Comment on "Linear superposition of regular black hole solutions of Einstein nonlinear electrodynamics"

被引:10
|
作者
Bronnikov, Kirill A. [1 ,2 ,3 ]
机构
[1] VNIIMS, Ozyornaya Ulitsa 46, Moscow 119361, Russia
[2] Peoples Friendship Univ Russia RUDN Univ, Inst Gravitat & Cosmol, Ulitsa Miklukho Maklaya 6, Moscow 117198, Russia
[3] Natl Res Nucl Univ MEPhI, Kashirskoe Shosse 31, Moscow 115409, Russia
来源
PHYSICAL REVIEW D | 2020年 / 101卷 / 12期
关键词
THEOREM;
D O I
10.1103/PhysRevD.101.128501
中图分类号
P1 [天文学];
学科分类号
0704 ;
摘要
It is argued that in the paper by A. A. Garcia-Diaz and G. Gutierrez-Cano [Phys. Rev. D 100, 064068 (2019)] on nonlinear electrodynamics coupled to general relativity, along with some interesting results and useful observations, many statements are either inaccurate or incomplete. In particular, the authors only consider solutions with an electric charge, whereas their magnetic counterparts have features of equal interest, both similar to and different from those of electric ones. Moreover, it is not mentioned that in electric solutions with a regular center the Lagrangian function L(f) (f = F mu nu F mu nu) cannot have a Maxwell weak-field limit. The observation on superpositions of regular solutions suffers some inaccuracies. The present Comment tries to fill these gaps and to provide necessary corrections.
引用
收藏
页数:4
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] REMOVING BLACK HOLE SINGULARITIES WITH NONLINEAR ELECTRODYNAMICS
    Corda, Christian
    Mosquera Cuesta, Herman J.
    MODERN PHYSICS LETTERS A, 2010, 25 (28) : 2423 - 2429
  • [42] On the black hole mass decomposition in nonlinear electrodynamics
    Pereira, Jonas P.
    Mosquera Cuesta, Herman J.
    Rueda, Jorge A.
    Ruffini, R.
    PHYSICS LETTERS B, 2014, 734 : 396 - 402
  • [43] Regular and black hole solutions in the Einstein-Skyrme theory with negative cosmological constant
    Shiiki, N
    Sawado, N
    CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM GRAVITY, 2005, 22 (17) : 3561 - 3573
  • [44] A general study of regular and singular black hole solutions in Einstein’s conformal gravity
    Qiqi Zhang
    Leonardo Modesto
    Cosimo Bambi
    The European Physical Journal C, 2018, 78
  • [45] A general study of regular and singular black hole solutions in Einstein's conformal gravity
    Zhang, Qiqi
    Modesto, Leonardo
    Bambi, Cosimo
    EUROPEAN PHYSICAL JOURNAL C, 2018, 78 (06):
  • [46] REGULAR AND BLACK-HOLE SOLUTIONS OF EINSTEIN-YANG-MILLS DILATON THEORY
    LAVRELASHVILI, G
    MAISON, D
    NUCLEAR PHYSICS B, 1993, 410 (02) : 407 - 422
  • [47] New regular black hole solutions
    Lemos, Jose P. S.
    Zanchin, Vilson T.
    XIX INTERNATIONAL FALL WORKSHOP ON GEOMETRY AND PHYSICS, 2011, 1360 : 145 - 150
  • [48] Slow-rotating dirty black hole in Einstein-nonlinear electrodynamics-dilaton theory
    Mazharimousavi, S. Habib
    PHYSICS OF THE DARK UNIVERSE, 2024, 46
  • [49] LINEAR SUPERPOSITION OF SOLUTIONS OF THE EINSTEIN-MAXWELL-EQUATIONS
    XANTHOPOULOS, BC
    CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM GRAVITY, 1986, 3 (02) : 157 - 167
  • [50] Comment on "Linear superposition in nonlinear equations" - Reply
    Khare, A
    Sukhatme, U
    PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS, 2003, 90 (23)