Conformationally defined 6-s-trans-retinoic acid analogs .3. Structure-activity relationships for nuclear receptor binding, transcriptional activity, and cancer chemopreventive activity

We recently demonstrated that conformationally defined 6-s-trans-retinoic acid (RA) analogs were effective in the prevention of skin papillomas (Vaezi et al. J. Med. Chem. 1994, 37, 4499-4507) and selective agonists for nuclear receptor binding and activation (Alam et al. J. Med. Chem. 1995, 38, 2302-2310). In order to probe important structure-activity relationships, we evaluated a homologous series of four 6-s-trans-retinoids that are 8-(2'-cyclohexen-1'-ylidene)-3,7-dimethyl-2,4,6-octatrienoic acids with different substituents at 2' (R(2)) and 3' (R(1)) positions on the cyclohexene ring. UAB1 (R(1) = R(2) = H), UAB4 (R(1) = R(2) = Me), UAB7 (R(1) = Me, R(2) = iPr), and UAB8 (R(1) = Et, R(2) = iPr) contain alkyl R groups that mimic, to different extents, portions of the trimethylcyclohexenyl ring of RA. Both 9Z- and all-E-isomers of these retinoids were evaluated in binding assays for cellular retinoic acid-binding proteins (CRABP-I and CRABP-II), a nuclear retinoic acid receptor (RAR alpha), and a nuclear retinoid X receptor (RXR alpha). The all E-isomers of UAB retinoids bound tightly to CRABPs and RAR alpha, the binding affinity of the all-E-isomer increased systematically from UAB1 to UAB8, and binding for the latter was comparable to that of all-E-RA. In contrast to RA, the (9Z)-UAB retinoids were at least 200-fold less active than the all-E-isomers in binding to RAR alpha. The (9Z)-UAB isomers exhibited increasingly stronger binding to RXR alpha, and (9Z)-UAB8 was nearly as effective as (9Z)-RA in binding affinity. The retinoids were also evaluated in gene expression assays mediated by RAR alpha and RXR alpha homodimers or RAR alpha/RXR alpha heterodimers. Consistent with the binding affinities, the (all-E)-UAB retinoids activated gene transciption mediated by RAR alpha homodimers or RAR alpha/RXR alpha heterodimers, while the (9Z)-UAB isomers activated only the RXR alpha homodimer-mediated transcription. The all-E- and 9Z-isomers of the UAB retinoids were further evaluated for their capacity to prevent the induction of mouse skin papillomas. When compared to RA, only the (all-E)-UAB retinoids containing bulky R(1) and R(2) groups were effective in this chemoprevention assay. (9Z)-RA displayed equal capacity as RA to prevent papillomas, while the 9Z-isomers of the UAB retinoids were much less effective. Taken together, these studies demonstrate that the cyclohexenyl ring substituents of 6-s-trans-UAB retinoids are important for their biological activities and that the chemopreventive effect of the all-E-isomers of these retinoids correlates well with their capacity to bind to RARs and activate RAR/RXR-mediated transcription.