Teaching and incentives: Substitutes or complements?

被引:0
|
作者
Allen, James [1 ,2 ,6 ]
Mahumane, Arlete [3 ]
Riddell, James [4 ]
Rosenblat, Tanya [5 ]
Yang, Dean [1 ,2 ,6 ]
Yu, Hang [7 ,8 ]
机构
[1] Univ Michigan, Dept Econ, Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA
[2] Univ Michigan, Ford Sch Publ Policy, Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA
[3] Natl Inst Hlth, Beira Operat Res Ctr, Maputo, Mozambique
[4] Univ Michigan, Div Infect Dis, Med Sch, Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA
[5] Univ Michigan, Sch Informat, Dept Econ, Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA
[6] Univ Michigan, Populat Studies Ctr, Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA
[7] Peking Univ, Natl Sch Dev, Beijing, Peoples R China
[8] Peking Univ, Inst South South Cooperat & Dev, Beijing, Peoples R China
基金
美国国家卫生研究院;
关键词
COVID-19; Teaching; Education; Learning; Cost-effectiveness; Mozambique; Africa; EDUCATION EXPERIMENTAL-EVIDENCE; STUDENT-ACHIEVEMENT EVIDENCE; FINANCIAL INCENTIVES; DEVELOPING-COUNTRIES; IMPACT; BEHAVIOR; METAANALYSIS; INFORMATION; LITERACY; DEMAND;
D O I
10.1016/j.econedurev.2022.102317
中图分类号
F [经济];
学科分类号
02 ;
摘要
Interventions to promote learning are often categorized into supply-and demand-side approaches. In a ran-domized experiment to promote learning about COVID-19 among Mozambican adults, we study the interaction between a supply and a demand intervention, respectively: teaching via targeted feedback, and providing financial incentives to learners. In theory, teaching and learner-incentives may be substitutes (crowding out one another) or complements (enhancing one another). Experts surveyed in advance predicted a high degree of substitutability between the two treatments. In contrast, we find substantially more complementarity than ex-perts predicted. Combining teaching and incentive treatments raises COVID-19 knowledge test scores by 0.5 standard deviations, though the standalone teaching treatment is the most cost-effective. The complementarity between teaching and incentives persists in the longer run, over nine months post-treatment.
引用
收藏
页数:22
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] MULTIMARKET OLIGOPOLY - STRATEGIC SUBSTITUTES AND COMPLEMENTS
    BULOW, JI
    GEANAKOPLOS, JD
    KLEMPERER, PD
    [J]. JOURNAL OF POLITICAL ECONOMY, 1985, 93 (03) : 488 - 511
  • [42] Decentralization and Consumer Welfare with Substitutes or Complements
    Pasquier, Nicolas
    [J]. REVIEW OF INDUSTRIAL ORGANIZATION, 2024, 64 (03) : 449 - 469
  • [43] Maintenance and investment: Complements or substitutes? A reappraisal
    Boucekkine, R.
    Fabbri, G.
    Gozzi, F.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF ECONOMIC DYNAMICS & CONTROL, 2010, 34 (12): : 2420 - 2439
  • [44] Private and public consumption: substitutes or complements?
    Jalles, Joao Tovar
    Karras, Georgios
    [J]. OXFORD ECONOMIC PAPERS-NEW SERIES, 2022, 74 (03): : 805 - 819
  • [45] Masturbation and Partnered Sex: Substitutes or Complements?
    Regnerus, Mark
    Price, Joseph
    Gordon, David
    [J]. ARCHIVES OF SEXUAL BEHAVIOR, 2017, 46 (07) : 2111 - 2121
  • [46] Text and voice: complements, substitutes or both?
    Andersson, K.
    Foros, O.
    Steen, F.
    [J]. INDUSTRIAL AND CORPORATE CHANGE, 2009, 18 (06) : 1231 - 1247
  • [47] SUBSTITUTES, COMPLEMENTS AND RIPPLES IN NETWORK FLOWS
    GRANOT, F
    VEINOTT, AF
    [J]. MATHEMATICS OF OPERATIONS RESEARCH, 1985, 10 (03) : 471 - 497
  • [48] Are the informal economy and cryptocurrency substitutes or complements?
    Goel, Rajeev K.
    Mazhar, Ummad
    [J]. APPLIED ECONOMICS, 2024, 56 (20) : 2470 - 2481
  • [49] Democracy and State Capacity: Complements or Substitutes?
    Hanson, Jonathan K.
    [J]. STUDIES IN COMPARATIVE INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT, 2015, 50 (03) : 304 - 330
  • [50] A Unifying Hierarchy of Valuations with Complements and Substitutes
    Feige, Uriel
    Feldman, Michal
    Immorlica, Nicole
    Izsak, Rani
    Lucier, Brendan
    Syrgkanis, Vasilis
    [J]. PROCEEDINGS OF THE TWENTY-NINTH AAAI CONFERENCE ON ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, 2015, : 872 - 878