a person in a way that the person cannot. In a next step, I will explain that persons can take two perspectives towards their own mental states: a first-person perspective and a third-person perspective. I will conclude that the possibilities of first-person reference from a third-person perspective are limited.
引用
收藏
页码:37 / 52
页数:16
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] Third-Person Bio
    Barkley, Christine
    [J]. MASSACHUSETTS REVIEW, 2022, 63 (04): : 696 - 697
  • [42] MUTUAL REFERENCE FRAME-QUALITY ASSESSMENT FOR FIRST-PERSON VIDEOS
    Bai, Chen
    Reibman, Amy R.
    [J]. 2017 24TH IEEE INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON IMAGE PROCESSING (ICIP), 2017, : 290 - 294
  • [43] Representing the cognitive construal of Chinese first-person singular reference in discourse
    Liu, Fengguang
    Xue, Bing
    [J]. LANGUAGE SCIENCES, 2018, 67 : 1 - 13
  • [44] When my wrongs are worse than yours: Behavioral and neural asymmetries in first-person and third-person perspectives of accidental harms
    Hirschfeld-Kroen, Joshua
    Jiang, Kevin
    Wasserman, Emily
    Anzellotti, Stefano
    Young, Liane
    [J]. JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY, 2021, 94
  • [45] Topic-relevant reference groups and dimensions of distance - Political advertising and first- and third-person effects
    Meirick, PC
    [J]. COMMUNICATION RESEARCH, 2004, 31 (02) : 234 - 255
  • [46] Vamps and Villains or Citizen-Subjects? Converting a Third-Person Self-Conception of the Indian Christians into a First-Person Narrative
    Sebastian, Mrinalini
    [J]. STUDIES IN WORLD CHRISTIANITY, 2010, 16 : 109 - 125
  • [47] Reference and the first person pronoun
    Glock, HJ
    Hacker, PMS
    [J]. LANGUAGE & COMMUNICATION, 1996, 16 (02) : 95 - 105
  • [48] THIRD-PERSON OVERT PRONOUN AND ZERO REFERENCE IN ESTONIAN: INSIGHTS FROM TWO EXPERIMENTS
    Hint, Helen
    Reile, Maria
    Kaiser, Elsi
    [J]. EESTI JA SOOME-UGRI KEELETEADUSE AJAKIRI-JOURNAL OF ESTONIAN AND FINNO-UGRIC LINGUISTICS, 2023, 14 (02): : 75 - 109
  • [49] Joint Person Segmentation and Identification in Synchronized First- and Third-Person Videos
    Xu, Mingze
    Fan, Chenyou
    Wang, Yuchen
    Ryoo, Michael S.
    Crandall, David J.
    [J]. COMPUTER VISION - ECCV 2018, PT I, 2018, 11205 : 656 - 672
  • [50] The use of storytelling and first-person narratives in communication by Las Kellys as a reference for NGOs
    Fernandez-Munoz, Cristobal
    Tome-Caballero, Miguel
    [J]. PROFESIONAL DE LA INFORMACION, 2020, 29 (03): : 1 - 11