Nuclear changes in necrotic HL-60 cells

Cell death in eukaryotes can occur by either apoptosis or necrosis. Apoptosis is characterized by well-defined nuclear changes which are thought to be the consequence of both proteolysis and DNA fragmentation. On the other hand, the nuclear modifications that occur during necrosis are largely less known. Here, we have investigated whether or not nuclear modifications occur during ethanol-induced necrotic cell death of HL-60 cells. By means of immunofluorescence staining, we demonstrate that the patterns given by antibodies directed against some nuclear proteins (lamin B1, NuMA, topoisomerase ll alpha, SC-35, B23/nucleophosmin) changed in necrotic cells. The changes in the spatial distribution of NuMA strongly resembled those described to occur during apoptosis. On the contrary, the fluorescent pattern characteristic for other nuclear proteins (C23/nucleolin, UBF, fibrillarin, RNA polymerase I) did not change during necrosis. By immunoblotting analysis, we observed that some nuclear proteins (SAF-A, SATB1, NuMA) were cleaved during necrosis, and in the case of SATB1, the apoptotic signature fragment of 70 kDa was also present to the same extent in necrotic samples. Caspase inhibitors did not prevent proteolytic cleavage of the aforementioned polypeptides during necrosis, while they were effective if apoptosis was induced. In contrast, lamin B1 and topoisomerase ll alpha were uncleaved in necrotic cells, whereas they were proteolyzed during apoptosis. Transmission electron microscopy analysis revealed that slight morphological changes were present in the nuclear matrix fraction prepared from necrotic cells. However, these modifications (mainly consisting of a rarefaction of the inner fibrogranular network) were not as striking as those we have previously described in apoptotic HL-60 cells. Taken together, our results indicate that during necrosis marked biochemical and morphological changes do occur at the nuclear level. These alterations are quite distinct from those known to take place during apoptosis. Our results identify additional biochemical and morphological criteria that could be used to discriminate between the two types of cell death. (C) 2001 Wiley-Liss Inc.